RAW RANKED SITES ABOUT
#STUDENTS BRITAIN

The most comprehensive list of students britain websites last updated on Nov 1 2019.
Stats collected from various trackers included with free apps.
1
Scroll.in - Latest News, In depth news, India news, Politics news, Indian Cinema, Indian sports, Culture, Video News Scroll.in is an independent website covering news, politics, sports, culture and everything in between. Get the latest news, reportage, analysis and commentary on all that matters in India and beyond.
2
The Manila Times Online | Home The Manila Times takes pride in being the country's oldest and longest-running English daily with a diverse opinion section and comprehensive coverage of the latest stories on politics, business, sports, entertainment, lifestyle and other issues of national global concern.
3
Bristol 24/7 | Bristol news, what's on, food and drink, lifestyle Bristol news, comprehensive what's on listings, reviews and special offers online, on mobile, in print - check out our monthly magazine
4
Estados Unidos - Revista Gerente Principales noticias de economía, finanzas, negocios. Todo lo que necesita saber un gerente en Estados Unidos.
5
International Education Consultant, Student Agency, Melbourne, Australia | StudyCo International Education Consultant, Student Agency, Melbourne, Australia | StudyCo . StudyCo is an international student education agency in Melbourne, Australia. Our student recruitment agency provides information about the study programs offered globally including bachelor, master, PhD and English programs. Also, you get free of charge admissions services. We are one of the trusted education agents in Australia.
6
UK travel and events. Work or study abroad in Britain. British culture and life. Study, work, live, travel in Britain (London/England, Wales, Scotland). Guide to British culture, traditions and events. UK student life for international students at university, college or language school. Learn English. Tours and tourist information.
7
The UK''s 15 National Parks. Visit and learn about Britain''s most inspiring areas of countryside. The home of the UK''s 15 National Parks - Britain''s breathing spaces. For visitors, for students, for anyone with a love of wide open skies.
8
BRIT POLITICS - All About British Politics and History Facts, quotes, speeches, news and analysis about British politics and history. For all ages, students and free to use.
9
Experts in studying in England, Scotland & Wales | Across the Pond Providing free expert advice to US students looking to study at some of the top best universities in Great Britain UK
10
Dancesport UK - Dance Shoes, Apparel, Equipment & Accessories Supplier Online Britain''s first and favourite site dedicated to Ballroom and Latin American dancing
11
LearnPick - Find Tutors in London, Manchester, Liverpool, UK - LearnPick LearnPick is Britain''s largest online platform helping students and learners find great tutors and teachers near their localities.
12
Learn More About IndoGenius - Start your application today! IndoGenius is India’s leading provider of short courses to international students with over 1,200 alumni from the UK, U.S., and Australia since 2011. You’ll leave India bursting with new ideas, experiences, and inspiration to help you carve out your future studies and career path.
13
THE TEEN MAGAZINE | An Online Magazine For Teens The Teen Magazine is an online magazine for teens covering all things lifestyle, beauty, fashion, health, academics, high school, and more...
15
History of Women Religious of Britain and Ireland – An international research network The History of Women Religious of Britain and Ireland (H-WRBI) is an international network that encourages research of women religious and makes available material to facilitate research.  We are broad in scope and time period covering the history of women religious from medieval to modern times. This international network includes  academics, archivists, students and many others…
16
Coletti Viola at the Colburn School of Music Paul Coletti, Colburn Viola faculty, Mr. Coletti currently is professor at the Colburn school in Los Angeles. At age 25 he was appointed Head of Strings at the University of Washington which made him the youngest Head of Strings in the world. Two years later he became professor at the Peabody Institute of Johns Hopkins University. Other positions include guest visiting professor at UMKC, Kansas City, and Head of Chamber Music at UCLA. He has given master classes internationally at the Guildhall School, London, the Chicago Institute, Toho school in Tokyo, the Shanghai Conservatory, Hans Eisler, Berlin, McGill, Northwestern , Rice, Baylor, Texas, Florida, Brigham Young, Colorado and Columbia University, and throughout Asia, South America, Europe and Australia. His students hold positions of prominence in every facet of the musical world. Additionally he has been a jury member of many international competitions such as the ARD in Munich, Max Rostal in Berlin, New York Young Concert Artists, and the 3rd International Violin competition in China, and the Primrose Competition. As a contestant he won top prizes at Naumberg, Tertis and at age 21 won the Golden Harp at the Belgrade Jeunnesse Musicale viola competition. Since then Coletti has won several prestigious awards with his wife Gina for their commitment to music education, including co-producing The Viola Show on public access television, and Viola Fest which each year brings together 120 young violists. The Colettis were honored in 2007 as Civic Honorees by the Los Angeles City Chambers. His compositions are performed worldwide and include Three Pieces for Viola and Piano published by Oxford University Press, Anima Mundi for viola and orchestra. He has also been editor of viola works by Rebecca Clarke for OUP. In 1997 ANA airlines, Japan, featured his chamber music on its in-flight entertainment. The ABRSM, Royal Schools of Music in Britain, offers From My Heart in its 2012-15 syllabus. Among the many composers who have written for him, most notable is the solo sonata of Michael Hersh, and Bruce Miller Viola Concerto which was nominated for a Pulitzer Prize. In 1994 Coletti started composing, innovating and performing on electric viola. This led to a music video Dreamocean that was filmed and produced on the Scottish Isles featuring narration by actor Leonard Nimoy. During the following decade he performed on pop CDs, in jazz clubs, in tango shows, and music videos, halls such as Avery Fisher in New York and clubs such as Dark Star, Sidewalk cafe, and the Knitting Factory, at Sony Plaza, the Grand Canyon, St Barths, and in 1998 on CNN, televised live from the Argentine consulate in New York.In addition to Menuhin and Lysy among his many teachers have been Sandor Vegh and Don McInnes, both to whom he was an assistant, Felix Galimir, Raphael Hillyer, Lillian Fuchs, William Lincer, Dorothy Delay, Felix Andriewsky, Johannes Eskar, Jimmy Durrant, Lorand Fenyves, Gyorgy Sebok, Anna Chumachenco, Janos Starker and Zoltan Szekely.
23
Britain International Academy Britain International Academy is an energetic and highly dynamic organization, formed by a team of professionals with a total cumulative experience of over 10 years in the field of education, Management, recruitment, marketing and IT, amongst others.
24
CCSU Apartments Off Campus Housing near Central Connecticut State University in New Britain CT CCSU Student Apartments Rentals and Housing Off Campus near Central Connecticut State University in New Britain, CT
25
Britain Gallery | UK Map | UK Places, Hotels, Travel, Shopping, Society | England Map. Britain guides, accommodation, hotels, consumer issues, society, economy, country, people, trends, topics of interest for travellers, students, local residents. England Map.
26
ACE Campus @ +91-9911232525 | Overseas Education Consultant In Delhi | GMAT Coaching In Delhi | GRE coaching In Delhi Paschim Vihar | TOEFL Coaching In Delhi Tilak Nagar | IELTS Coaching In Delhi | GRE Coaching In Delhi | SAT coaching In Delhi | Study In Abroad consultancy In Delhi | Study In Abroad consultancy In paschim vihar Delhi | Study In Abroad consultancy in tilak nagar Delhi Ace campus is providing world class consultancy and coaching for GMAT , GRE , IELTS , TOEFL , IELTS , SAT and Personality Development . Call us at 9911232525 . Students who want to study abroad may contact us . Ace campus is located in Paschim Vihar Delhi And Tilak Nagar Delhi . We are providing overseas education consultancy for Britain , USA , Australia , Singapore , Russia And many more
27
The Industrial Revolution in Great Britain (1750 - 1850) | How did Britain change in a century The Industrial Revolution in Great Britain took place roughly between 1750 and 1850. It was a process described as a series of changes in agriculture, industrial technology, and organization of labour, transport and business. As students of the English language, I hope that you will enjoy reading about this period, as it drastically transformed Britain…
28
Learn More About IndoGenius - Start your application today! IndoGenius is India’s leading provider of short courses to international students with over 1,200 alumni from the UK, U.S., and Australia since 2011. You’ll leave India bursting with new ideas, experiences, and inspiration to help you carve out your future studies and career path.
29
About-Britain.com a thematic guide to Britain A thematic guide to Britain for visitors and students, including tourism, cities and British life and institutions.
30
icas-Net | Health & Fitness At OU Medicine, our mission is leading well being care. Subspecialties embody electroencephalography , electromyography , evoked potential , nerve conduction research and polysomnography Generally these assessments are performed by techs with no medical diploma, however the interpretation of those assessments is done by a medical professional. There isn't any change in the high three of this 12 months's medicine subject rankings, with Harvard University , University of Oxford and College of Cambridge persevering with to provide the top medical doctors on this planet. Investigators on the Heart for Musculoskeletal Well being at IU Faculty of Medicine deal with the discovery and improvement of recent therapies for musculoskeletal disease. Should you wish to query the decision that has been made, please consult with Part 6 of the Code of Observe for Admission of Students to the College of Birmingham. In summary, all of these non-educational points are vital for preparation to check medicine and many can be thought-about at interview. Elective studies: Two months in the spring of the fourth yr are allotted to full-time studies of your personal selection, both in a division of the Medical School or at one other centre in Britain or, as nearly all of […]
32
LiverpoolMedics - Resource for Liverpool Medics - Students Studying Medicine in Liverpool UK LiverpoolMedics is an internet resource dedicated to medical education in the United Kingdom, provided by current Liverpool medical students - Liverpool Medics
33
BRIT POLITICS - All About British Politics and History Facts, quotes, speeches, news and analysis about British politics and history. For all ages, students and free to use.
34
Welcome to The Schorr Collection - a catalogue of Old Master and Nineteenth-Century Paintings The Schorr Collection, a privately held art collection with over 400 works of 15th century devotional images to 19th century French Impressionist landscapes created by Old Master artists ranging from Rubens, Turner, Delacroix, Cranach and Pissarro.
35
Welcome to StudyUnitedKingdom - StudyUnitedKingdom The United Kingdom (UK) is perfect for history and landscape loving students. Orientate yourself on a study in the UK, a short course via www.studyunitedkingdom.eu
37
Anglo-Russian Research Network The Anglo-Russian Research Network was founded in 2011 by Rebecca Beasley (Queen’s College, Oxford) and Matthew Taunton (UEA) to bring together scholars from a variety of disciplines, students and all those with an interest in cultural and intellectual relations between Britain and Russia in the period 1880-1950. The network supports a variety of activities, including…
38
Academy of the Marital Way At the Academy of the Martial Way Taekwondo Center in Flagstaff, our mission is to use martial arts to assist our students in successfully developing their minds, bodies, and character to their fullest potentials.
39
Home - Swisslimbs SwissLimbs is a Swiss not-for-profit organization based in Lugano. We accomplish initiatives in the public interest in Switzerland and abroad, in particular in the field of rehabilitation and ortho-prosthetic services, high-mobility artificial limbs for amputees and disabled people.
41
I Don't Call Myself a Poet | Interviews with Contemporary Poets Living & Working in Britain This project began with students of CMW1001: Introduction to Writing - Poetry at the University of Middlesex in Spring 2012. Students were each assigned to interview a poet, and collaborated in class on developing a pool of "burning questions." The initial project produced 68 interviews, but the site plans to grow! It was inspired by…
42
New Britain High School New Britain High School is a high school website for New Britain alumni. New Britain High provides school news, reunion and graduation information, alumni listings and more for former students and faculty of New Britain HS in New Britain, Connecticut
43
Home | Brooke House College Brooke House College is a co-educational, international boarding college, specialising in preparing students from all over the globe, and from Britain, for entrance to the most prestigious universities to which they can aspire in both the U.K. and U.S.A.
44
Paragon Kickboxing & Boxing Gym - Paragon Gym Kickboxing and boxing are rapidly becoming London''s top health and fitness activities. They inspire people of all shapes and sizes to boost their confidence, well-being and self-defence skills. The Paragon Gym in Shoreditch, Hackney is known for the relaxed and friendly environment in which it teaches these arts to the highest levels. Our teaching staff welcomes students from complete beginners, to elite experienced athletes.
45
Eire, Ireland, into, Irish schools, English schools, England, Education, UK, Britain, Study, University, Graduate,
46
STANLEY Tools, BOSTITCH Tools, RAI Technical Ltd RAI Technical Ltd Employment, Sales, Hire, Repair, Nottingham, United Kingdom
47
Bruntnell-Astley ltd Contemporary Glass Art & Crafts Gallery - Contemporary Glass Art Gallery: Bruntnell-Astley Ltd. Based in Stourbridge, the glassmaking heartland of Great Britain, our gallery features glass art from the finest names in contemporary glass 7 . From students to international names artists are exhibited on equal footing. With the nature of an online gallery this leads to saving & works can be shipped internationally.
48
Words About Words – A Literature blog compiled by the TCE students of Christ University, Bangalore This Blog, compiled and created by the TCE (Theatre, Communication and Media, English Studies) students of Christ University, Bangalore, is dedicated to the English writings of the many great authors of Britain/England and the world over. In the study of great writers (poets, playwrights, novelists, etc.)  and the understanding of them, the students and writers…
49
yoloportal.com offers Online Education in Pakistan, a career in counselling,a career in counselling psychology,a career in counselling uk,a report on career counselling,athabasca university career counselling,benefits of career counselling,brock university career counselling,career counselling,career counselling 10th std students,career counselling 2015,career counselling 34,career counselling a holistic approach,career counselling adelaide,career counselling after 10,career counselling after 10+2,career counselling after 10th,career counselling after 10th in mumbai,career counselling after 10th ppt,career counselling after 12th,career counselling after 12th commerce,career counselling after 12th ppt,career counselling after 12th science,career counselling after class x,career counselling after matric,career counselling ahmedabad,career counselling and guidance,career counselling app,career counselling at 40,career counselling at st xavier''s college mumbai,career counselling auckland,career counselling australia,career counselling bangalore,career counselling barrie,career counselling bhopal,career counselling board,career counselling board 2015,career counselling books,career counselling brampton,career counselling brisbane,career counselling bristol,career counselling burlington,career counselling business,career counselling calgary,career counselling canberra,career counselling cape town,career counselling certificate,career counselling chandigarh,career counselling chennai,career counselling class 10,career counselling class xi,career counselling courses,career counselling courses in india,career counselling courses in mumbai,career counselling courses online,career counselling dalhousie,career counselling definition,career counselling degree,career counselling delhi,career counselling description,career counselling diploma,career counselling dubai,career counselling dublin,career counselling durban,career counselling durham region,career counselling edinburgh,career counselling edmonton,career counselling edmonton free,career counselling education,career counselling email,career counselling engineering,career counselling ernakulam,career counselling essay,career counselling exam,career counselling experts,career counselling for 10th passed students,career counselling for 12th students,career counselling for class 8,career counselling for class 9,career counselling for class x students,career counselling for class x students ppt,career counselling for class xii,career counselling for high school students,career counselling for medical students,career counselling for o level students,career counselling for over 50,career counselling for school students ppt,career counselling for students,career counselling for students in pakistan,career counselling for students in pakistan ppt,career counselling for students online,career counselling for students ppt,career counselling for young adults,career counselling free,career counselling games,career counselling george brown,career counselling glasgow,career counselling goa,career counselling gold coast,career counselling government,career counselling guelph,career counselling guide,career counselling gurgaon,career counselling guwahati,career counselling halifax,career counselling hamilton,career counselling hamilton nz,career counselling helpline,career counselling high school students,career counselling hindi,career counselling hobart,career counselling hong kong,career counselling hyderabad,career counselling hyderabad turning point,career counselling in bangalore,career counselling in delhi,career counselling in indore,career counselling in islamabad,career counselling in karachi,career counselling in kolkata,career counselling in lahore,career counselling in pakistan,career counselling in sector 32 chandigarh,career counselling in thane,career counselling in the 21st century,career counselling in urdu,career counselling jabalpur,career counselling jaipur,career counselling jalandhar,career counselling jobs,career counselling jobs calgary,career counselling jobs in chennai,career counselling jobs in delhi,career counselling jobs melbourne,career counselling jobs singapore,career counselling jobs toronto,career counselling kamloops,career counselling kanpur,career counselling karachi,career counselling kelowna,career counselling kent,career counselling kerala,career counselling kingston ontario,career counselling kitchener,career counselling kolkata,career counselling kya hai,career counselling lahore,career counselling latrobe,career counselling leeds,career counselling lethbridge,career counselling live chat,career counselling logo,career counselling london,career counselling london ontario,career counselling lucknow,career counselling ludhiana,career counselling meaning,career counselling meaning in hindi,career counselling meaning in urdu,career counselling melbourne,career counselling melbourne free,career counselling melbourne reviews,career counselling models,career counselling moncton,career counselling montreal,career counselling mumbai,career counselling nagpur,career counselling nait,career counselling navi mumbai,career counselling near me,career counselling new york,career counselling new zealand,career counselling newcastle,career counselling noida,career counselling north vancouver,career counselling number,career counselling nyc,career counselling nz,career counselling oakville,career counselling online,career counselling online chat free,career counselling online course,career counselling online for students,career counselling online free,career counselling online free for students,career counselling online tests,career counselling oshawa,career counselling ottawa,career counselling pakistan,career counselling pdf,career counselling perth,career counselling portal,career counselling ppt,career counselling ppt after 10th,career counselling ppt after 12th,career counselling presentation,career counselling presentation 2011,career counselling process,career counselling pune,career counselling qualifications,career counselling questionnaire,career counselling questions,career counselling questions answers,career counselling questions for students,career counselling quiz,career counselling quiz free,career counselling quora,career counselling quotes,career counselling qut,career counselling raipur,career counselling ranchi,career counselling red deer,career counselling reddit,career counselling regina,career counselling report,career counselling report sample,career counselling resources,career counselling richmond,career counselling rmit,career counselling salary,career counselling seminar,career counselling services,career counselling session,career counselling session for class x students,career counselling singapore,career counselling sites,career counselling south australia,career counselling speech,career counselling st. john''s,career counselling sydney,career counselling techniques,career counselling test,career counselling test after 12th,career counselling test for class 9,career counselling test online,career counselling thane,career counselling theories,career counselling tips,career counselling tools,career counselling toronto,career counselling training,career counselling u of t,career counselling ubc,career counselling uk,career counselling unisa,career counselling uottawa,career counselling uq,career counselling usa,career counselling uvic,career counselling uwa,career counselling uwo,career counselling vadodara,career counselling vancouver,career counselling vancouver free,career counselling vashi,career counselling vaughan,career counselling vernon bc,career counselling victoria,career counselling victoria university,career counselling videos,career counselling videos in hindi,career counselling waterloo,career counselling waterloo ontario,career counselling websites,career counselling wellington,career counselling wellington new zealand,career counselling wikipedia,career counselling windsor,career counselling winnipeg,career counselling wollongong,career counselling worksheets,career counselling workshop,career counselling yarmouth,career counselling ymca,career counselling york region,career counselling yorkshire,career counselling yorkton,career counselling yorku,career counselling youth,career counselling youtube,career counselling zunker,career counselling zurich,careers360 counselling,carleton university career counselling,concordia university career counselling,dams career counselling 2015,dams career counselling 2016,flinders university career counselling,hindu career counselling 2015,ht career counselling 2015,i need career counselling,images of career counselling,importance of career counselling,importance of career counselling for school students,is a career in counselling good,is a career in counselling right for me,meaning of career counselling,monash university career counselling,nbt career counselling 2015,need of career counselling,objective of career counselling,ottawa u career counselling,phyl j career counselling,process of career counselling,scope of career counselling,starting a counselling career,stellenbosch university career counselling,theories of career counselling,u of l career counselling,u of m career counselling,u of r career counselling,u of s career counselling,u of t career counselling,u of w career counselling,university career counselling,1. e-learning,2 e learning heidelberg,2. e-learning,24/7 e learning,3 advantages of e learning,3 disadvantages of e-learning,3 e learning center,3 manfaat e-learning,3 minute e learning,3 peringkat e-learning,3e learning cycle,4 e learning cycle,4 e''s of learning humanities,4 levels of e learning,4 seasons e learning,4-door e-learning,4-e learning & prevention center inc,4-e learning and prevention center,4-h volunteer e-learning course,5 e learning sites,5 e learning websites,5e learning cycle,5e learning cycle model,5e learning cycle robert karplus,5e learning cycle template,5e learning model,6 e learning model,6 october university e learning,6 plataformas de e-learning,6 principles of e-learning,6 rules to designing e-learning for maximum motivation,6 sigma e-learning,6e learning cycle,7 city e learning,7 e''s learning cycle,7-eleven e-learning,7e learning model,7e learning model nsta,8 plataformas de e-learning,9 steps to better e-learning project management,a.c.e. learning center,a.g.e.s. learning solutions,aat level 2 elearning,ankieta o e-learningu,api-u e learning,appel d''offre e-learning,aqa gcse p.e learning grids questions,area 9 e-learning,at&t e-learning,b&q e-learning,b+r e learning,b-e learning,b-learning vs e-learning,b-learning y e-learning,b.e.s.t. learning center,bab 2 e-learning,bizsafe level 1 elearning,bp e & p learning center,c & e learning noli me tangere,c language e learning,c programming e learning,c programming e learning courses,c sharp e learning,c&e learning,c&k e-learning,c''est quoi le e-learning,c.a.r.e. learning centre bermuda,c.i.t.e learning styles inventory,c.i.t.e. learning styles,challenges with e-learning,channel 4 e-learning,chapter 8 e-learning and use of technology in training,co je e-learning,coffee 1 e learning,coloplast e3learning,control-m e-learning,cours d''anglais e learning,cours d''anglais e learning gratuit,d reizen e learning,dfd level 0 e-learning,drupal 7 e learning,drupal 8 e-learning,e & k learning center,e 4 learning,e b m u learning,e c learning academy,e e learning khipu,e e-learning bejaia,e e-learning iscte,e l learning style questionnaire,e l thorndike learning theory,e learning,e learning 02,e learning 101,e learning 108,e learning 10th class,e learning 123,e learning 12th,e learning 12th commerce,e learning 18+,e learning 1st standard,e learning 1st standard marathi,e learning 2 heidelberg,e learning 2.0,e learning 2015,e learning 2016,e learning 2017,e learning 2020,e learning 247,e learning 2nd std,e learning 3 insubria,e learning 3 unikl miat,e learning 360,e learning 3d animation,e learning 3ds max,e learning 3rd std,e learning 4 health,e learning 4 therapists,e learning 4 tourism,e learning 4 u,e learning 4 u umass,e learning 4 you,e learning 4.0,e learning 456,e learning 4th class,e learning 56,e learning 5th std,e learning 6 october,e learning 6 october university,e learning 626,e learning 6th class,e learning 7 eleven,e learning 7th class,e learning 8.unibg,e learning 81,e learning 8th class,e learning 8th class cbse,e learning 9 klasse,e learning 911,e learning 94,e learning 9th,e learning 9th class,e learning 9th class science,e learning adalah,e learning adamson,e learning advantages,e learning advantages and disadvantages ppt,e learning and blended learning,e learning app,e learning app by pgc,e learning app download,e learning apps for students,e learning auth,e learning benefits,e learning best buy,e learning bits,e learning book pdf,e learning books free download,e learning boots,e learning bue,e learning by pgc,e learning by pgc app,e learning by pgc registration,e learning cdsbeo,e learning center,e learning center free courses,e learning class 8,e learning class 9,e learning class v6 0 descargar,e learning cmc,e learning cmu,e learning commons,e learning companies,e learning companies in india,e learning compass,e learning courses,e learning d2l,e learning ddsb,e learning definition,e learning definition in urdu,e learning definition pdf,e learning definition ppt,e learning definition wikipedia,e learning development,e learning disadvantages,e learning drupal 7,e learning dsbn,e learning e health,e learning economics,e learning edge,e learning education,e learning embrace,e learning english,e learning essay,e learning eureka,e learning evaluation,e learning examples,e learning excel,e learning f gas,e learning f mipa,e learning f mipa um,e learning f y k,e learning farmfoods,e learning fmach,e learning for 9th class marathi medium,e learning for health,e learning for kids,e learning for schools,e learning foundation,e learning framework,e learning frederick,e learning free,e learning fyk,e learning games,e learning gateway,e learning gau,e learning gedsb,e learning gju,e learning govt of punjab,e learning gp,e learning grade 5,e learning grade 6,e learning grade 7,e learning grade 8,e learning grand erie,e learning gunadarma,e learning hbl,e learning hcdsb,e learning hct,e learning hcu,e learning hdsb,e learning help,e learning heroes,e learning holy quran,e learning hub,e learning icai,e learning icon,e learning in education,e learning in education ppt,e learning in hindi,e learning in india,e learning in pakistan,e learning in south africa,e learning industry,e learning institutes in pakistan,e learning iso 9001,e learning ja,e learning jaiib,e learning jamaica contact,e learning job description,e learning jobs,e learning johor,e learning journals,e learning ju,e learning just,e learning k 12 education,e learning k12,e learning kaplan,e learning kcbs,e learning kenya,e learning kfc,e learning kit,e learning kku,e learning kmph,e learning kuim,e learning kya hai,e learning labschool,e learning lakehead,e learning ldcsb,e learning ldsb,e learning libels,e learning lkdsb,e learning lms,e learning login,e learning logo,e learning là gì,e learning matrix,e learning meaning,e learning meaning and characteristics,e learning meaning in urdu,e learning minhaj ul quran,e learning monroe,e learning msa,e learning msu,e learning muic,e learning mzumbe,e learning navy,e learning ne kosove,e learning network,e learning nhs,e learning notes,e learning ntt,e learning nursing,e learning nust,e learning nz,e learning objectives,e learning ocdsb,e learning ocsb,e learning online,e learning ontario,e learning ontario ucdsb,e learning open source,e learning oracle,e learning ovgu,e learning oxford,e learning pakistan,e learning pdf,e learning pgc,e learning portal,e learning poste trackid=sp-006,e learning ppt,e learning program punjab,e learning project in php with source code,e learning punjab,e learning punjab 10th class,e learning punjab 9th class,e learning qantas,e learning qassim,e learning qualifications,e learning que es,e learning questions,e learning quiz,e learning quora,e learning quotes,e learning quran,e learning rcdsb,e learning research,e learning resources,e learning riinvest,e learning rmutl,e learning rsu,e learning ru,e learning runwood,e learning sbi,e learning school,e learning services,e learning sites online education,e learning slideshare,e learning sma 59,e learning sman 6 malang,e learning survey questionnaire,e learning synonyms,e learning system,e learning system project documentation,e learning tanuvas,e learning tarc,e learning tcdsb,e learning tdsb,e learning tesco,e learning thesis research paper,e learning tools,e learning tools examples,e learning trackid=sp-006,e learning tvdsb,e learning types,e learning uf,e learning ukcbc,e learning unam,e learning unisel,e learning unp,e learning unpam,e learning usm,e learning utm,e learning utp,e learning vector,e learning vet,e learning video,e learning viettel,e learning vnpt,e learning vodacom,e learning voice over,e learning voice over rates,e learning vs traditional learning essay,e learning vtu,e learning wales,e learning website templates,e learning website templates free download,e learning websites,e learning websites for computer courses,e learning wikipedia,e learning wits,e learning wmu,e learning wrdsb,e learning wu,e learning x console,e learning x ray,e learning x.4-6,e learning xconsole,e learning xerox,e learning xl,e learning xml,e learning xrh unipi,e learning xu,e learning xxi banorte,e learning ycdsb,e learning yic,e learning ymca,e learning yorku,e learning young drivers,e learning youngs,e learning youtube,e learning yrdsb,e learning zambia,e learning zeiss,e learning zone,e learning zone hampshire county council,e learning zone pizza hut,e learning zone uum,e learning zu,e learning zuellig pharma,e learning zuj,e modules e learning,e uhl e learning,e&l learning style,e&p learning place,e&p learning place review,e-e learning,e-la e learning anaesthesia,e-learning 06 congressi,e-learning 1.0,e-learning 2014,e-learning 24/7,e-learning 24/7 blog,e-learning 3.0 and 4.0,e-learning 3.0 pdf,e-learning 3d,e-learning 3dn,e-learning 4-6,e-learning 6,e-learning 6 sigma,e-learning 70 20 10,e-learning 81/08,e-learning 85,e-learning 8nv,e-learning 8nvvtwi,e-learning class 7,e-learning e-training,e-learning ge industrial,e-learning grade 9 diagnostic test,e-learning je,e-learning ne demek,e-learning ne shqiperi,e-learning r,e-learning section 508,e-learning shell 02,e-learning v podnikovém vzdelávání,e-learning v ceské republice,e-learning x.4,e-learning x.5,e-learning xaverius 1,e-learning xavier,e-learning z certyfikatem za darmo,e-z learning driving school,e-z learning driving school arlington va,e-z learning driving school inc,ead x e-learning,elearning .u.j,elearning 4 tarc,elearning 68,elearning for you,elearning guild,elearning high noon,elearning jsmu,elearning network rail,elearning nuh,elearning qudent,elearning rah,elearning rama,elearning utd,elearning yds,elearning yu,elearning yum,elearning zimbabwe,element k learning,experience with e-learning,f.l.e.x. learning program,g-cube e-learning,g.e.d accommodations for learning disabilities,gd&t e-learning,ge healthcare e learning,ge learning.ge.com,ge mark 6 e learning,grade 9 e-learning exams,grade 9 e-learning exams 2013,h and e learning,h e-learning,h&m e learning,h&m e learning guide,h&m grow e learning,h&s e-learning,h.e.l.p. learning center,h.o.p.e. learning and therapy center,hc 1 e learning,helmo.be e-learning,help 2 e learning,html5 elearning,ifrs 9 deloitte e learning,ifrs 9 e learning,institut d''assurance e learning,issues with e learning,j e denson learning center,j e i learning center,j&e learning centre,j&j e-learning,k-12 e-learning,k-instituutti e-learning,k.u e learning portal,klas 2 e learning,ksiazki e learningu,l&t e-learning,l''e-learning,l''e-learning a scuola,l''e-learning en france,l''e-learning une solution pour votre entreprise,learning with e-learning tools,level 1 e learning definition,level 1 elearning,level 2 e learning course,level 3 e learning,link 2 e learning,m and k learning,m and s learning,m tech e learning,m&b e learning,m&e learning center,m-learning versus e-learning,m-learning vs e-learning,m.e.g (e-learning),m.s.u e learning,marc j. rosenberg e-learning,mayer r. e. multimedia learning,me e learning,moodle-2.0-e-learning-course-development,n & e learning llc,n s toor e learning,n&e learning,ncalt e learning,nec3 e-learning,nhs p e learning,o level e learning,o q significa e learning,o q é e-learning,o que e-learning,o que significa e-learning,o que é e-learning nas empresas,o/e learning,o/e learning inc,objective c learning,offre d''emploi e-learning,p&g e-learning,p.e 10 learning materials,p.e learning objectives,p.e stages of learning,p.r.y.d.e. learning centres inc,para q sirve e-learning,paris 8 e learning,pio x e learning,pitfalls with e-learning,plateforme e-learning,prince2 e learning,pro9 e learning,problems with e learning,problems with e-learning systems,q learning e greedy,q significa e learning,q& s e-learning,q-das e learning,qe es e-learning,qhotels e learning,r programming e learning,r.e. mcnair discovery learning academy,re-thinking e-learning research foundations methods and practices,s chand e learning,s chand e learning noida,s i e learning,s.e.e.k. early learning center,s.o.l.e. learning,s.t josephs elearning centre,safeguarding level 1 elearning,sap r/3 e-learning,sas programming 1 e-learning,sbi e learning,schools with e-learning,scout training module 1 e learning,slavin r.e. cooperative learning,sman 1 sidoarjo e-learning,ssmg.be e-learning,sta je e-learning,storyline 2 elearning,studio k e learning,subsea 7 elearning,subsea 7 elearning login,swiss re e learning,szkolenie z e-learningu,t mobile e learning,t.h.e. creative learning,t.h.e. creative learning programs ltd,t.l.e learning module,tally 9 e learning,tally.erp 9 e-learning package download,tanuvas e learning 8th sem,tanuvas e learning 8th semester,togaf 9 e learning,top 5 e learning authoring tools,top 5 e learning companies in india,top 5 e-learning software,toys r us e learning,trendy v e-learningu,u e learning centre,u of e learning,u of e learning certificate,u of t e learning,u-learning vs. e-learning,uf e e learning,universities with e-learning,usyd elearning,v corsi e learning,v oblakoch e learning,v t u e learning,v t u learning,v u learning,v&vn e-learning,v-markt e-learning,vtu e learning 5th sem civil,vtu e learning 5th sem civil notes,vtu e learning 5th sem notes,vtu e learning 6th sem notes,vtu e learning 7th sem notes,w.e. phillips learning academy,what s e-learning,windows 7 e learning courses,windows 8 microsoft e-learning,wszystko o e learningu,wszystko o e-learning,www.buddhanet/e-learning/5minbud.htm,x-cell e-learning,x-rite e learning,z academy elearning,z energy academy e learning,z energy e learning,z/os mainframe programming e-learning bundle,što je e learning,3f fit for future,chloe hampson fit for future,clarence valley council fit for future,education fit for the future,fit 2 future,fit 4 future bern,fit 4 future brasov,fit 4 future braunschweig,fit 4 future camps,fit 4 future personal training,fit 4 future schweiz,fit 4 future spieltonne,fit 4 future wroclaw,fit 4 future zug,fit for future,fit for future 2013,fit for future 2015,fit for future 2015 brasov,fit for future 2016,fit for future 2016 brasov,fit for future allianz,fit for future announcement,fit for future at,fit for future barnsley,fit for future basel,fit for future benchmarks,fit for future canterbury,fit for future consultants,fit for future council amalgamations,fit for future criteria,fit for future csp,fit for future definition,fit for future e.v,fit for future e.v. hagen,fit for future e.v. hamm,fit for future gmp,fit for future gstt,fit for future guidelines,fit for future hagen,fit for future ipart,fit for future ipart report,fit for future jobs,fit for future jyllinge,fit for future klagenfurt,fit for future kongress,fit for future kraków,fit for future leaflet,fit for future lehrbetriebe schaffen zukunft,fit for future lillie eberhard,fit for future local government,fit for future logo,fit for future map,fit for future mohawk college,fit for future network,fit for future news,fit for future nhs,fit for future nsw,fit for future pogp,fit for future program,fit for future programme,fit for future ratios,fit for future reforms,fit for future report,fit for future ryde,fit for future st margaret''s hospice,fit for future st margarets,fit for future stations,fit for future strategy,fit for future submissions,fit for future synonym,fit for future template 2,fit for future tfl,fit for future the pharmaceutical industry in europe 2020,fit for future villingen,fit for future zingst,fit for future zug,fit for future zürich,fit for less future locations,fit for the digital future,fit for the future,fit for the future 7 benchmarks,fit for the future a review of the public health workforce,fit for the future a roadmap,fit for the future aberdeen,fit for the future age uk,fit for the future assessment,fit for the future auburn,fit for the future bankstown,fit for the future birmingham,fit for the future blueprint,fit for the future bootcamp,fit for the future boundaries,fit for the future business,fit for the future capitalising on global trends,fit for the future carlsberg,fit for the future clarence valley,fit for the future conference,fit for the future conference 2015,fit for the future council report,fit for the future criteria,fit for the future dates,fit for the future deadline,fit for the future december 2015,fit for the future decision,fit for the future department of health,fit for the future dr foster,fit for the future dubbo,fit for the future duncan green,fit for the future efa,fit for the future eurobodalla,fit for the future evaluation,fit for the future event,fit for the future exercise,fit for the future facebook,fit for the future faq,fit for the future far west initiative,fit for the future final report,fit for the future findings,fit for the future funding,fit for the future gosford,fit for the future government response,fit for the future hemsley fraser,fit for the future hornsby,fit for the future hospice,fit for the future hurstville,fit for the future ibm,fit for the future improvement plan,fit for the future improvement proposal,fit for the future in european gastroenterology,fit for the future incentives,fit for the future innovation fund,fit for the future inquiry,fit for the future ipart,fit for the future iriss,fit for the future jeanette winterson,fit for the future jersey,fit for the future joint organisations,fit for the future keith jones,fit for the future key dates,fit for the future kiama,fit for the future kpmg,fit for the future lake macquarie,fit for the future latest news,fit for the future list,fit for the future liverpool,fit for the future london,fit for the future london underground,fit for the future marrickville,fit for the future mckinsey,fit for the future meaning,fit for the future media,fit for the future mergers,fit for the future methodology,fit for the future ministerial advisory group,fit for the future national trust,fit for the future network,fit for the future newport,fit for the future news,fit for the future newsletter,fit for the future nhs,fit for the future nomura,fit for the future northern ireland,fit for the future nsw,fit for the future nz,fit for the future october 2015,fit for the future olg,fit for the future one stop shop,fit for the future options,fit for the future origin,fit for the future outcomes,fit for the future oxfam,fit for the future palliative care conference,fit for the future parliamentary inquiry,fit for the future pdf,fit for the future postnatal,fit for the future progress report,fit for the future project,fit for the future proposals,fit for the future queanbeyan,fit for the future quotes,fit for the future randwick,fit for the future report,fit for the future results,fit for the future review,fit for the future roadmap,fit for the future rural council,fit for the future self assessment tool,fit for the future smh,fit for the future social enterprise,fit for the future station groups,fit for the future sydney,fit for the future template 1,fit for the future template 3,fit for the future the court report 1976,fit for the future unfit,fit for the future update,fit for the future wakool,fit for the future warringah,fit for the future website,fit for the future what is it,fit for the future willoughby,fit for the future winchester,fit for the future winterson,fit for the future wyong,fit for the future yass,fit for the future zwickau,fit for your future,fit for your future boston,fit future fun run,fit future improvement technology foundation,fit future kassel,fit future of fashion,fit future of fashion show 2014,fit or future,fit your future nauta,fit-4-future activity day zug,future feet auckland,future shop fitbit,homes fit for the future,ihk karlsruhe fit for future,ipart fit for future report,ipart fit for the future final report,iwona kirstein fit for future,junee fit for the future,k+s fit for the future,m&s fit for the future,template 2 fit for the future,unfit for future,usu fit for the future,volksbank pforzheim fit for future,willoughby council fit for future,yass valley council fit for future,zvei fit for the future,comparacion entre ielts y toefl,comparação ielts e toefl,costo ielts e toefl,diferencia ielts y toefl,difference between ielts toefl gre,durata ielts e toefl,equivalencia de ielts or toefl,equivalencia entre ielts y toefl,equivalencia entre ielts y toefl ibt,equivalencia ielts e toefl,equivalencia ielts y toefl,examen ielts y toefl,ielts & toefl made easy by george john,ielts & toefl made easy pdf,ielts 4 toefl,ielts 4.0 toefl,ielts 4.5 toefl,ielts 5 setara toefl,ielts 5 toefl equivalent,ielts 5 toefl ibt,ielts 5.5 toefl,ielts 6 0 toefl,ielts 6 or toefl 83,ielts 6 setara dengan toefl,ielts 6 setara toefl,ielts 6 toefl,ielts 6 toefl karsiligi,ielts 6 vs toefl,ielts 6.0 toefl 550,ielts 6.0 toefl 80,ielts 6.5 or toefl 80,ielts 6.5 toefl 90,ielts 6.5 toefl karsiligi,ielts 6.5 toefl pbt,ielts 7 sama dengan toefl,ielts 7 setara toefl,ielts 7 toefl 100,ielts 7 vs toefl 100,ielts 7.5 toefl equivalent,ielts 7.5 toefl ibt,ielts 8 toefl equivalent,ielts a toefl,ielts and toefl made easy,ielts and toefl made easy by george john pdf,ielts and toefl pbt score comparison,ielts and toefl score comparison,ielts and toefl which is easier,ielts atau toefl ibt,ielts comparison with toefl,ielts e toefl,ielts e toefl cosa sono,ielts e toefl differenze,ielts en toefl,ielts equivalent toefl 550,ielts hay toefl,ielts i toefl,ielts ili toefl,ielts in toefl,ielts khác toefl nhu th? nào,ielts level 7 toefl,ielts mi kolay toefl mi,ielts mi zor toefl mi,ielts n toefl,ielts o toefl,ielts o toefl cual es mejor,ielts o toefl differenze,ielts o toefl difficoltà,ielts o toefl ibt,ielts o toefl mas facil,ielts o toefl migliore,ielts o toefl per lavoro,ielts o toefl più facile,ielts o toefl yahoo,ielts or toefl,ielts or toefl for canada,ielts or toefl for usa,ielts or toefl in canada,ielts or toefl is easier,ielts or toefl which is better for usa,ielts or toefl which is easier,ielts or toefl which is easy,ielts or toefl which is harder,ielts or toefl yahoo answers,ielts to toefl,ielts to toefl conversion,ielts toefl,ielts toefl 6.5,ielts toefl adalah,ielts toefl and,ielts toefl and sat,ielts toefl and toeic,ielts toefl australia,ielts toefl band score,ielts toefl better,ielts toefl calculator,ielts toefl cambridge,ielts toefl cefr,ielts toefl classes in thane,ielts toefl coaching indore,ielts toefl comparison british council,ielts toefl comparison writing,ielts toefl conversion,ielts toefl correlation,ielts toefl course,ielts toefl denklik,ielts toefl denkligi,ielts toefl difference,ielts toefl difficulty,ielts toefl easier,ielts toefl easy,ielts toefl equality table,ielts toefl equivalency,ielts toefl exam,ielts toefl farki,ielts toefl gre,ielts toefl gre gmat sat,ielts toefl hangisi daha zor,ielts toefl hangisi kolay,ielts toefl harder,ielts toefl ibt,ielts toefl ibt speaking test,ielts toefl itp,ielts toefl karsilastirmasi,ielts toefl karsiligi,ielts toefl made easy book,ielts toefl made easy free download,ielts toefl made easy george john,ielts toefl meaning,ielts toefl more difficult,ielts toefl nedir,ielts toefl or cae,ielts toefl or cambridge,ielts toefl or gre,ielts toefl or pte,ielts toefl or toeic,ielts toefl pantip,ielts toefl paper based comparison,ielts toefl pbt score comparison,ielts toefl pearson comparison,ielts toefl practice test,ielts toefl preparation,ielts toefl pte,ielts toefl pte comparison,ielts toefl pte score comparison,ielts toefl puan denkligi,ielts toefl puan karsilastirmasi,ielts toefl sat,ielts toefl sat gre gmat,ielts toefl scale,ielts toefl score,ielts toefl score conversion,ielts toefl tehran,ielts toefl test online,ielts toefl toeic,ielts toefl toeic comparison,ielts toefl toeic difference,ielts toefl umrechnung,ielts toefl unterschied,ielts toefl validity,ielts toefl vk,ielts toefl vocabulary,ielts toefl what the difference,ielts toefl which is easier,ielts toefl yds,ielts toefl yds denklik,ielts v toefl,ielts ve toefl nedir,ielts versus toefl,ielts vs toefl,ielts vs toefl acceptance,ielts vs toefl comparison,ielts vs toefl difficulty,ielts vs toefl for canada,ielts vs toefl for usa,ielts vs toefl ibt,ielts vs toefl ibt difficulty,ielts vs toefl pantip,ielts vs toefl score,ielts vs toefl usa,ielts vs toefl which is easier,ielts x toefl,ielts y toefl,ielts yds toefl denklik tablosu,ielts yoxsa toefl,konversi ielts ke toefl,perbedaan ielts dan toefl,pontuação ielts e toefl,preço ielts e toefl,punteggio ielts e toefl,que es ielts and toefl,toefl ielts hangisi zor,toefl ielts results compared,toefl ielts which is easy,toefl or ielts,toefl v ielts,toeic toefl ielts score comparison,way 2 ielts toefl,yds lys 5 toefl ielts forum,0 que mentoring,1 day mentoring course,1-1 mentoring,1-2-1 mentoring,1-2-1 mentoring jersey,2 way mentoring,2011 mentoring minds.com level 5,2015 mentoring conference,2016 mentoring summit,3 creek mentoring,3 mentoring goals,3 mentoring methods,3 principles mentoring,3 stars mentoring,3 stars mentoring inc,30 mentoring,360 mentoring program,3degrees mentoring,3g mentoring,3m mentoring program,4 h mentoring weekend,4-h mentoring,4-h mentoring utah county,5 c''s mentoring model,5 mentoring skills,5 phase mentoring relationship model,5 stages of mentoring,5 step mentoring process,5-phase mentoring model,5c mentoring model,7 steps of mentoring,7x7 mentoring salon,8 pillars of mentoring,8 schilde mentoring,8 shields mentoring,8a mentoring,99 mentoring fragen,a mentoring agreement,a mentoring contract,a mentoring course on smalltalk,a mentoring framework,a mentoring moment,a mentoring plan,a mentoring program,a mentoring relationship,a mentoring system,a mentoring teacher,a to z mentoring,art of mentoring 8 shields,at&t mentoring program,b braun mentoring,b braun mentoring programm,b braun stiftung mentoring,b-men mentoring,b4nny 6v6 mentoring,c-me mentoring foundation trust,c-me mentoring trust,cal u mentoring,coach x mentoring,coaching and mentoring,coaching i mentoring eric parsloe,coaching i mentoring pdf,coaching i mentoring wikipedia,coaching o r mentoring,coaching vs mentoring,coaching x mentoring e counseling,como surgiu o mentoring,d/s mentoring,day 1 mentoring,definition mentoring vs coaching,diablo 3 mentoring,difference b w mentoring and coaching,dota 2 mentoring,e mentoring africa,e mentoring brightside,e mentoring for student success,e mentoring nottingham,e mentoring pro,e mentoring programs,e mentoring realising opportunities,e mentoring sheffield,e mentoring software,e mentoring warwick,everquest 1 mentoring,everquest 2 mentoring,ey mentoring,fox 5 mentoring monday,g force mentoring program,g star model mentoring,g12 mentoring,gen y mentoring,gen y mentoring program,generation x mentoring,generation z mentoring,guild wars 2 mentoring,gw2 mentoring,heroes 5 mentoring,heroes 6 mentoring,heroes v mentoring,hsg mentoring,i am mentoring program,i mentoring him,i-983 mentoring and training plan,inspire u mentoring,j m mentoring,k award mentoring plan,k+ mentoring,korzysci z mentoringu,ksiazki o mentoringu,launch u mentoring,level 1 mentoring,level 1 mentoring courses,level 2 mentoring course,level 3 mentoring,level 3 mentoring courses in birmingham,level 5 mentoring,level 6 mentoring,lineage 2 mentoring,lineage 2 mentoring system,m&m mentoring uclan,m_olives mentoring consultants,mach 1 mentoring,me2 mentoring,mentor i mentoring,mentoring,mentoring 101,mentoring 101 book,mentoring 101 john c maxwell pdf,mentoring 101 john maxwell pdf,mentoring 101 john maxwell summary,mentoring 101 pdf,mentoring 101 ron proctor,mentoring 101 train the trainer curriculum,mentoring 101 training curriculum,mentoring 1on1,mentoring 2 manhood,mentoring 2.0,mentoring 2013,mentoring 2014,mentoring 2015,mentoring 2016,mentoring 2017,mentoring 3 stage model,mentoring 360,mentoring 3rd grader,mentoring 4 georgia,mentoring 4 growth,mentoring 4 reading achievement,mentoring 4 stages,mentoring 4 success,mentoring 4 success kansas,mentoring 418.pdf,mentoring 436.pdf,mentoring 50+,mentoring 501c3,mentoring 5th graders,mentoring 6th graders,mentoring 98,mentoring academy,mentoring activities,mentoring adalah,mentoring agreement,mentoring an 8 year old,mentoring and befriending foundation,mentoring and coaching,mentoring and coaching definicion,mentoring and coaching in the workplace,mentoring and the 6cs,mentoring app,mentoring articles,mentoring at work,mentoring beginning teachers,mentoring benefits,mentoring best practices,mentoring bible verse,mentoring black youth,mentoring blogs,mentoring books,mentoring boundaries,mentoring britain,mentoring business,mentoring c''est quoi,mentoring central,mentoring checklist,mentoring circles,mentoring clipart,mentoring coaching,mentoring college students,mentoring conference,mentoring contract,mentoring courses,mentoring curriculum,mentoring day,mentoring def,mentoring definicion,mentoring definition,mentoring definition business,mentoring definition cipd,mentoring development plan,mentoring dfw,mentoring disadvantaged youth,mentoring do''s and don''ts,mentoring doe,mentoring education,mentoring employees,mentoring en español,mentoring entrepreneurs,mentoring evaluation,mentoring evaluation form,mentoring examples,mentoring exercises,mentoring expectations,mentoring experience,mentoring facts,mentoring fb 09,mentoring feedback,mentoring fees,mentoring for free,mentoring for growth,mentoring for success,mentoring forms,mentoring fortune 500 companies,mentoring foster youth,mentoring foundation,mentoring framework,mentoring games,mentoring gardens,mentoring goals,mentoring goals examples,mentoring graduate students,mentoring grants,mentoring graphics,mentoring group,mentoring guide,mentoring guidelines,mentoring handbook,mentoring handbook template,mentoring hbr,mentoring hessen,mentoring high school students,mentoring history,mentoring hours,mentoring how to,mentoring hub,mentoring humor,mentoring i coaching,mentoring i do you watch,mentoring i tutoring,mentoring icon,mentoring images,mentoring in education,mentoring in hrm,mentoring in medicine,mentoring in nursing,mentoring in schools,mentoring in spanish,mentoring in the bible,mentoring in the workplace,mentoring job description,mentoring jobs,mentoring jobs birmingham,mentoring jobs in schools,mentoring jobs london,mentoring jobs near me,mentoring jokes,mentoring journal,mentoring junior engineers,mentoring junior staff,mentoring karir,mentoring kcl,mentoring kent,mentoring key points,mentoring keywords,mentoring kick off ideas,mentoring kit,mentoring knowledge transfer,mentoring knoxville tn,mentoring kpi,mentoring leaders,mentoring leadership,mentoring leadership style,mentoring letter,mentoring log,mentoring log template,mentoring logo,mentoring london,mentoring lunch,mentoring là gì,mentoring matters,mentoring meaning,mentoring meaning in english,mentoring meaning in hindi,mentoring meaning in tamil,mentoring meaning in urdu,mentoring minds,mentoring minds 5th grade math,mentoring minds 5th grade reading,mentoring minds 5th grade science,mentoring minds level 5 math answer key,mentoring minds level 6,mentoring minds level 6 answers,mentoring minds level 7,mentoring minds level 7 answer key,mentoring minds level 7 answers,mentoring minds level 8 answer key,mentoring minds level 8 science,mentoring minds online,mentoring minds.c,mentoring models,mentoring moments,mentoring network,mentoring new employees,mentoring new nurses,mentoring new teachers,mentoring new teachers checklist,mentoring nursing,mentoring nursing and healthcare students,mentoring nursing students,mentoring nyc,mentoring nz,mentoring o coaching,mentoring o que esperar,mentoring o que faz,mentoring o que é,mentoring objectives,mentoring of students,mentoring online,mentoring online islamabad,mentoring opportunities,mentoring or coaching,mentoring or mentorship,mentoring organizations,mentoring others,mentoring outcomes,mentoring pdf,mentoring plan,mentoring ppt,mentoring process,mentoring program outline,mentoring programme,mentoring programs,mentoring programs for youth,mentoring programs in the workplace,mentoring pronunciation,mentoring q es,mentoring qualifications,mentoring qualifications uk,mentoring qualities,mentoring questionnaire,mentoring questions,mentoring questions for mentee,mentoring quiz,mentoring quotes,mentoring quotes bible,mentoring quotes for business,mentoring relationships,mentoring report,mentoring report sample,mentoring research,mentoring resources,mentoring responsibilities,mentoring resume,mentoring revelation online,mentoring rmit,mentoring role,mentoring rwth fakultät 7,mentoring s.r.l,mentoring scheme,mentoring session,mentoring skills,mentoring slideshare,mentoring software,mentoring statistics,mentoring students,mentoring styles,mentoring synonym,mentoring system,mentoring t shirt ideas,mentoring t shirts,mentoring teachers,mentoring teachers in schools,mentoring techniques,mentoring theory,mentoring thesaurus,mentoring tips,mentoring tools,mentoring topics,mentoring training,mentoring training course,mentoring u bih,mentoring u sad,mentoring uk,mentoring undergraduate research,mentoring undergraduate students,mentoring unimelb,mentoring university,mentoring university students,mentoring up,mentoring uph,mentoring usa,mentoring usmc,mentoring v coaching,mentoring v counselling,mentoring v materské škole,mentoring v ošetrovatelství,mentoring v praxi,mentoring v sociální práci,mentoring v ucitelství,mentoring viable prospects,mentoring videos,mentoring visit form,mentoring volunteering,mentoring vs coaching,mentoring vs mentorship,mentoring vs supervision,mentoring vs teaching,mentoring vs training,mentoring vs tutoring,mentoring w biznesie,mentoring w dzialaniu,mentoring w dzialaniu przewodnik praktyczny,mentoring w edukacji,mentoring w firmie,mentoring w miejscu pracy,mentoring w organizacji,mentoring w polsce,mentoring websites,mentoring west midlands,mentoring wikipedia,mentoring women''s network,mentoring workplace,mentoring works,mentoring works washington,mentoring worksheets,mentoring workshop,mentoring workshop activities,mentoring x coaching,mentoring xenoverse,mentoring y coaching,mentoring y coaching beatriz valderrama,mentoring y coaching pdf,mentoring y liderazgo,mentoring year 7 students,mentoring year 9,mentoring young adults,mentoring young minds,mentoring young offenders,mentoring young person,mentoring your successor,mentoring youth,mentoring youth in foster care,mentoring youth programs,mentoring youth quotes,mentoring youtube,mentoring zachary,mentoring zacínajících ucitelu,mentoring zfh,mentoring zhaw,mentoring ziele,mentoring ziele mentee,mentoring zimbabwe,mentoring zitate,mentoring znaczenie,mentoring zürich,mentoring_417,mentoring_429,mentoringprogramm b.braun stiftung,o que eh mentoring,o que mentoring,p&g mentoring program,p&g reverse mentoring,p.i.t. mentoring,plan m mentoring uni bremen,plus 1 mentoring,price b mentoring learners in practice,program mentoringu w firmie,project k mentoring,q es el mentoring,r&d mentoring,reverse mentoring c''est quoi,reverse mentoring l,reverse mentoring l''oréal,sammy d mentoring,sims 4 mentoring,sims 4 mentoring child,sims 4 mentoring fitness,sponsorship vs mentoring,studia podyplomowe z mentoringu,szkolenia z mentoringu,szkolenie z mentoringu,top 5 mentoring questions,u of t mentoring program,ua&p mentoring,uchicago law mentoring program,uottawa mentoring,uwindsor mentoring,valore d mentoring,what is mentoring,wszystko o mentoringu,x factor judges mentoring 2015,x factor mentoring,x factor whos mentoring who 2015,x-company mentoring,x-mentoring rhein ruhr,xavier mentoring program,xl mentoring,xl mentoring grimsby,xlp mentoring,xlp mentoring lewisham,xlp mentoring scheme,xlp mentoring training,xtreme mentoring,y mentoring perth,y-now mentoring program,year 6 mentoring,year 9 mentoring,youtube mentoring,0 level maths past papers,0 level past papers,0/l past papers,3247 past papers,387 past papers,4365 past papers,4eao past papers,4ma0 past papers,4u past papers,5014 past papers,512 past papers,6ar01 past papers,6bio1 past papers,6ch01 past papers,7+ past papers,7100 past papers,8+ past papers,9 past papers,9 past papers 2016,a level past papers,a level past papers accounting,a level past papers biology,a level past papers chemistry,a level past papers economics,a level past papers edexcel,a level past papers maths,a level past papers maths edexcel,a level past papers physics,a past papers,a&p past papers,a/l past papers,a/l past papers 2014,a/l past papers 2015,acca f9 past papers,acca p past papers,aiou past papers f.a,aku eb past papers x,amc 8 past papers,aqa 4365f past papers,aqa as past papers,aqa biology past papers g,aqa c past papers,aqa d&t past papers,aqa past papers,aqa past papers biology,aqa past papers chemistry,aqa past papers english,aqa past papers g,aqa past papers geography,aqa past papers maths,aqa past papers physics,aqa past papers psychology,aqa past papers science,aqa past papers spanish,aqa physics past papers g,be.d past papers,botany c past papers,botany d past papers,bs.c past papers,buss 2 past papers,buss1 past papers,buss3 past papers,c past papers,c&g past papers,c.s.s past papers,c.x.c past papers,ccea r.e past papers,chemistry 1 past papers,class 8 past papers,class 9 past papers,comedk past papers,core 3 past papers,core 4 past papers,cpa u past papers,cxc f&n past papers,d&t past papers,d.com english past papers,d.com past papers 2013,d.com past papers 2014,d.com past papers lahore board,e past papers,econ 2 past papers,econ 3 past papers,edexcel c past papers,edexcel c2 as past papers,edexcel d&t past papers,edexcel maths past papers h,edexcel p.e past papers,edexcel past papers g,edexcel r.e past papers,edexcel r.s past papers,edexcel re past papers,edexcel s past papers,edinburgh u past papers,english b past papers,exam p past papers,extreme past papers,f gas past papers,f past papers,f.a past papers gujranwala board,f.sc math past papers,f.sc past papers,f7 past papers,g & l past papers,g sat exam past papers,g.a.q. past papers,gat c past papers,gce o/l past papers,gcse b past papers,gcse p.e past papers,gcse past papers,gmat past papers,grade 4 past papers,grade 5 past papers,grade 6 past papers,grade 7 past papers,grade 8 past papers,grade 9 pastpapers,grade r past papers,gsat past papers,h physics past papers,h.s.c past papers,hsk 3 past papers,hsk 4 past papers,i c m past papers,i com past papers federal board,i com past papers lahore board,i edexcel past papers,i gcse past papers english,i law past papers,i to b past papers,i.c.t past papers,i.com past papers,i.com past papers 2014,i.com past papers 2015,i.com past papers bise lahore,i.t past papers,ib b&m past papers,ict a/l past papers,ise 0 past papers,islamiat past papers o level,itec a&p past papers,j whitney past papers,k stage 2 past papers,k.i.m past papers,k.u past exam papers,k.u past papers,l.o past papers,london a/l past papers,m.a economics past papers,m.a english past papers,m.a history past papers,m.a islamiat past papers,m.a urdu past papers,m.ed past papers of sargodha university,mathematics d past papers,maths 5-7 past papers,maths d past papers,module c past papers,n level past papers,n level past year papers,n.t.s past papers,national 5 past papers,o level biology past papers,o level chemistry past papers,o level english past papers,o level maths past papers,o level past papers,o level past papers mathematics,o level physics past papers,o n past papers,o/l past papers,o/l past papers 2014,o/l past papers 2015,o/l past papers english,ocr d&t past papers,ocr p.e past papers,ocr r.e past papers,ocr r.s past papers,p past papers,p&n past papers,p&n past papers marking,p.e edexcel past papers,p.e gcse past papers,p.l.e pastpapers,p.u past papers,papers past n.z,papers past nelson n z,past exam papers 0 level,past papers,past papers 0 level,past papers 0417,past papers 0470,past papers 0500,past papers 0510,past papers 0522,past papers 0580,past papers 0610,past papers 0620,past papers 0625,past papers 10 class federal board,past papers 10 class physics,past papers 1123,past papers 12,past papers 1424,past papers 1st year,past papers 1st year 2016,past papers 1st year 2017,past papers 1st year gujranwala board,past papers 1st year lahore board,past papers 2015,past papers 2016,past papers 2016 fbise,past papers 2016 physics,past papers 2017,past papers 2017 fbise,past papers 2059/2,past papers 2nd year,past papers 2nd year 2017,past papers 2nd year lahore board,past papers 3248,past papers 3u,past papers 3u maths,past papers 4-6,past papers 4024,past papers 4037,past papers 416,past papers 417,past papers 4th year mbbs,past papers 5 years,past papers 5-7,past papers 5054,past papers 5070,past papers 5090,past papers 514,past papers 5th class,past papers 5th class 2012,past papers 6-8,past papers 651,past papers 6574,past papers 695,past papers 696,past papers 697,past papers 6th class,past papers 7+,past papers 7010,past papers 7110,past papers 7115,past papers 8 class 2017,past papers 8 class lahore board,past papers 837,past papers 8th class faisalabad board,past papers 8th class gujranwala board,past papers 8th class gujranwala board 2013,past papers 8th class lahore board 2011,past papers 8th class maths,past papers 8th class punjab board,past papers 8th class sargodha board,past papers 9,past papers 9701,past papers 9709,past papers 9th class,past papers 9th class bahawalpur board,past papers 9th class chemistry,past papers 9th class english medium,past papers 9th class faisalabad board,past papers 9th class federal board,past papers 9th class gujranwala board,past papers a level,past papers a levels physics,past papers acca,past papers accounting,past papers ad ib,past papers adamjee,past papers aiou,past papers aiou ba 416,past papers aku eb,past papers app,past papers ba english,past papers beaconhouse class 7,past papers biology 5090,past papers biology 9th class,past papers biology o level,past papers bise grw,past papers bise lahore,past papers bsc chemistry,past papers bsc gcuf,past papers by moaaz,past papers c1,past papers cardiff,past papers ccea,past papers chemistry,past papers chemistry a level,past papers cie,past papers co,past papers css,past papers cxc,past papers dae,past papers dcu,past papers department of education,past papers dg khan board,past papers distance education suit,past papers dit,past papers dmu,past papers download,past papers dpt uos,past papers durham,past papers ecat,past papers economics,past papers economics a level,past papers edexcel,past papers education,past papers english,past papers english essay css,past papers english lecturer,past papers english o levels,past papers entry test,past papers f.a part 2,past papers f8,past papers fbise,past papers for assistant,past papers for entry test,past papers for nums,past papers for o levels,past papers for ppsc,past papers form 3,past papers form 3 mauritius,past papers fpsc,past papers fsc part 1,past papers gat,past papers gat general,past papers gce guide,past papers gcuf,past papers general knowledge,past papers geography,past papers grade 11 physics,past papers grade 12,past papers grade 12 physics,past papers grade 3,past papers grade 7,past papers grade 7 science,past papers grade 7 south africa,past papers grade 7 sri lanka,past papers grw,past papers history,past papers history edexcel,past papers history o level,past papers home economics,past papers hsc,past papers hsc maths,past papers hssc 1,past papers hssc federal board,past papers hssc part 2,past papers hull uni,past papers ib,past papers ibp,past papers icap,past papers icmap,past papers igcse,past papers inspector asf,past papers international relations,past papers islamiat css,past papers islamiat elective 2016,past papers islamiyat o levels,past papers jc,past papers jekyll and hyde,past papers jkuat,past papers june,past papers june 2013 edexcel,past papers june 2014,past papers june 2015,past papers june 2016,past papers june 2017,past papers junior cert,past papers karachi board,past papers karachi university,past papers kcl,past papers kcse,past papers kcse 2016,past papers kent,past papers kenya,past papers ks1,past papers ks2,past papers ks3,past papers lahore board,past papers lecturer commerce,past papers lecturer economics,past papers lecturer education,past papers lecturer english,past papers lecturer english ppsc,past papers lecturer history ppsc,past papers lecturer ppsc,past papers llb 2016,past papers llb part 2 bzu,past papers maldives,past papers malta,past papers manchester,past papers maths,past papers maths edexcel,past papers maths edexcel gcse,past papers maths gcse higher,past papers matric,past papers matsec,past papers mq,past papers nat,past papers nbp,past papers ned university karachi,past papers nts,past papers nts educators,past papers nts test pdf,past papers nums,past papers nust,past papers nust entry test,past papers nz,past papers nz herald,past papers nzqa,past papers o level,past papers ocr,past papers of 10th class,past papers of 9th class,past papers of css,past papers of d.com 2,past papers of fsc part 1,past papers of m.ed aiou,past papers of mcat,past papers of nts,past papers of ppsc,past papers online,past papers p.u b.sc,past papers physics,past papers physics fbise,past papers physics o level,past papers pieas,past papers ppsc,past papers ppsc english,past papers ppsc staff nurse,past papers preston university,past papers psychology,past papers punjab university,past papers qau,past papers qca,past papers qmu,past papers qmul,past papers qub,past papers queens online,past papers questions,past papers questions and answers,past papers qut,past papers rawalpindi board,past papers rawalpindi board 2nd year,past papers reading,past papers reddit,past papers religion,past papers religious studies,past papers revision,past papers rhs level 2,past papers rhul,past papers rs edexcel,past papers sargodha board,past papers sarhad university,past papers sat,past papers senior auditor,past papers sindh board,past papers sociology a level,past papers sociology css,past papers spsc,past papers ssc 1,past papers ssc 2,past papers taleem e pakistan,past papers tamil,past papers tanzania,past papers tcd,past papers textiles,past papers to do online,past papers tom newby,past papers travel and tourism,past papers trials,past papers tuks,past papers uet,past papers uhs,past papers university of peshawar,past papers university of sargodha,past papers uob,past papers urdu,past papers urdu 2016 1st year,past papers urdu 2nd year fsd,past papers urdu o level,past papers urdu part 2,past papers varsity college,past papers vcaa,past papers vectors,past papers verbal reasoning,past papers veterinary nursing,past papers virtual university pakistan,past papers visual arts,past papers vu,past papers vu final term,past papers vuw,past papers warwick,past papers wced,past papers website,past papers with answers,past papers wits,past papers wjec,past papers wjec biology,past papers wjec english,past papers wjec maths,past papers wsu,past papers x,past papers xii karachi board,past papers xtremepapers,past papers year 10 maths,past papers year 11,past papers year 2,past papers year 3,past papers year 3 maths,past papers year 4,past papers year 7,past papers year 8,past papers year 9,past papers york,past papers york economics,past papers za,past papers za darasa la saba,past papers za qt,past papers zejtun,past papers zero semester vu,past papers zica,past papers zoology,past papers.com,past papers.n,pastpapers.co/cie,pastpapers.ie,pastpapers.lk,pastpapers.papacambridge.com › igcse,pastpapers.pk,persian past papers f.a,pharm d past papers,r past papers,r.e 2046 past papers,r.e gcse past papers,r.e ocr past papers,r.e past papers,r.s past papers,s level maths past papers,s.e.a past papers,sat 1 past papers,sat 2 past papers,std v past papers,step 1 past papers,t.m.o past papers,u of t past papers,u.tt past papers,urdu past papers o level,wjec d&t past papers,wjec past papers,wjec past papers r.e,wjec r.e past papers,wjec r.s past papers,x past papers,xat past papers,xcel past papers,xhosa past papers,xi past papers,xtreme past papers,xtremepapers biology,y pant past papers,year 3 past papers,year 5 past papers,year 6 past papers,year 7 past papers,year 8 past papers,year 9 past papers,zoology c past papers,ab na roko na toko,darling roko na toko na,honey singh mujhe roko toko rap lyrics,mujhe roko toko honey singh,mujhe roko toko honey singh lyrics,mujhe roko toko honey singh mp3,mujhe roko toko lyrics,mujhe roko toko mp3 download,parle g roko mat toko mat,parle g roko mat toko mat lyrics,roko mat toko mat,roko mat toko mat ad,roko mat toko mat download,roko mat toko mat free download,roko mat toko mat full mp3 download,roko mat toko mat full song,roko mat toko mat full song download,roko mat toko mat lyrics,roko mat toko mat parle g,roko mat toko mat ringtone,roko mat toko mat singer,roko mat toko mat song,roko mat toko mat song download,roko mat toko mat song free download,roko mat toko mat song lyrics,roko mat toko mat song mp3,roko mat toko mat video,roko mat toko mat video download,roko na toko nahi,roko toko campaign,toko bagus roko elektrik,toko bong roko,toko jual rokok elektrik,toko online rokok elektrik,toko roko electrik,toko roko elektrik,toko roko elektrik bogor,toko roko elektrik di bali,toko roko elektrik di baltos,toko roko elektrik di bandung,toko roko elektrik di bekasi,toko roko elektrik di cimahi,toko roko elektrik di garut,toko roko elektrik di jakarta,toko roko elektrik di tangerang,toko roko hilversum,toko roko openingstijden,toko rokok elektrik balikpapan,toko rokok elektrik bandung,toko rokok elektrik di bogor,toko rokok elektrik di cirebon,toko rokok elektrik jakarta,toko rokok elektrik tangerang,toko rokok sin,toko yang menjual rokok elektrik,tokopedia rokok elektrik,us koi roko na roko,1042 webinars,1095 webinars,1095-c webinars,1099 webinars,1099 webinars 2015,123sonography webinars,12d webinars,1800 respect webinars,1e webinars,2 degrees webinars,2020 webinars 2014,2020 webinars 2015,2020 webinars 2016,24/7 webinars,24option webinars,27001 webinars,340b webinars,3cx webinars,3d printer webinars,3e webinars,3m webinars,3m webinars 2013,3m webinars 2014,3m webinars 2015,3m webinars 2016,3p learning webinars,3play media webinars,3shape webinars,4 good nonprofit webinars,4 good webinars,4-h webinars,401k webinars,451 webinars,4a''s webinars,4as webinars,5linx webinars,7 figure webinars,7 figure webinars download,7 figure webinars lewis howes,7 figure webinars login,7 figure webinars review,7 habits webinars,7sage webinars,8x8 webinars,911 webinars,99designs webinars,a drawback of webinars is that they,a drawback of webinars is that they quizlet,a team webinars,aat level 3 webinars,aat level 4 webinars,ab 86 webinars,act 48 webinars,acuho-i webinars,adobe connect 9 webinars,are webinars a waste of time,at&t webinars,awwa webinars,b&h webinars,b&k webinars,bb&t webinars,bernina 830 webinars,bit 9 webinars,bsi 9001 webinars,buss3 webinars,c programming webinars,c&en webinars,c-tpat webinars,cad-1 webinars,caesar 2 webinars,capture one 8 webinars,capture one 9 webinars,clicker 6 webinars,clickz webinars,comptia a+ webinars,control-m webinars,cpa webinars,d&b webinars,d&t webinars,d+h webinars,daily 5 webinars,district 79 webinars,dr z webinars,dsm 5 webinars,dsm v webinars,e clinical webinars,e discovery webinars,e learning webinars,e&y webinars,e-tuitions/webinars,e-verify webinars,e/m webinars,ecommerce webinars,ehealth webinars,encase 7 webinars,extjs 6 webinars,form i-9 webinars,form z webinars,free dsm 5 webinars,free l&d webinars,free pre k webinars,gasb 68 webinars,gd&t webinars,hepatitis c webinars,hud 4000.1 webinars,i cat care webinars,i hate webinars,i ready webinars,i trust webinars,i-9 webinars,i-sight webinars,ieee mtt-s webinars,ikid webinars,iso 9001 webinars,k&l gates webinars,k-12 webinars,k-2 webinars,kaplan webinars,karatbars webinars,kareo webinars,kcura webinars,kinnser webinars,kissmetrics webinars,kpmg webinars canada,ktea-3 webinars,l&d webinars,land fx webinars,lane 4 webinars,learning a-z webinars,legacy 8 webinars,level 3 webinars,licor 6400 webinars,lightroom 5 webinars,m&a webinars,medicare part b webinars,memoq webinars,microsoft r webinars,n-able webinars,ng911 webinars,noridian part b webinars,north u webinars,novitas part b webinars,o que sao webinars,o que significa webinars,o que são webinars,o que webinars,o''reilly bwd webinars,o''reilly webinars,ohs webinars,optimum g webinars,oral b webinars,p&c insurance webinars,p&g webinars,p&i webinars,panorama 9 webinars,pcss-o webinars,pearson wisc v webinars,pge webinars,pix4d webinars,point 2 webinars,point b webinars,pre k webinars,prim&r webinars,prince2 webinars,psmo-i webinars,pt&c webinars,q es webinars,q interactive webinars,quality webinars,quest webinars,quickbase webinars,quickbooks webinars training,quranic webinars,r programming webinars,rapid7 webinars,redhat 7 webinars,region 4 webinars,regulation e webinars,rms 9 webinars,rootsmagic 5 webinars,rootsmagic 6 webinars,rootsmagic 7 webinars,rstudio webinars,rtl z webinars,s&op webinars,s&p dji webinars,s&p webinars,s-frame webinars,sage 50 webinars,section 508 webinars,shrp2 webinars,simple k webinars,sterile u webinars,storyline 2 webinars,t rowe price webinars,tutor2u webinars,u of m webinars,u of t webinars,unit4 webinars,usp 797 webinars,v cube webinars,version 1 webinars,virginia 529 webinars,vision 6 webinars,webinar jeo,webinar o webinar,webinarjam,webinarjam api,webinarjam download,webinarjam integrations,webinarjam login,webinarjam reviews,webinarjam support,webinarjam trial,webinarjam vs zoom,webinars,webinars 101,webinars 1920,webinars 2015,webinars 2016,webinars 2017,webinars 2020,webinars 3m,webinars 3shape,webinars 777,webinars a cookbook for educators,webinars adalah,webinars adobe,webinars advantages,webinars amy porterfield,webinars angel broking,webinars as a marketing tool,webinars ato,webinars australia,webinars autism,webinars aws,webinars b2b,webinars b2b marketing,webinars benefits,webinars best practices,webinars brain injury,webinars brighttalk,webinars british council,webinars business,webinars business analysis,webinars by dennis,webinars ca sri lanka,webinars cambridge english,webinars childcare,webinars communication skills,webinars comparison,webinars constant contact,webinars cost,webinars cpa,webinars create abilities,webinars customer service,webinars d-link,webinars definition,webinars deloitte,webinars dental,webinars dentistry,webinars digital marketing,webinars disadvantages,webinars domestic violence,webinars doorway to college,webinars download,webinars dyslexia,webinars early childhood,webinars education,webinars electrical engineering,webinars elt,webinars english teaching,webinars esc,webinars esl,webinars events,webinars examples,webinars explained,webinars for business,webinars for dummies,webinars for gps,webinars for librarians,webinars for marketing,webinars for professional development,webinars for sage 50 payroll,webinars for social workers,webinars for students,webinars for teachers,webinars free,webinars gartner,webinars gdpr,webinars genealogy,webinars genealogy free,webinars good or bad,webinars google,webinars google hangout,webinars gotomeeting,webinars gov uk,webinars grant writing,webinars hbr,webinars healthcare,webinars hmrc,webinars hootsuite,webinars hosting,webinars how do they work,webinars how they work,webinars how to,webinars hr,webinars hubspot,webinars icai,webinars icon,webinars images,webinars in education,webinars in hindi,webinars in india,webinars in marketing,webinars in moodle,webinars in spanish,webinars invision,webinars kaspersky,webinars knx,webinars kpmg,webinars law,webinars leadership development,webinars legacy,webinars lexisnexis,webinars library training,webinars linkedin,webinars list,webinars live,webinars login,webinars là gì,webinars marketing,webinars mcgill,webinars meaning,webinars meaning in hindi,webinars meaning in tamil,webinars meaning in telugu,webinars meaning in urdu,webinars meme,webinars mental health,webinars meraki,webinars nbcc,webinars neil patel,webinars nerium,webinars neuropsychology,webinars neuroscience,webinars nonprofit organizations,webinars now,webinars nursing,webinars nutrition,webinars nz,webinars o que e,webinars o que é,webinars on air,webinars on air pricing,webinars on autism,webinars on demand,webinars on digital marketing,webinars on domestic violence,webinars on gst,webinars on leadership,webinars on youtube,webinars online,webinars or seminars,webinars page,webinars pharmaceuticals,webinars philippines,webinars physical therapy,webinars platforms,webinars pmi,webinars pronunciation,webinars pros and cons,webinars psychology,webinars pwc,webinars qbo,webinars qiagen,webinars qlik,webinars qualtrics,webinars quickbooks,webinars radiology,webinars real estate,webinars recording,webinars recruitment,webinars resemble an online television show,webinars resourcd,webinars reviews,webinars rics,webinars right now,webinars rstudio,webinars salesforce,webinars science,webinars shopify,webinars social media,webinars social work,webinars software,webinars south africa,webinars statistics,webinars strategy,webinars synonyms,webinars tableau,webinars tally solutions,webinars tally solutions 9090,webinars that convert,webinars that convert login,webinars that work john nemo,webinars to go,webinars to promote,webinars today,webinars tools,webinars training,webinars uk,webinars ukti,webinars unitronics,webinars using google hangout,webinars using microsoft lync,webinars using skype,webinars using skype for business,webinars using webex,webinars uva,webinars uwv,webinars veeam,webinars vet,webinars veterinary,webinars via google,webinars via lync,webinars videos,webinars vmware,webinars vs podcasts,webinars vs webcasts,webinars website,webinars what are they,webinars wiki,webinars with certificates,webinars with skype,webinars with skype for business,webinars with wow factor,webinars with zoom,webinars wlu,webinars wordpress,webinars xero,webinars xperthr,webinars youtube,webinars zendesk,webinars zoho,webinars zoom,webinars.5linx,wisc 5 webinars,wisc v webinars,x rite photo webinars,x rite webinars,x rite webinars archives,xamarin webinars,xero webinars australia,xero webinars nz,xero webinars uk,xm webinars,xojo webinars,xtalks webinars,yale webinars,yalsa webinars,yardi webinars,yelp webinars,yiah webinars,ynab webinars,yoga webinars,yokogawa webinars,youngevity webinars,z health webinars,zabbix webinars,zemax webinars,zend webinars,zenfolio webinars,zillow webinars,zingtrain webinars,zurich webinars yoloportal.com offers Online Education in Pakistan. Learn latest & Past Papers Electronics, Mobiles, Books & much more
50
Learn English in London - The Burlington School of English London General English, IELTS test preparation, Cambridge English exam preparation and Business English courses in London. Study English in London and focus on a full English immersion course. Prepare for internationally recognised exams by studying one of our exam preparation courses for IELTS or Cambridge English. Improve your English for the workplace by studying Business English or English for work in London. Aged 7 - 17 years old, Burlington School also offers English courses for young learners in Autumn, Winter, Spring and Summer. If you are looking for a Summer Language Camp in United Kingdom we have the perfect English Summer Camp for you. Our Summer Language Camp in Ardingly gives students the opportunity to learn English in the United Kingdom in one of the most respected independent schools in Britain. At the Burlington School of English in London, we provide english courses and lessons in London. We offer General English Courses, Business English Courses and English Courses for Juniors.
52
Prosperitaselt – Online English Language & Corporate Leadership Training with Proven Results. Committed to Helping, Enriching and Empowering Others & YOU Just another WordPress site
54
Home Established in 1988 by Chief Instructor and Head Coach, Master Mike McKenzie (Black Belt, 7th Dan), Quest Taekwondo is a modern, professional and inspirational taekwondo organisation where students can be assured of the highest standard of training in order to reach their maximum potential. The lead Quest training venue is based at Penistone Grammar School''s brand new international standard sports facility near Barnsley/Sheffield, South Yorkshire. Quest also has venues in Leeds, Bradford, Liverpool and Hull.
55
Solterra Academy | CT | Special Education School Solterra Academy, in New Britain, Connecticut, provides comprehensive special education for students, from age 5 to 21.
56
Exclusive English English speaking courses | English courses online | Exclusive English Exclusive English offer English speaking Courses in London, Hereford or Overseas. Students studying in Britain also gain privileged access to tradition Britain
57
Home | CIBI The Carmelite Institute of Britain and Ireland (CIBI) is a collaborative initiative of the British and Irish Provinces of Carmelites and the Angelo-Irish Province of Discalced Carmelites.CIBI was founded in November 2005 and the first students commenced their studies in September 2006.
58
Solterra Academy | CT | Special Education School Solterra Academy, in New Britain, Connecticut, provides comprehensive special education for students, from age 5 to 21.
59
International Education Consultant, Student Agency, Melbourne, Australia | StudyCo International Education Consultant, Student Agency, Melbourne, Australia | StudyCo . StudyCo is an international student education agency in Melbourne, Australia. Our student recruitment agency provides information about the study programs offered globally including bachelor, master, PhD and English programs. Also, you get free of charge admissions services. We are one of the trusted education agents in Australia.
60
The UK''s 15 National Parks. Visit and learn about Britain''s most inspiring areas of countryside. The home of the UK''s 15 National Parks - Britain''s breathing spaces. For visitors, for students, for anyone with a love of wide open skies.
61
Homepage - Great British Mag The UK's only media channel for EU and international students in the UK. Great information, fun, quirks, tips and guidance for all things Britain!
62
Združenie turizmu Terchová | Both these strategies consider some time, in the big event the documents may be completed nicely. Moreover, You will imbibe the best way to get your essays perform by locating your own style as well as words. Afterwards, the very same will be truthful of essays theywill have to write. This actually is generally a fantastic article Elena. By the opinion of professional essay writing service EssayBasics.com, an article actually should not be just a list. Writing an essay isn't merely accumulating the numerous information and not simply assembling the beneficial info from the different sources to put it to use in your projects. We must disclose the required - class college essay is truly a failure. Students need not spend some time about the documents any more. He's enshrined within the hearts of his own pupils. Typically, individuals won't develop these skills by themselves. What was when she got it like married? she probably features a lot of thoughts about that day. The creating skills the students acquire, in addition to the thinking abilities, are important. Furthermore, over 75% of the surveyed were not able to accommodate how to teach articles when nurturing critical thinking. Take complete benefit of this understanding capability whenever you may. The objective of the program is consistently to aid each student in distinguishing universities and colleges that are a fantastic match for her or his interests, demands, and aspirations, while in inclusion assisting the student and household through the application procedure Camp is the preceding week of school! To qualify for desire based assistance pupils and their own households must finish the FAFSA (www.fafsa.ed.gov). We desire every university student to acquire a business to be a highly successful excellent achiever. I had the very good fortune of studying in outstanding school and universities. Scholarships tend to be called merit based support. Viewers too may readily carry in mind a chart when compared to a couple of sentences of the blog post. Her incredible report gives her the best average in her category at open school in britain. It doesn't always require to be materialistic gains for your own viewers. Make studying or narrative time portion of each day. Use the 7 practices resolved in this short post to make an effect on your visitors. Cause and effect yet another major aspect to numerous varieties of writing. Today, because of texting, e-mail, blogs, etc., a growing amount of conversation happens through composing. Your company is, in inclusion, obvious with good usage of paragraphs and cohesive devices. This actually has to be qualified by the understanding that there's a special type and fashion in educational writing. The liver gets its method of getting blood from two boats. You should evaluate the instructions for every college that provides test discretionary to establish the qualifications and necessary. This class is made for pupils that have attained a sophisticated degree. Check scores aren't included on JC transcript. Most importantly, take this class. Get your own endeavor completed by experts within their special area and you'll locate some modified documents. The shape and articles will fit your course and discipline you're in. All All These are often an important portion of a student's program. In any event, it will likely be a successful appraisal. Clean off the fertilizer in tiers. The initial week, you are going to discover several skills that will ensure you're never going to lack for ideas. Having said That, the scaffold offered by the essay outline also has to participate instruction. Creating abilities also have firm. Following is a comprehensive guide on the best way to compose a effective ACT article. You're able to talk about your own function to our team, and we are going to permit you to manage. They're able to judge the genuine value of the instructor within almost no time. Linda is an excellent teacher. Quite simply, a great teacher is actually a pupil's buddy, thinker and information.
63
EuroCooling & Heating EuroCooling and Heating, the leading European network for avant-garde technologies in Refrigeration, Air Conditioning and Heating
64
Body and Gender in the Eighteenth Century | Articles by 3d year students of English Studies, Université Paris-Diderot Articles by 3d year students of English Studies, Université Paris-Diderot
66
United World Colleges Great Britain - UK National Committee United World Colleges Great Britain is the National Committee which selects British students to attend UWCs across the world.
67
Home | English in Britain Gallery Home - The English in Britain Gallery is the place where accredited English language course providers in Britain show what their schools look like, what their students do, where they live, where they learn and where they go.
68
UK travel and events. Work or study abroad in Britain. British culture and life. Study, work, live, travel in Britain (London/England, Wales, Scotland). Guide to British culture, traditions and events. UK student life for international students at university, college or language school. Learn English. Tours and tourist information.
70
CANTONESE SCHOOL IN LONDON- LANGUAGE CLASSES / LESSONS EVERY SUNDAY. CANTONESE CLASSES FOR BEGINNERS AND AT ALL LEVELS.Cantonese classes in London at Fei Jau Dak Chinese School in London. Beginners Cantonese. Learn Cantonese at Fei Jau Dak Chinese School, at beginner, intermediate and advanced levels. Cantonese tutor provided. Cantonese courses availible for students to learn at their own pace. *****Cantonese Lessons Every Sunday*****.
71
Learn English in London - The Burlington School of English London General English, IELTS test preparation, Cambridge English exam preparation and Business English courses in London. Study English in London and focus on a full English immersion course. Prepare for internationally recognised exams by studying one of our exam preparation courses for IELTS or Cambridge English. Improve your English for the workplace by studying Business English or English for work in London. Aged 7 - 17 years old, Burlington School also offers English courses for young learners in Autumn, Winter, Spring and Summer. If you are looking for a Summer Language Camp in United Kingdom we have the perfect English Summer Camp for you. Our Summer Language Camp in Ardingly gives students the opportunity to learn English in the United Kingdom in one of the most respected independent schools in Britain. At the Burlington School of English in London, we provide english courses and lessons in London. We offer General English Courses, Business English Courses and English Courses for Juniors.
73
Home Welcome to History Interactive Key Stage 4 GCSE Modern World and School History resources. Revise GCSE History. GCSE exam revision and Key Stage 3 History teaching and learning.
76
THE BATTLE OF BRITAIN HISTORICAL SOCIETY The official website of the Battle of Britain Historical Sociey. An educational history of the Battle of Britain designed for the internet for use by students and scholars making a study of this period of our modern history. Covering such topics as the leaders of both sides, the pilots, the squadrons, the airfields and the aircraft. Also a concise chonology of the period of the battle during 1940,
77
Brockenhurst College | Brock is one of the most successful Sixth Form colleges in the UK, offering A levels, Vocational, Adult Learning, Apprenticeships, Business courses. Brockenhurst College is first choice for more than 2,700 school leavers and 8,000 adult learners across the region.
78
TxtMania | The Philippines, a group of over 7,000 islands with combined land area encompassing 300,000 square kilometres, grew into a nation under more than three centuries of Spanish conquest and 42 years of American rule. It is the first country outside the New World that closely witnessed the United States' rise to power following the 1898 Spanish-American War. Situated 800 kilometres southeast of mainland Asia, the archipelago, named after King Philip II of Spain, was discovered in 1521 by Ferdinand Magellan, the same explorer who had discovered the Pacific Ocean in search of the so-called "Spice Islands" and is now widely considered the first navigator to have cruised around the planet. Ironically, the Filipinos, after having been subdued for centuries by foreign colonizers as a result of Magellan's voyage, would emerge as the best seafarers in the world, manning a third of all international vessels today. Some 7.8 million overseas Filipino workers (OFWs) and Filipino migrants would help rebuild cities in many countries and bring back over US$10 billion in annual remittances to their families in the Philippines. The country's geographical location and long exposure to foreign influences has placed the Philippines on a unique cultural base in Asia. It is now the only predominantly Catholic country in the region, with 70 million out of its total population of 85 million (as of 2005) confessing to be Catholic. There are also large numbers of Protestants and Born-Again Christians in the country while the Muslim population is concentrated in southern Mindanao. Early Trade The first inhabitants of the Philippines were the Negritos who traveled from mainland Asia over a land bridge that is now underwater. Migrants from other Southeast Asian countries such as Indonesia and Malaysia later followed and established a Malayan culture that flourished before the Spaniards came. Chinese and Arab merchants helped establish markets at the community level. A sultanate system, first established in the southern island of Sulu in the 14th century, is believed to have reached the islands of Luzon and Visayas, giving way to the rise of the Islamic faith. The Spaniards would later drive the Muslims to the south and establish Catholicism as the main religion in the north and central parts of the country. Local villages, known as barangay, traded agricultural and fishery products with each other. The Igorot tribe in Northern Luzon carved the marvellous Banaue Rice Terraces from the mountains, a proof of their advanced agriculture technology. Communities near the shore exchanged goods with Chinese and Arab merchants, who came aboard large ships. These communities traded slaves, gold, beeswax, betel nuts, pearls, and shells for porcelain, silk, iron, tin and semi-precious stones. The Philippine islands were a part of an extensive trade route used by Chinese merchants as early as the 10th century. By the time Magellan arrived in the islands, regular trade and cultural contact between Chinese traders and local chieftains were firmly instituted. Many Chinese merchants settled in the country and shared their crafts with the natives. Some historians claim that an Italian Franciscan priest, named Father Odorico, was actually the first European to have reached the Philippines in 1324 when his ship bound for China took refuge from a storm in Bolinao Island in northern part of Luzon. Aside from the Banaue Rice Terraces in the Cordillera Mountains, early settlers did not leave any giant monument, and this is what makes conservative historians doubt the existence of the rich kingdoms in the country hundreds of years ago. However, it cannot be denied that early Filipinos were learned individuals who expressed their beliefs and sentiments in rich languages. According to the National Commission for Culture and the Arts (NCCA), there are actually 78 language groupings and over 500 dialects in the Philippines. Feudal Society Magellan, who claimed the archipelago for Spain in 1521, died in a battle with a group of local warriors led by Lapu Lapu at Mactan Island. It was Ruy Lopez de Villalobos, in the fourth Spanish expedition, who named the territory as Filipinas after the heir to the Spanish throne in 1543. In 1565, Miguel Lopez de Legaspi led an expedition to colonize the islands and by 1571, most parts of the archipelago came under Spanish rule. The Spaniards established the colonial government first in Cebu in 1565 and then in Manila in 1571. Historians claim that University of San Carlos in Cebu and University of Sto. Tomas in Manila are the oldest universities teaching European type of education in Asia. Jesuit and Dominican priests established the two institutions. Under Spanish rule, Catholicism became the dominant religion. Catholic friars not only lorded over the congregations; they enjoyed vast political and economic influence, which they eventually used to repress Filipino peasants' uprisings in the largely feudal Philippine society at that time. The Spaniards also quelled a number of rebellions instigated by the Chinese migrants. The friars distributed lands to Spanish families, who later comprised the landowning class. To perpetuate their economic interests, this class would also rise to become the political elite that would remain in power to this day. This gave way to the hacienda system in the Philippines, where cacique or landowners managed large tracts of lands tilled by peasant workers. Under the system, farmers were supposed to receive half of the harvest, but they usually ended up with much less because they had to pay for large interests on debt incurred from the cacique. This would be later corrected with a system of land reform, which, however, remains to be fully implemented to this day. Galleon Trade The Manila-Acapulco galleon trade became the major trading system between Asia and the Americas for nearly two centuries. Manila became a transhipment point of American silver to China. It was through this trade that the first Chinese silk and porcelain reached the shores of the New World. There were unverified claims that Filipinos helped build the city of Los Angeles in America. The Chinese and Filipinos would later become the two largest Asian migrant groups in the United States. Coconut became the country's top agricultural product, because of Spain's huge need for charcoaled coconut shells used for the caulking of the galleons. In 1642, the colonial government issued an edict requiring each Filipino to plant 200 coconut trees all over the country. By 1910, coconut exports would account for a fifth of total Philippine exports and to this day, coconut oil remains the country's top agricultural shipment. The Galleon Trade lasted for about 200 years until 1815. It is during this period that rice and tropical fruits from the Philippines such as mango and banana made their way to Latin America. Beginning 1750, Spanish priests encouraged the development of plantations to grow abaca (hemp), tobacco, coffee and sugar. Sugar barons from the Visayas would later emerge as among the richest clans in the country. From 1762 to 1764, the British briefly captured Manila during the Seven Years War. The treaty of Paris ended the British occupation and returned the colony to the hands of their original colonial masters. Plantation Crops In 1781, the Spanish governor established the tobacco monopoly in the Philippines, which would become a major source of revenue for the colonial government. From 1820 to 1870, the Philippines would be transformed to an agricultural export economy. Located on the oceanic trading routes connecting Asia to other parts of the world, the Philippines became a transhipment point of merchandise goods from all over Southeast Asia on their way to Europe. The Philippines exported plantation crops such as sugar, abaca, other fibres, tobacco, coffee, and coconut products to China, Spain, United States, United Kingdom and British East Indies. In return, it imported textiles and rice. Historians claim that Spain administered the Philippine affairs through Mexico. Spanish administrators in the country were actually reporting to the Viceroyalty of Mexico. After Mexico gained its independence from Spain in 1821, Madrid directly governed its only Asian colony and even allowed rich Filipinos to study in Europe. The Spanish rule gave way to the rise of a small but highly powerful elite class, which to this day, controls most of the Philippine economy. The elite families, which own large plantations, were able to send their children to Europe for education. Foreign Investors Investors from Spain, Germany, Britain and other European countries laid the groundwork for utility companies in steam navigation, cable, telegraphy, railroads and electricity in the country. They also invested heavily in rice and sugar milling, textile and banking. The local elite developed the brewing industry, which would become one of the most profitable sectors in the economy. Although the educated Filipinos who studied in Europe shunned the use of force to topple the colonial government, their writings provoked nationalist sentiments among young men, who eventually formed a revolutionary movement against Spain. In 1896, the war between Spanish and Filipino soldiers escalated following the death of novelist Jose Rizal and rebel leader Andres Bonifacio. Emilio Aguinaldo, the new leader of the revolutionary forces, forged a pact with US Commodore George Dewey in Hong Kong to defeat the Spanish army. American Colony The Americans entered the scene because of its conflict with Spain over Cuba. With the outbreak of the Spanish-American war in the Pacific, the Philippines had to be taken by the US, lest other European countries such as Britain, France and Germany would fight for their next Southeast Asian colony. On June 12, 1898, Aguinaldo, first backed by American forces, declared the independence of Kawit, Cavite, the seat of the revolutionary Filipino government at that time, from Spanish rule. The Americans took possession of Manila on August 13, 1898. While armed clashes with Spanish forces continued in other parts of the country, the Americans and the Spaniards were negotiating for the purchase of the Philippines for US$20 million. In the Treaty of Paris in 1898, Spain ceded the Philippines, Cuba, Puerto Rico, and Guam to the US. Filipinos felt insulted at the fact that their country has been passed from one colonial master to another for only US$20 million. When the US, which had not conquered any country before, made known its intention to succeed Spain as the next colonizer of the Philippines, Aguinaldo and his men waged a revolutionary resistance that ended with his capture in March 1901. The American soldiers easily subdued the remaining factions of rebellion with the help of their powerful weapons and their divide-and-conquer tactic. As an archipelago of 7,000 islands, the Philippines is home to different ethnic groups which do not speak the same language. The national government's attempt to declare Tagalog (spoken in Central and Southern Luzon including Metro Manila) as the national language would not easily win the support of other regions. The Philippine-American war took the lives of 4,234 American and 16,000 Filipino soldiers. The death toll was much higher on the civilian population, with as high as 200,000 casualties. Although local resistance persisted until 1903, the US ended its military rule on July 4, 1901. American Way Under American civilian rule, the Philippines was introduced to US-type of education, Protestant religion, and later to the concept of democracy. Placed under US control were most parts of the country, except in the southern portion of Mindanao where Muslim rebels held strong resistance. William Howard Taft, the 27th US president, was the first American Civil Governor in the Philippines. Taft was praised for establishing a civil service system, creating a national legislature, suppressing prices, upgrading health standards, and sponsoring land reform and road building in the country. In 1907, the First Philippine Assembly composed of educated and rich Filipinos with vast landholdings. Manuel L. Quezon, who represented the Philippines in the US Congress, lobbied for the passage of the Jones Law, which in 1916 abolished the Philippine Assembly to give way for a bicameral legislature made up of the Senate and the House of Representatives. With the passage of the Tydings-McDuffie Act in 1934, Filipinos had their first taste of self-rule through the Philippine Commonwealth, a transitional government designed to prepare the Filipinos over a ten-year period for independence. By 1935, the Commonwealth was in place with Quezon as its first president. The Philippines also approved a new constitution in the same year. The United States is credited for helping establish the Republic of the Philippines, the first democratic government in Asia. Economically, the Philippines was ahead of its Asian neighbours, who were still subjects of European colonial powers before the war. Japanese Invasion In December 1941, the Japanese Imperial Army invaded the Philippines and drove the Commonwealth Government from Manila. While Quezon continued to head the government-in-exile until his death in New York in August 1944, the Japanese forces handpicked Jose P. Laurel, a graduate of Yale University and Tokyo International University, to head a new government under their control. The Philippines was dragged into the war because of Japan's military ambition to become the dominant force in Asia and the Pacific. Japan wanted to be the leader of an economic zone in East Asia, which would be the source of its raw materials. The US presence in the Philippines, known for its strategic location in Southeast Asia, was the largest threat to the Japanese forces, following the destruction of the American Pacific fleet at Pearl Harbor on December 7, 1941. While the American forces were regrouping in the United States, Filipino soldiers formed a guerrilla organization called Hukbalahap (People's Anti-Japanese Army). Some 30,000 guerrillas at that time engaged the Japanese army in intermittent clashes. The Hukbalahap would later adopt the communist ideology and rule in the countryside. Meanwhile, Sergio Osmeña replaced Quezon as the head of the government-in-exile and joined General Douglas MacArthur in the liberation of Manila. General MacArthur returned to the Philippines via the island province of Leyte, along with 174,000 army and navy servicemen on October 20, 1944. The liberation of Manila took almost 20 days from February 3 to 23, 1945 and the fierce battle destroyed much of the city, with its ruins now often compared to the ruins of Warsaw, Poland in Europe. The Japanese army, however, continued to fight in the provinces, until September 2, 1945 when General Yamashita, the Tiger of Malaya who was believed to have hidden vast amount of treasures during the war, surrendered in Baguio City. It is estimated that the battle of Manila cost the lives of 1 million Filipinos, 300,000 Japanese and 60,000 Americans. The intensity of the US-Japan war would force the former to drop an atomic bomb in Hiroshima on August 6, 1945 and in Nagasaki three days later. US Bases By February 1945, Osmeña restored the Commonwealth in the Philippines but it was only on July 4, 1946 that the US granted the Philippines its independence, coinciding with the celebration of the Independence Day in America. However, US military bases would remain in the country for the next 45 years. On March 14, 1947, Manila and Washington signed the Treaty of General Relation, which provided the US to construct military bases for a lease period of 99 years. In 1959, the agreement was amended to shorten the lease period until 1991, after which both sides were to renegotiate the contract. When the US sought a ten-year extension of the lease period in 1991, the Philippine Senate, led by Senate President Jovito Salonga, rejected the proposal in a historic casting of vote on September 16, ending US military bases in the country. With newfound freedom in 1946, Filipinos elected Manuel A. Roxas, leader of the Liberal Party and one of the seven members of the Constitutional Convention who drafted the 1935 Constitution, as the first president of the independent republic in April 1946. His presidency was focused on rebuilding the cities and municipalities torn by the war, redistributing lands as wealthy landowners returned to reclaim their estates, and confronting the Hukbalahap, which by this time was tagged as a socialist-communist organization. The economy grew at a rapid pace, immediately after the war. Special Treatment Close economic ties between Manila and Washington continued after the war on the back of agreements providing for preferential tariffs for American exports and special treatment for US investors in the Philippines. In the 1946 Philippine Trade Act, the Americans were granted duty-free access to the Philippine market and special rights to exploit the country's natural resources. Because of the Trade Act, the Philippines suffered a huge trade deficit with the influx of American imports. In 1949, the Philippine government was forced to impose import controls, after getting the consent of Washington. Roxas' two-year presidency ended with his death, following a heart attack while delivering a speech at Clark Air Force Base in Pampanga province in April 1948. Vice president Elpidio Quirino succeeded Roxas as president and defeated Jose P. Laurel to keep his post in the 1949 presidential race. It was during Quirino's term that the Minimum Wage Law was enacted and the Central Bank was established to stabilize the peso and consumer prices. The country's gross national product grew by an average of 7.7 percent annually in the early 1960s, on the back of the double-digit increase in the manufacturing sector. In the 1953 presidential election, Ramon Magsaysay, who had served as defense secretary under the Quirino administration, won by a landslide. The charismatic Magsaysay initiated peace talks with the Hukbalahap, which would later evolve into a communist organization. He became popular for opening the gates of Malacanang Palace to ordinary people. He died in a plane crash on Mount Manunggal in Cebu in March 1957, which to this day remains a mystery to many Filipinos. While the standard of living in the Philippines was below that of the Western World, the country was often cited as the second richest economy in Asia, after Japan in the 1960s. However, ill-advised economic policies, poor governance and rapid population growth in the country would allow other Asian economies such as Korea, Taiwan, Singapore, Hong Kong, Malaysia, Thailand and China not only to catch up with but to leave the Philippines behind in the race towards industrialization. Filipino First Vice President Carlos P. Garcia assumed the country's top government post following the death of Magsaysay. Garcia was known for his First Filipino Policy and Austerity Program, which put the interests of Filipinos ahead those of foreigners. Under his austerity measures, he encouraged temperate spending, which resulted in less imports and more exports. His nationalist policies, however, perpetuated the business interests of the ruling elite in the country and did not encourage local businesses to be competitive. Garcia lost to his vice-president in the 1961 presidential poll. Protectionist policies allowed local manufacturers to control the economy from 1949 to 1962, discouraging them from becoming competitive. Diosdado Macapagal, father of incumbent President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo, was the president from 1961 to 1965. Before he became president, he authored the land reform program as a legislator and was vice-president to Garcia. As president, Macapagal began a five-year socio-economic program by removing imports control and liberalizing foreign exchange. It was Macapagal who declared June 12 as the national Independence Day. In 1962, the Macapagal administration began devaluing the peso by half to around 3.90 to the US dollar. Macapagal initiated a shift in investments from the light industries to chemicals, steel and industrial equipment. He was also one of the proponents of the MAPHILINDO, a trade bloc of three South East Asian countries – the Philippines, Malaysia, Indonesia. This bloc later expanded to what is now the Association of the Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN). By 1965, foreign capital was present in nearly a third of the country's capital stock. Martial Law Ferdinand Marcos, the Senate president, defeated Macapagal in the presidential election to become the country's tenth president in November 1965. A close ally of the United States, Marcos launched military campaigns against the insurgents including the communist Hukbalahap and Moro rebels in Mindanao. In August 1967, Manila hosted a summit that led to the creation of the ASEAN. With his reelection in 1969, Marcos had to contend with worsening civil strife. An ideologist named Jose Ma. Sison founded the Communist Party of the Philippines on December 26, 1968. It was during the same year that University of the Philippines Nur Misuari founded the Moro National Liberation Front (MNLF), the armed wing of Islamic resistance movement. In June 1971, the government convened the Constitutional Convention to amend the Constitution. Ironically, Marcos declared Martial Law on September 21, 1972, following a series of bombings in Metro Manila, He abolished Congress, curtailed freedom of the press, imposed curfews, ordered the arrest of his political enemies, prohibited labour unions, and controlled the economy with the help of his cronies. Although his wife Imelda was credited for building some of the country's finest monuments, she was criticized for personal extravagance, a form of which was maintaining a collection of 3,000 pairs of shoes. Green Revolution The so-called green revolution in the early 1970s, which introduced new farming technologies, enabled the Philippines to export rice to its neighbours. The International Rice Research Institute was established in Los Banos town, Laguna province where Thai, Vietnamese and other Asian researchers trained to develop their own rice production. Thailand would later become the world's largest rice exporter and the Philippines one of the largest rice importers. With the introduction of new farming technologies, the Philippines became heavily dependent on importer fertilizers, which are mostly fuel-based. The increase in world crude oil prices also pushed prices of fertilizers, to the detriment of Filipino farmers trying to adopt the modern technologies. Chinese Tycoons On June 9, 1975, the Marcos administration signed a joint communiqué with Communist China to restore official diplomatic relations. The Communiqué recognized that "there is but one China, of which Taiwan is an integral part. In return, China vowed not to interfere in the internal affairs of the Philippines and refrained from providing any substantial support to the Communist Party of the Philippines, the largest insurgent group in the country. The largest success story in the Philippines actually involved Chinese merchants who left China in pursuit of business opportunities abroad. Unlike rich American investors, Chinese migrants came to the Philippines with little money but large determination that the country's democratic society would help them become rich. True enough, they found goldmine in the Philippines. Today, the richest individuals in the Philippines have Chinese names, including billionaires such as Lucio Tan, Henry Sy, John Gokongwei, and George Ty. Together, they are the largest group of investors in the Philippines and control most of the largest companies in the country. Overseas Workers Under Martial Law, one man other than Marcos would singularly define labour relations in the Philippines and the role of the Filipino workers in the world. Labour Minister Blas Ople, a former journalist, authored the Labor Code on November 1, 1974 and launched the overseas employment program in 1976, which would send young and talented Filipinos who could not find work at home to other countries for dollar-earning jobs. Ople obtained the permission of Marcos to deploy thousands of Filipino workers overseas to meet the growing need of Saudi Arabia, Iran, Iraq and the United Arab Emirates for skilled workers and the rising demand for Filipino seamen in flag-of-convenience vessels. Hesitant at first, Marcos later conceded to the proposal, if only to tame the growing militancy building among the hearts of the young and intelligent Filipinos who could not find job opportunities in their own land. The Philippine Overseas Employment Administration (POEA) and the Overseas Workers Welfare Administration (OWWA) were established to intensify recruitment of Filipino workers. This would make the Philippines the third largest destination of dollar remittances in the world, next to the more populous countries of India and Mexico. The Marcos administration also tried to court foreign investors, by committing guarantees against nationalization and imposing restrictions on trade-union activity. However, the blatant record of human rights abuses by the military under his administration was a big turnoff among foreigners. Under Martial law, the military and the police killed, abused, or arrested at least 10,000 Filipinos, including some of the brightest students and intellectuals. Many had disappeared without a trace. While Marcos lifted martial law on January 17, 1981 in time for the visit of Pope John Paul II to Manila in February, he maintained most of his powers as a dictator. Benigno Aquino, an opposition senator living in asylum in the US, decided to return to Manila in 1983. His death, from assassins' bullets at the tarmac of the Manila International Airport, sparked adverse sentiments against the Marcos administration. Bankruptcy As the economy stagnated under the Marcos administration because of a mix of bad economic policies, corruption and uncontrolled population growth, the government had to resort to foreign borrowing to finance the fiscal deficit. In October 1983, the Central Bank notified its creditors about its plan to default payment on debt amounting to US$24.6 billion. With the growing loss of confidence by the business community, the peso depreciated by as much as 21 percent in 1983. The gross domestic product shrank by 6.8 percent in 1984 and by 3.8 percent in 1985. Emboldened by Marcos' dipping popularity, the opposition gathered around Aquino's widow, Corazon Cojuangco Aquino, who would later challenge Marcos in the 1986 snap presidential election. When Batasang Pambansa (National Assembly) declared Marcos the winner amid allegations of widespread electoral fraud, protesters, buoyed by Manila archbishop Jaime Cardinal Sin, trooped to the streets. Following the defection of Defense Minister Juan Ponce Enrile and Armed Forces vice chief Fidel Ramos from Marcos, protesters began converging along EDSA near Ortigas Avenue, which would culminate in the ouster of Marcos from Malacanang Palace on February 25, 1986. The media called the bloodless uprising as the 1986 EDSA People Power Revolution - something that political groups would later thought could be replicated time and again. Democratic Rule After Marcos, his family and his cronies fled from the Philippines, Aquino became president, organized a new government, freed the political prisoners and tried to restore democratic rule in the country. In February 1987, her government approved a new Constitution, which would later be subjected to heated debates over its restrictive provisions on foreign participation in the economy. The 1987 Constitution restored the presidential system of government with a bicameral legislature composed of the Senate and the House of Representatives and an independent judiciary headed by the Supreme Court chief justice. To avoid a replication of Marcos' excesses, the Constitution limited the president's stay in office to one six-year term. It also created the autonomous regions of Muslim Mindanao and Cordillera and put agrarian reform as the cornerstone of the government's plan for social transformation. A renegade faction in the Philippine military launched a series of coup attempts against the Aquino presidency. Perception of political instability dampened economic activities and refrained the economy from matching the large strides taken by its Asian neighbors in the 1980s and 1990s. By this time, Singapore, Malaysia and Thailand have overtaken the Philippines in the race towards industrialization. The Arroyo administration, while taking pride of having restored democracy, failed to bring the economy on track towards industrialization, and one of the factors singled out was the president's political inexperience and lack of consistency in pushing for economic reforms. In the 1992 presidential election, Aquino endorsed the candidacy of her chosen successor – Defense Secretary Fidel Ramos. In June 1991, Mount Pinatubo's powerful eruption sent tons of ashes around the planet's atmosphere. Subsequent lava/lahar flow buried several towns in Central Luzon and jolted the economy. The natural tragedy also forced American soldiers at Clark Field and Subic Bay to withdraw from their bases earlier than stipulated. The US turned over to the Philippine government the two bases with total assets amounting to US$1.3 billion. The Philippine government later transformed the two bases into special economic zones. Liberalisation In 1992, Fidel Ramos was elected President. He began his term amid an energy crisis, which plunged the country literally into darkness. This he was able to resolve by inviting foreign investors to take part in the so-called build-operate-transfer (BOT) scheme, where they would serve as independent power producers (IPPs) enjoying a lot of incentives and guaranteed market. While it brought light to Filipino households, the scheme would later translate to high electricity rates. In 1995, the Ramos administration also had to contend with a rice shortage, as a result of low agricultural production and poorly managed importation program. Since then, the government has authorised the National Food Authority (NFA) to import rice at will in order to prepare for any shortage in domestic stock. The Ramos presidency was also responsible for economic reforms such as privatisation of government assets, trade and banking liberalisation and deregulation, which would push annual trade growth at double-digit levels and draw in large-ticket foreign investments. By 1996, the Philippines was described as a newly industrialising economy along with the likes of Thailand and Malaysia. It was also under the Ramos presidency that communism was legalised, and some leftist organisations would later join Congress as partylist groups. The government and the Moro National Liberation Front (MNLF) headed by Nur Misuari would sign a peace agreement that would establish a peace zone in southern Philippines. However, other militant rebel groups such as the Moro Islamic Liberation Front (MILF) and Abu Sayyaf would continue waging a war against the government for a Islamic state in the south. What Ramos failed to accomplish is the amendment to the 1987 Constitution to remove the restriction on foreign ownership of land and public utilities, which limits maximum ownership to 40 percent. The opposition party accused him of trying to tinker with the charter to remove the six-year term limit of the president and in the process perpetuate his stay in power. In the end, he had to give up such attempt under the weight of public opinion. Financial Crisis With the outbreak of the Asian financial crisis, the Philippine economy contracted by 0.6 percent in 1998, the same year Joseph Estrada, a popular politician with links to the movie industry, became president. The economy actually grew although at a slower pace at 3.4 percent in 1999 and at 4 percent in 2000 even as the inflation and interest rates began to decline. In comparison, growth reached 5.2 percent under the Ramos presidency in 1997. While Estrada got the backing of Filipino-Chinese businessmen by reducing the problem of kidnapping, he did not get the same support from other "elite" businessmen. Despite appointing top economists, Estrada, a former college dropout, could not convince the "high society" that he could resolve the country's economic woes. Ironically, what brought down the Estrada administration was not his economic policies, seen by many as not substantially different from those of Ramos, but the perception of wide corruption in his administration. In October 2000, a former ally implicated Estrada in illegal gambling payoffs and kickbacks. Reports that he has many wives housed in different mansions also got Estrada indifferent treatment from the Church, which was a force behind the 1986 People's Power Revolution. EDSA 2 In December 2000, the House of Representatives impeached Estrada. The subsequent impeachment trial at the Senate was aborted when senators from the opposition party walked out of the courtroom, triggering street demonstrations reminiscent of the 1986 revolt. Within hours after the walkout, the crowd at EDSA grew into millions of anti-Estrada protesters. When political and military leaders withdrew their support from Estrada, Supreme Court Chief Justice Hilario Davide swore Vice President Gloria Mapacagal Arroyo as the next president on January 20, 2001. Arroyo, a daughter of former President Diosdado Macapagal, came to Malacanang with a promise to clean the government of corrupt officials and bring down the number of poor Filipinos, which represents a third of the total population. In her first year in office, she faced numerous challenges starting with the May 1 rebellion, instigated by the Estrada camp to regain the presidency. The rebellion proved futile, as the highly politicised military and the police remained loyal to Arroyo. She also had to contend with Muslim extremists, who began to target cities in their attacks. Following the terrorist attacks in the US on September 11, 2001, the Philippines was one of the first countries to express support for a US-led international campaign against terrorism. On the economic front, Congress passed the liberalisation of the retail trade sector and the Electric Power Industry Reform Act of 2001, which aims to privatise the state-owned National Power Corporation. The Arroyo administration also promoted business process outsourcing (BPO), information technology, tourism, and mining as key investment areas for foreign companies. Trade with other Asian countries was also given importance in view of the declining trade volume with the United States. Telecommunications One particular industry, which has led economic growth since 2000 is telecommunications, although this proved to be a bane for other industries as Filipinos cut their expenditures on other items to buy mobile phones and pay for monthly network services. By 2005, it is estimated that half of the 85 million Filipinos would have mobile phones, a high penetration rate for a developing market. Because of the global economic slump following the September 11 attacks, the GDP grew by merely 1.8 percent in 2001. Growth reached 4.3 percent in 2002 and 4.7 percent in 2003 even as the Arroyo administration confronted communist and Islamic insurgency problems and a shocking military coup in July 2003. After surviving the coup, Arroyo won the May 2004 presidential election over Estrada's close friend and popular actor Fernando Poe Jr. Economic growth reached 6.1 percent in 2004, the highest in 15 years, although this was negated by high inflation and uncontrolled unemployment rates which were more felt by the poor. Fiscal Deficit Pressed by economists to narrow the burgeoning fiscal deficit, President Arroyo urged Congress to pass a package of tax reform measures aimed at achieving a balanced budget by the end of her term in 2010. Because of a long history of budget deficits, the public debt hit more than 130 percent of the GDP in 2003 and has been rising since then. Different sectors, however, criticised the administration for passing a heavier burden of taxation on the people at a time crude oil prices were hovering at historic high levels and pushing prices of goods and services beyond the capacity of ordinary consumers. By the second half of 2005, there were signs that the fiscal deficit was narrowing, even with the delay in the implementation of the Expanded Value Added Tax (EVAT) law, which raised by 2 percentage points the tax rate on consumer products and services to 12 percent and by 3 percentage points the corporate income tax to 35 percent. The new EVAT law, which was expanded to cover fuel and electricity, took effect on November 1, 2005. New Constitution As the popularity of President Arroyo dipped to the lowest level amid allegations that she bought her way to the presidency in the 2004 presidential elections, she was given an option to correct the loopholes in the political system by amending the 1987 Constitution. She formed a Consultative Commission to recommend charter amendments focusing on lifting all restrictions to foreign investments and paving the way for a shift in the form of government from a presidential, central system into a parliamentary, federal system. Posted by Text Mates at 4:16 PM 0 comments Labels: Economy, History, National, Social Filipino Inventions Solar powered Balut maker The College of Engineering and Agro-Industrial Technology at the University of the Philippines-Los Banos has invented a solar "balut" maker. Engineer Fernando Paras Jr. said the machine, which covers an area of five square meters, is actually an incubator that can process duck eggs into embryonated eggs or balut for 15 to 17 days. Traditionally, balut makers in Pateros have been using electricity for incubation. The new invention is a two-way solar-powered system, with the solar water heater serving as the primary heat source while the photovoltaic cells serve as the auxiliary heat source regulating the temperature inside the incubator. The machine can process up to 4,000 eggs at the same time. This can double the income of farmers. SMS reader for the Blind A group of four engineering students from the De La Salle University invented the SMS reader, a device that allows the blind to read and send text messages. The prototype is composed of a black box with a Braille display that mimics the interface of a mobile phone. A data cable is connected to a slot in the black box. Superkalan Narciso Mosuela of La Union province invented the "superkalan", a novelty stove that can be fired with anything that burns—wood, paper, dried dung and leaves, corn cobs, and coco shells. The body of this stove is made of aluminum alloy, with a cast iron heat intensifier. For his invention, the Food and Agricultural Organization (FAO) bestowed on Mosuela the "best design award" for Third World country category in 1987. Aside from the superkalan, Mr. Mosuela invented a functional rice thresher and other kitchen gadgets. Anti-cancer cream In November 2005, Filipino inventor Rolando dela Cruz won the gold medal for his "DeBCC" anti-cancer cream at the prestigious International Inventor's Forum in Nuremberg, Germany. The "DeBCC" cream, developed from cashew nuts and other local herbs, was chosen over 1,500 entries as the "most significant invention" of the year. According to Mr. dela Cruz, the cream was a simple answer to basal cell carcinoma (BCC), the most common type of skin cancer worldwide. BCC affects around 800,000 Americans every year, according to the Skin Care Foundation. BCC also affects 500,000 Europeans and 190,000 Australians every year. Mole Remover In 2000, Rolando dela Cruz developed an ingenuous formula that could easily remove deeply grown moles or warts from the skin without leaving marks or hurting the patient. His formula was extracted from cashew nut (Annacardium occidentale), which is common in the Philippines. The formula won for dela Cruz a gold medal in International Invention, Innovation, Industrial Design and Technology Exhibition in Kuala Lumpur in September 2000. In March 1997, dela Cruz established RCC Amazing Touch International Inc., which runs clinics engaged "in a non-surgical removal of warts, moles and other skin growths, giving the skin renewed energy and vitality without painful and costly surgery." Modular Housing System Edgardo Vazquez won a World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) gold medal in 1995 for developing a modular housing system. Such a system called Vazbuilt is reportedly capable of building within weeks a house with prefabricated materials that can withstand typhoons and earthquakes. Ironically, Vasquez is not getting enough support from the Philippine government to propagate his technology, which could help provide shelter to some five million Filipino families without their own homes. Vazquez is the national president of the Filipino Inventors Society. Super Bunker Formula-L In 1996, Rudy Lantano Sr., a scientist from the Philippine Department of Science and Technology (DOST), won the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) gold medal for developing Super Bunker Formula-L, a revolutionary fuel half-composed of water. The mix burns faster and emits pollutants, 95 percent less than those released to the air by traditional fuel products. The inventor said his invention is a result of blending new ingredients and additives with ordinary oil products through agitation and mixing, which is a very safe process. The initial plan was to commercially produce two million liters of Alco-Diesel, two million liters of Lan-Gas and an unlimited quantity of Super Bunker Formula-L each day for customers in Luzon. Natural Gas Vehicle The Department of Energy (DOE) has developed a vehicle that runs on natural gas, whose rich deposits remain untapped under the Philippine seabed. The project's main objective is to look into the potential of natural gas as an alternative fuel to conventional petrol and diesel for the transport sector. The natural gas vehicle (NVG) has been road-tested in Isabela where an existing natural gas supply from the PNOC Gas Plant is located. Test runs have also been made in Cagayan, Ifugao and Mountain Province. The test vehicle used was the Isuzu Hi-Lander 4JA-1, direct injected diesel engine. The use of natural gas as a fuel is cheaper. On a gallon-equivalent basis, natural gas costs an average of 15 to 40 percent less than gasoline and diesel. There are over one million NVGs in the world today, according to the International Association for Natural Gas Vehicles. Lamp Fixing Invention A Filipino inventor has developed a technology, which could revive a busted lamp (pundido) and give it more years of functional life than those of new ones. Acclaimed by the Filipino Inventors Society as timely and revolutionary, the Nutec system can prolong the life of fluorescent lamps up to seven years. Nutec was developed by New World Technology, headed by president Eric Ngo and chosen as the "Product of the Year" at the Worldbex 2000 Building and Construction Exposition held at the Manila Hotel. Engineer Benjamin S. Santos, national president of the Inventors Society, called Nutec a timely invention. "Tubig Talino" The Department of Science and Technology claimed that it has developed "Tubig Talino", an iodine-rich drinking water that treats micronutrient deficiencies responsible for goiter, mental and physical retardation, and birth defects. "Tubig Talino" is actually a mixture of 20 liters of water and 15 ml of "Water Plus + I2". Consumption of five glasses a day of this iodine fortification in drinking water is expected to provide 120 micrograms of iodine, which meets 100 percent of the recommended dietary allowance (RDA) of a male adult. Feminine Hygiene Product Inventor Dr. Virgilio Malang won a gold medal for his invention "Psidium Guajava Effervescing Gynecological Insert", a silver medal for his "Patient Side-Turning Hospital Bed", and three bonze medals for his inventions "external vaginal cleanser", "light refracting earpick", and "broom's way of hanging" at the Seoul International Fair in held South Korea in December 2002. There were 385 inventions from 30 countries that joined the competitions. Patis Contrary to popular belief, there was no fish sauce or Patis yet during the Spanish occupation. Patis began to become a part of most Filipinos' diet only after the Japanese occupation. Here is an account of how an enterprising lady discovered the fermentation of Patis. Immediately after the war, the family of Ruperta David or Aling Tentay started a dried fish business. One day, Aling Tentay stored in jars some salted fish that turned into fragments even before they dried. While in jars, the fish fragments turned into a liquid substance that tasted like our Patis today. Thus the beginning of the thriving Patis business of Aling Tentay, which was officially registered in 1949 and is known today as Tentay Food and Sauces Inc. (Source: Philippine Daily Inquirer) A Showcase of Ingenuity Nothing perhaps has been associated with Filipino technology as much as the country's pride - jeepney. The word "jeep" evolved from the military designation, general-purpose or G.P., of a light vehicle first used by the Americans in World War II. Developed by the U.S. Army Quartermaster Corps, this vehicle was powered by a four-cylinder engine and was classified as a quarter-ton truck in carrying capacity. It had served as a command vehicle, reconnaissance car, and ammunition carrier. The American soldiers brought these vehicles to the Philippines in the 1940s. After the war, these vehicles were left by the Americans and converted by the Filipinos into public utility vehicles. Employing artistic and indigenous designs, the Filipinos came up with a longer, well-decorated, techni-colored and sleeker vehicle, which they later called jeepney. From the standard military jeep, the body was extended to accommodate between 20 to 30 passengers. Modern jeepneys now sport very colorful and intricate paintings, fancy adornments, and metallic decors reflective of Filipino sentiments, values, and culture. The town of Las Pinas has been recognized as the jeepney-producing center in the country. Today, public utility jeepneys or PUJs serve as the primary means of transportation in most provinces. For this, the Philippines came to be known as the "land of the jeepneys".
79
82
SSchool and Office Supplies Manufacturer | Hamelin Group Hamelin, a French stationery company, is a leader in the field of manufacturing school and office products for children, students and professionals.
83
courtweek.com - Archives: 2011November 1, 2011The Law of Post-Halloween Legal StandardsToday is All Saints Day or All Hallows, a holy day of obligation for some. To others, it''s just the day after Halloween -- a day they forget was once merely All Hallows Eve. Some spend All Hallows recovering from the revelry of the night before, and some are still on the streets in the wee hours of the holy day. Our Case of the Week examines once such alleged citizen on the streets and the unfortunate lesson she learned about differing standards of legal review in a California appellate decision handed down last week.Let''s Make a DealAngelique Bongiovanni found herself in the legal system in 2009, charged with possession of methamphetamine in two separate cases. In a deal that would come back to haunt her on the day after Halloween, she made a plea bargain in one of the cases. Under the plea agreement, Ms. Bongiovanni pleaded no contest, and was placed on probation for three years. As an added bonus, her 365-day jail sentence was suspended to run concurrently with the sentence from her other drug bust.It seemed like a good deal at the time, and it would have been...if only she hadn''t allegedly been out with the witches, warlocks, goblins, and alleged gang members on the streets of Los Angeles on All Hallows 2009.All Hallows HijinksOn Nov. 1, 2009, Wendy Diaz lived with her husband and three children in a Los Angeles neighborhood with a gang problem. Perhaps not unlike Chauncey and Wadsworth fighting over tee times, the proper procedure for shaking martinis, or the best way to train a polo pony, Ms. Diaz''s neighborhood faced fights from the gentlemen and ladies of the rival gangs, "Vincent Town," and "Columbus Street." Police arrested a Columbus Street gang member for breaking into the Diaz home.After taking her children trick-or-treating on Halloween evening, Ms. Diaz ventured outside at approximately 1:00 in the morning of All Hallows to look for a friend parking on the street. Instead, Ms. Diaz said she saw Ms. Bongiovanni accompanied by a companion in a pumpkin costume.According to Ms. Diaz, Ms. Bongiovanni proceeded to engage in an expletive-laden tirade of threats. To accommodate the gentle readers of Courtweek.com who would rather witness a debate between Chauncey and Wadworth on the best ways to make covert contributions to the Republican National Committee instead of enduring the vile threats of alleged gang members, we will attempt to sanitize the vulgarity of Ms. Bongiovanni''s alleged utterances.Ms. Diaz said Ms. Bongiovanni approached her and called her an [expletive deleted] snitcher, adding, "You been [expletive deleted] snitching.""You and your family are coming down," Ms. Bongiovanni stated allegedly, as she is said to have added for emphasis, "You [expletive deleted] rata," and "[expletive deleted] all biccicletas."To assist our readers in appreciating the full flavor of Ms. Bongiovanni''s supposed soliloquy, we should note that each deleted expletive is a version of the same slang word referring to an act of sexual intimacy. In addition, "rata" can refer to a Soviet fighter plane from the 1930s, plants from the Metrosideros genus in New Zealand, or rat in Spanish. We''ll let you decide which one Ms. Bongiovanni might have meant. Also, biccicletas is a derivation of the Spanish word for bicycles. Seems innocuous enough. However, in Ms. Bongiovanni''s case, People v. Bongiovanni, California''s Second District Court of Appeal noted biccicletas was also a term Columbus Street gang members used as a sign of disrespect (or "dissing" in gangspeak) when addressing the upstanding citizens of the Vincent Town gang.Ms. Diaz reported the incident to police the same day and gave law enforcement a description of the woman who threatened her. She then identified Ms. Bongiovanni from a photo line up. Police knew Ms. Bongiovanni to be a member of the Columbus Street gang for almost a decade and that she went by the gang name, "Diabla." It wasn''t difficult police work...Ms. Bongiovanni sported Columbus Street gang tattoos on her body. If that weren''t enough, police said she also admitted she was a member.Winning 10-2?However, nifty tattoos notwithstanding, Ms. Bongiovanni denied she was a member of the gang at trial. In addition, Ms. Bongiovanni noted she was approximately 50 pounds heavier than Ms. Diaz had described her. Then again, it was Halloween, and with her friend in that pumpkin costume, she probably got a lot of candy. Despite Ms. Diaz''s testimony and police testimony citing various Columbus Street gang activities including murder, assaults, car theft, and narcotics distribution, the jury deadlocked, and it''s vote was 10-2 in favor of acquitting Ms. Bongiovanni. The court declared a mistrial and thus granted prosecutors'' motion to dismiss the charges pursuant to California Penal Code section 1385.So, it was time for Ms. Bongiovanni to do the happy dance. Sure, she was on probation, but the charges were dropped. No probation violation there...or so she thought.At an ensuing probation violation hearing, Ms. Bongiovanni argued she had not violated her probation in the All Hallows morning incident. She claimed the whole thing was a case of mistaken identity, and she argued the jury''s 10-2 vote in her favor showed she hadn''t done anything wrong.Most members of the jury may have believed her, but the judge wasn''t buying it. More importantly, for purposes of sending Ms. Bongiovanni to the slammer for a probation violation, the opinions of those 10 jurors didn''t matter.You see, California probation violation determinations differ from a criminal trial in that the fact-finder in a probation violation hearing is the judge -- not a jury. In addition, where in a criminal trial, the legal standard is proof beyond a reasonable doubt, in a probation violation hearing, the standard is only a preponderance of the evidence. In other words, there can be a fair amount of doubt as to whether you did it, but if the judge weighs the evidence, and there''s more evidence indicating guilt rather than innocence, you lose.In Ms. Bongiovanni''s case, the judge noted the cops testified at trial that she was a member of the Columbus Street gang, a Columbus Street member was arrested in connection with the break-in at the Diaz home, and that Ms. Diaz identified Ms. Bongiovanni as the woman who threatened her. In the minds of 10 of 12 jurors, that wasn''t enough to prove anything beyond a reasonable doubt. However, under the preponderance of the evidence standard, that''s all the judge needed.In upholding the trial court''s decision that Ms Bongiovanni violated her probation, California''s Second District Court of Appeal wrote, "Appellant''s argument that a jury vote of of 10-2 for acquittal supports her credibility is not persuasive because the fact finder in the probation violation hearing was the trial judge, not the jury. Because probation revocation differs substantially from criminal prosecution and the facts supporting the revocation need only be proved by a preponderance of the evidence, we find substantial evidence to support the trial court''s finding that the appellant violated her probation."So, Ms. Bongiovanni had her probation revoked, and it was three years of incarceration for her. The moral of this week''s Case of the Week: if you''re on probation and walking around with a giant pumpkin on All Hallows, study legal standards of review before you go calling someone an [expletive deleted] Soviet fighter plane. __________________________October 22, 2011The Law of Flying DwarfsThose readers who enjoyed -- or perhaps didn''t enjoy -- this writer''s On Trial column in The National Law Journal may remember the saga of Dave the Dwarf. He fought to save the Constitution...while saving his livelihood in dwarf tossing. To commemorate the 10th anniversary of Dave the Dwarf''s epic legal battle--and because a Florida state representative is now trying to do in the legislature what Dave could not do in the courts--we now revisit the Law of Dwarf Tossing...and what it tells us about the 5th and 14th Amendments to the United States Constitution...as well as legislative and regulatory drafting in the state of Florida.Big Fun in a Little PackageDavid Flood is a gentleman of somewhat small stature: three foot two, to be exact. He''s also a Tampa, Fla., radio personality and quasi-celebrity. Known as Dave the Dwarf to his legions of little listeners and big fans on Tampa''s 93.3 FLZ radio, Mr. Flood also has had a side business, and that''s what made him a legal star. You see, for a fee, you could bring Dave the Dwarf to your birthday party, St. Patrick''s Day festival, bar mitzvah, or Millard Fillmore Inauguration Day celebration, and Dave would let you engage in the time-honored tradition of dwarf tossing.That''s right, you could put little Dave in a harness and toss him to your heart''s content. Dwarf tossing was a cultural phenomenon in the 1980s. It was the biggest thing since Members Only jackets. It seemed a good time was being had by all, as tiny torpedoes of humanity went airborne at parties.That was, until the Little People of America and their friends in the Florida Legislature intercepted the toss.Little LobbyistsNot everyone was amused by this zany brand of miniature fun. Among the concerned populace was a public interest organization known as Little People of America, Inc. The non-profit organization provides support and information to people of short stature, and states it is the only dwarfism support organization providing services to those afflicted with all of the over 200 types of dwarfism.Little People and others lobbied the Florida Legislature, and the result was the passage of Section 561.665, Florida Statutes, governing activities involving exploitation of people with Dwarfism in establishments selling alcohol.Not all little people supported the law, and one of them was Dave the Dwarf.Dave the Dwarf sued then-Florida Governor Job Bush in an attempt to overturn the law, arguing the law was an unconstitutional violation of his rights under the Due Process Clause of the 5th Amendment and the Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment.Specifically, Dave the Dwarf argued in Flood v. Bush, No. 8:01cv02261 (M.D. Fla. filed Nov. 28, 2001), that his due process rights were violated because the law failed to properly define those covered by the law, making the law unconstitutionally vague. He argued also that the law violated his equal protection rights because the law treated him differently than others. For instance, you could be tossed, I could be tossed, and Oprah Winfrey could be tossed (with a great degree of difficulty), but Dave the Dwarf could not be tossed...or so he thought.Banned or Not?The governor''s lawyers swung into action in an attempt to toss Dave the Dwarf right out of court. They argued dwarfs needed protection. Dave counted that was hogwash. Also, in addition to maintaining Gov. Bush should be dismissed from the suit, the Florida Attorney General''s Office argued that there was no constitutional violation because the law didnt really ban dwarf tossing.Turns out they were right.The law itself banned only "undertaking or permitting any contest or promotion or other form of recreational activity involving exploitation endangering the health, safety, and welfare of any person with dwarfism" in establishments selling alcoholic beverages. Nowhere did the law ban dwarf tossing specifically.Dave the Dwarf argued dwarf tossing was good for his welfare because he made money doing it. Note the language is "health, safety, and welfare," as opposed to "health, safety, or welfare." Dave the Dwarf might have been better off leaving the law alone, continuing his aerial acrobatics, and arguing he was in compliance with the law because dwarf tossing promoted his welfare.As it was, the trial court tossed Dave out of the courthouse, holding the law did not ban dwarf tossing and that -- although the law mandated that the Division of Alcoholic Beverages and Tobacco of Floridas Department of Professional Regulation promulgate regulations on the issue -- they had failed to do it. While the regulators may have been out at the beach listening to Jimmy Buffet tunes and drinking margaritas, Dave the Dwarf could have been spending his days flying through the warm Florida breezes.So why is Florida State Rep. Ritch Workman trying to repeal the law while everyone from Jon Stewart to your short Uncle Freddy is weighing in on the issue?Well, it appears those regulators finally finished getting wasted away in Margaritaville, cruised on back home to Tallahassee, and did some regulating.The Oprah RuleThe Division promulgated Section 3.048 of Chapter 61A of its regulations, entitled, "Exploitation of Dwarfs." Unlike their friends in the Legislature, the regulators did more precise drafting and included dwarf tossing specifically. The regulation provided in subsection (2): "Any activity described as dwarf-tossing is specifically included within those acts of exploitation prohibited by this rule."Of course, there was also subsection (3), which could be called the Oprah Rule. It provided: "Nothing contained herein shall be construed to prohibit dwarfs from engaging in non-exploitative sporting or recreational events of the type engaged in by persons who are not dwarfs."So now we''ve come full circle: Oprah Winfrey can be tossed (if one has a large catapult), but Dave the Dwarf is, once again, left out of all the fun...unless Rep. Workman has his way. His bill, HB 4063, is pending in the Florida Legislature. In the meantime, you can catch Dave the Dwarf on his radio show, What Would The Dwarf Do?, where presumably, he is not being tossed...at least not yet.__________________________August 25, 2011The Law of Wiener WarsOnce the gentleman from New York''s Ninth Congressional District resigned his House seat for exposing his wiener, you may have thought you would be finished with bad wiener jokes for a while. You would be wrong.This week, mighty corporate litigants have been battling it out in the U.S. District Court for Northern District of Illinois in a wacky wiener war. The case of Sara Lee Corp. v. Kraft Foods Inc., features charges of hot dog blasphemy. Sara Lee, the makers of Ball Park Franks, and Kraft, the friendly folks bringing you the venerable Oscar Mayer wiener, both claim the other has disparaged its products in violation of federal and state law.Seriously though, we all read Upton Sinclair''s The Jungle in school. Thus, everyone thinks hot dogs are comprised of animal parts swept up off the factory floor anyway. How can one disparage a hot dog?Oh, I Wish I Were...Sara Lee fired the first shot in the Weiner War, suing Kraft in May 2009, claiming Kraft violated both the federal Trademark Act of 1946, 15 U.S.C. 1051 et seq., known commonly as the "Lanham Act," the Illinois Consumer Fraud and Deceptive Practices Act, and other Illinois state laws.In its federal complaint, Sara Lee alleged Kraft claimed falsely that Oscar Mayer wieners were the "100% pure beef hot dog" when it knew Oscar Meyer wieners contained other mouth-watering ingredients, such as sodium lactate, sodium diacetate, sodium phosphates, salt, corn syrup, and dextrose. Sara Lee claimed non-beef ingredients comprised approximately 20 percent of an Oscar Meyer wiener. Of course, Sara Lee conceded that most of this non-beef 20 percent was water.Sara Lee claimed Ball Park Franks were disadvantaged becausebeing the honest dudes they are Sara Lee would not compete with Oscars little lies by claiming falsely that Ball Park Franks were 100 percent pure beef.But, Oscar Meyers alleged crimes against humanity and hot dog harmony didn''t end there.In advertising paraphrasing Oscar Mayers famous jingles for its hot dogs and bologna, Kraft claimed, The best tasting beef hot dog has a name. Its O-S-C-A-R, and These days, its Ball Park and Hebrew National who are wishing they were an Oscar Mayer wiener. In addition, Kraft invited customers to Try the taste that knocked the others out of the park.Just as it claimed the 100 percent beef claim was false, Sara Lee claimed these comparisons against its hot dog were false as well.Sara Lees attorney, Richard Leighton of Washington, D.C.''s Keller and Heckman LLP, claimed the evil Oscar Mayer even cheated on taste tests, claiming testers were served boiled Ball Park franks on a paper plate with no bun, no ketchup, no mustard, nothing.It must have been a big taste test error because the bouquet of the sodium lactate and dextrose really pairs well with mustard.Not only were these claims placed in print and electronic media, Sara Lee claimed Kraft even put them on its Wienermobile, a vehicle described by Sara Lee as a hot dog-shaped vehicle that promotes Oscar Mayer and its products in interstate commerce.Have you ever seen the Wienermobile? This writer has. It looks like a rolling phallic sex toy designed to appeal to the prurient interest in violation of the U.S. Supreme Courts holding in Miller v. California.Sara Lee argued that, by making these allegedly false claims in interstate commerce, Kraft violated section 43(a)(1)(B) of the Lanham Act. Section 43(a)(1)(B) prohibits false or misleading advertising or marketing that damages another''s product. In addition, Sara Lee argued these false claims violated the applicable Illinois state laws.Not surprisingly, Oscar Mayer saw things differently.My [Fill in the Blank] Has a First NameMighty Oscar fought back, counterclaiming against Ball Park''s protective corporate mother, Sara Lee. Kraft argued the 100 percent beef was accurate because, although Oscar Mayer contained additives, beef was the only meat in Oscar Mayer. In addition, Kraft believed it needed to illustrate Oscar''s beefiness because of the public perception that hot dogs contain mystery meats.Damn you, Upton Sinclair!In addition, Kraft argued Sara Lee had its own hot dog advertising shenanigans.In a corporate legal battle example of Pee-wee Hermann''s famous retort, "I know you are, but what am I?," Kraft argued Sara Lee made its own false claims about how much beef there was in Oscar''s tubesteak. In addition, Kraft argued Sara Lee mislead consumers with taste tests by professional chefs proclaiming that Ball Park was America''s best franks.All jokes aside, the Wiener War in Sara Lee Corp. v. Kraft Foods Inc., may change the way companies market their products and establish limits for what merchants can say about their products and their competitors in advertising.Meanwhile, the court battle continues with weighty questions, such as "Do a bunch of San Francisco chefs know anything about Chicago hot dogs?" and, if you thought hot dog litigation was bad, just wait until companies start suing each other over other meats lots of people hate.When commenting on the litigation, Sara Lee''s Ball Park product director, Chuck Hemmingway said, "Simply put, we believe that these untrue statements are a bunch of bologna."First, they attack Oscar''s hot dogs, and now Oscar''s bologna? Mr. Hemmingway may want to watch out for the speeding Wienermobile. Oscar is not happy.____________________________August 12, 2011The Law of A&E''s Reality TV TroublesReality television tends to get lots of people into lots of trouble. From going to the slammer for failing to pay taxes on reality winnings to shooting sweet, innocent puppies with arrows, reality TV contestants have often been models of bad behavior. But what happens when it''s the reality show''s network getting in trouble? Our Case of the Week examines what happens when a reality show insinuates falsely that a woman tried to smuggle drugs into a jail via her vaginal cavity.Family DayMarlorita Battle was minding her own business visiting her husband, an inmate at the Riverbend Maximum Security Institution in Nashville, Tenn. Little did she know she was about to become a big, big star.On the day she chose to visit the prison, the A&E Television Network reality show, The Squad: Prison Police, was there, too. The Riverbend facility apparently had a drug problem, and there were allegations the contraband made its way into the prison compliments of visiting family members.It was time for some riveting reality TV drama.The episode of The Squad: Police Prison entitled, Conspiracy, began with Tennessee Corrections Special Agent John Fisher describing the Riverbend prison''s drug problem. He noted that an informant had indicated a woman was smuggling drugs into the prison on a regular basis."We''re expecting this lady today," Agent Fisher said, as A&E splashed Mr. Battle''s face on the screen.As Ms. Battle began what might have been a pleasant visit with her husband and small child, the A&E cameras moved in, and agent Fisher said, "We''ve identified the female subject and inmate," as a mugshot of Ms. Battles husband is shown to television viewers.Keystone Kops and the Nitty GrittyMs. Battle''s husband had the toddler on his lap, and the couple sat next to each other. Ms. Battle''s husband caressed her, and then Ms. Battle visited the restroom, causing Agent Fisher to use his supposedly excellent cop skills to determine a crime was in progress. Not unlike the Keystone Kops, Agent Fisher and his bumbling band of merrymen swung into action."Hold on now, she''s going to the bathroom," Agent Fisher says, adding, "Typically, these women hide stuff up their vaginal cavity [sic] and then go to the restroom to take it out. Now we are starting to get to the nitty gritty."The camera then shows the doors to the bathroom, triggering more amazingly astute analysis from Agent Fisherthis time its about the size of Ms. Battles bladder and her efficiency in the latrine."There she is, right there. See how fast she went in there. She didn''t have time to pee," Agent Fisher says.Apparently, Agent Fisher, unaware of a bygone era when gentlemen and ladies would not utter the verb, "pee," on national television, has a special mathematical formula for computing travel times for urine through the urethra and into the toilet, hand washing, mirror check, and egress from a restroom.Ms. Battle, allegedly carrying something in her hand, proceeded to kiss her husband, A&E provided a crashing cymbal sound to enhance the reality TV drama, and Agent Fisher exclaimed, "Some [expletive deleted] just happened. I think we got ''em. I think we got them."It was time for the brave men of law enforcement to swing into action with A&E there to capture all the zany fun.First, they conducted a strip-search, and then, they placed Ms. Battle''s husband in a so-called "dry cell." Its called a dry cell because there''s no running water, and thus, no way to get rid of contraband.They kept Ms. Battle''s husband in the dry cell for 24 hours. He neither urinated nor defecated any contraband.After releasing Ms. Battle''s husband from the dry cell, Agent Fisher called the incident a "false alarm," but he added more commentary during the closing credits of The Squad: Prison Police that would become significant in subsequent litigation. This is Courtweek, after allyou know someone''s gonna get sued."If you are dirty, if you are smuggling in contraband, drugs, cellphones, tobacco, then we''re going to catch you. We might not get you today, maybe next week, next month, next year, but eventually, we''re going to catch up with you, and we''re gonna get you. That''s what we do," Agent Fisher said.Reality TV in CourtMs. Battle sued A&E Television Networks, Inc., and Wild Eyes Productions, Inc., the producers of The Squad: Prison Police, in federal district court in Tennessee, alleging defamation and intentional infliction of emotional distress.A&E and Wild Eyes moved to dismiss the suit, arguing on the defamation claim that The Squad: Prison Police was not capable of defamatory meaning, noting that the program doesn''t claim Ms. Battle committed a crime, but instead "accurately reports the results of an investigation."The court didn''t buy it.Noting the camera angles, the ominous music, and the made-for-TV commentary of Agent Fisher, U.S. District Judge Kevin Sharp wrote:"Even though the Program indicates that a search of Plaintiff revealed no drugs, a jury could conclude from the overall way that the Program is presented that Plaintiff was a drug smuggler who just happened not to get caught on September 12, 2009. Such an impression is enforced by Agent Fisher''s parting comments to the effect that while we might not get you today, we will get you sooner or later if you are smuggling drugs into a Tennessee prison."In rejecting the attempt by A&E and Wild Eye''s to dismiss Battle v. A&E Television Networks, Inc., the court cited also the U.S. Supreme Court case of Milkovich v. Lorain Journal Co., and held that statements of opinion were not automatically protected from libel and slander claims on First Amendment grounds."After all, ''expressions of ''opinion'' may often imply an assertion of objective fact," the court said.The lesson we take from this week''s Case of the Week is that, before airing a show, A&E might want to make sure the subject is guilty of genital smuggling--or at least not put a cop on the air insinuating the innocent party just got lucky on that one occasion. After all, they could just put a bunch of people on a desert island, have a some obnoxious people become roommates, or have really untalented people sing.________________David Horrigan is an attorney, journalist, analyst at The 451 Group, editorial director at Courtweek.com, and former staff reporter and assistant editor at The National Law Journal. His articles have appeared also in The Washington Examiner, Law Technology News, The American Lawyer, The New York Law Journal, The San Francisco Examiner, Corporate Counsel, Texas Lawyer, Florida Lawyer, and Daily Business Review. E-Mail: dhorrigan@courtweek.comAugust 5, 2011The Law of Pig FumesHave you ever had a neighbor who cooked food they may have found tasty and delicious, but that emanated aromas reminiscent of aged Roquefort cheese and dirty baby diapers left in a garbage can in the hot sun? It would be most annoying, but would it be unlawful? Would the pungent aromas be trespassing onto your property?Believe it or not, the issue has been litigated, and, in this week''s Case of the Week, we learn whether various airborne items--chemical particulate matter, sewage plant smells, and pig farm fumes--are trespassing when they waft onto your property. People may disagree, and that''s okay. As we''ll discover, the courts disagree as well.Organic AirOluf and Debra Johnson had decided to get back to nature. They converted their Minnesota conventional family farm into an organic farm, hoping to achieve an organic food certification that would allow them to charge more for their farm fresh products.Soon the Johnsons were ready to enjoy their new organic Eden. As they began their new all-natural existence, they stopped using pesticides, and Mr. Johnson posted signs around the property, letting everyone know that the Johnsons'' new tree-hugging Utopia was a chemical-free zone.There was just one problem. The neighbors hadn''t joined the eco-friendly bandwagon.The Johnsons may have embraced Mother Nature, but their next-door neighbor, the Paynesville Farmers Union Cooperative Oil Company, was still spraying away. Pesticides and herbicides drifted onto the Johnsons farm.Seeing the neighboring farm much like a chinchilla sanctuary might view a petrochemical plant as a neighbor, the Johnsons filed complaints in 1998, 2002, 2005, 2007, and 2008. The Minnesota Department of Agriculture cited Farmers Union four times for violating Minn.Stat. 18B.07, subd. 2(b) (2010), which made it illegal to apply a pesticide resulting in damage to adjacent property.Having had enough of chemicals wafting onto their pristine, virginal, chemical-free land, the Johnsons sued in Minnesota state court in January 2009, alleging, among other things, that Farmers Union committed trespass by allowing its chemical fumes to invade their property.A state trial court was unconvinced. It granted summary judgment to Farmers Union, on all claims, including the trespass claim, holding that trespass by particulate matter was not recognized in Minnesota.Leading the charge for Birkenstock-wearing lovers of fields and streams everywhere, the Johnsons appealed.The Law of Pig FumesIn rejecting the Johnsons'' claim, the trial court relied on the Minnesota Court of Appeals'' decision in Wendinger v. Forst Farms, Inc., 662 N.W.2d 546 (Minn. App. 2003), review denied (Minn. Aug. 5, 2003). The facts leading to the court battle in Wendinger are every homeowner''s worst nightmare.The Wendingers and the Forsts had been neighbors for years. They had also farmed their lands for years, and the Wendingers built a new home on their land in 1984.In 1994, the Forsts entered into an agreement with Wakefield Pork, Inc., to construct and maintain a pig farm to house Wakefields'' pigs. In a design sure to make anyone nauseous, liquid pig waste was stored in an outdoor concrete lagoon. The pig poo was then pumped and spread on the fields each fall.As the scents from farmyard feces filled the ambient air, the Wendingers began to complain. Then, they filed scores of complaints with state and local authorities. Finally, they sued.Among their allegations was a claim for trespass, arguing the pig fumes entering their property constituted trespass.A trial court dismissed the trespass claim, and the Wendingers appealed. The Minnesota Court of Appeals affirmed, holding that the Wendingers'' claim was one for nuisance--not trespass--because the odors of which the Wendingers complained interfered with the use and enjoyment of their land, not with their exclusive possession of it.The trial court in Johnson used the Wendinger decision for the proposition that particulate matter traveling from one property to another could not constitute trespass. However, the appellate court in Johnson held the trial court read too much into the pig fume decision.Pesticides are not Pig FumesAlthough the appellate court in Wendinger used the phrase, "particulate matter," the appellate court in Johnson held all particulate matter is not alike."Nothing in our Wendinger analysis indicates that we intended the term particulate matter to define a unique category of physical substances that can never constitute a trespass," the court said. Basically, the court held pesticides are not pig fumes."Unlike the plaintiffs in Wendinger, the Johnsons do not claim trespass based on transient odors. Instead, they primarily complain that the liquid chemicals that the cooperative sprayed into the air from neighboring fields drifted, landed, and remained on the Johnsons'' organic crops in detectable form, contaminating them." Judge Kevin Ross wrote for the court.Where the Wendinger court said there was no trespass because the pig fumes only affected enjoyment of the land, not possession of it, in ruling for the Johnsons, the appellate court in Johnson held that pesticides can affect both possession and enjoyment."The errant dispersion of pesticides, which contain chemicals designed to affect the land, can interfere with possession," the court said.So, the next time youre cooking your Aunt Betsys Garlic and Sauted Sardine Surprise, youre probably okay--even if it does ruin the ambiance of your neighbor''s garden. But, if you spray Raid, and it ends up in your neighbors Cheerios, he may just lawyer-up.______________________________July 28, 2011The Law of Protecting Celine DionHow important is protecting Celine Dion?After all, she sells millions of records, and many middle-aged women adore her. However, there are millions more who would rather spend a weekend in an Iranian torture chamber than listen to Ms. Dion sing the theme from Titanic for the 4,761st time.The woman may need some protection.Well, in a development that may damage U.S.-Canadian relations and come as a shock to fans of syrupy, schmaltzy pop music, a federal appellate court has held that serving as Celine Dion''s bodyguard does not constitute an original contribution of major significance in a field of endeavor sufficient to warrant the granting of a EB-1 visa.The BodyguardHad the court heard the case of Kevin Costner''s character protecting Whitney Houston in The Bodyguard, the whole thing might have gone differently. Mr. Costner''s character had made a major contribution in the field of celebrity personal protection by serving as a U.S. Secret Service agent. Such a high level of demonstrated skill and accomplishment might have brought him a visa.But what if, instead of being employed by the U.S. Department of the Treasury to be part of elite squad of livesavers, Mr. Costner had been employed to protect the top-selling female Canadian recording artist of all time by the pride of Charlemagne, Quebec herself?Would the United States grant a visa to the man who had protected Canada''s fourth most famous export--next to Keanu Reeves in Bill and Ted''s Excellent Adventure, maple syrup, and those deeply disturbing Sarah McLachlan commercials with the abused puppies and kittens?Nikolaos Skokos thought they should.Mr. Skokos, a security consultant for Celine Dion, applied to the United States Department of Homeland Security (DHS) for an EB-1 visa, and DHS rejected him. Apparently, DHS didnt think protecting the vocal cords that brought Beauty and the Beast to warm the hearts of little children was important enough.To see what an affront this might be to Ms. Dion''s throngs of adoring fans, it helps to know a little bit about the legal process behind granting visas to enter the United States.Legal TitanicIn addition to establishing a lottery for certain visas and dropping homosexuality as a basis for exclusion from the United States, the Immigration Act of 1990 created the EB-1 visa to attract immigrants with exceptional talents and skills.The EB-1 visa has three types, one for multinational executives and managers, one for professors and researchers, and one for applicants of extraordinary ability. Two of the ways an applicant can demonstrate this extraordinary ability are showing he had made original contributions of major significance to his field of endeavor under 8 C.F.R. 204.5(h)(3)(v) or showing she was paid a high salary compared to others in her field under 8 C.F.R. 204.5(h)(3)(ix).Not only did DHS feel that protecting Celine Dion did not meet this standard of excellence, the U.S. District Court for the District of Nevada agreed with DHS, holding for the government and rejecting an appeal filed by Mr. Skokos.In the legal equivalent of running the Titanic into an icebergwhile listening to Celine Dion sing about it as Leo and Kate flail in the frigid waters of the North Atlantic, Mr. Skokos appealed to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit in Skokos v. Department of Homeland Security, and fared no better.The appellate court held Mr. Skokos failed to establish that his work for Ms. Dion constituted an original contribution of major significance to the field of bodyguarding. In addition, the court held he failed to establish that he was paid more than most celebrity bodyguards.The court noted Mr. Skokos claimed he was far more than a bodyguard--he supervised guards, made security arrangements in the exotic destinations where Ms. Dion shot her mesmerizingly dramatic videos, and provided around-the-clock protection for Ms. Dion and her family. Nevertheless, the court was unmoved that protecting the valuable Canadian export was sufficiently significant to get a visa.The court noted the high standard for granting an EB-1 visa, citing the case of Kazarian v. USCIS, where a physicist who had published articles, written a textbook, and lectured extensively didnt even qualify for an EB-1 visa because his work--although satisfying the criterion for authorship of scholarly articles--did not establish that his work was of major significance in the field of physics.But, is writing scholarly articles and lecturing on physics at universities really as important as ensuring the gaffer and the best boy don''t snag Celine Dion''s Perrier from the buffet table?Of course, some people have managed to prove they are important and accomplished enough to get an EB-1 visa. Golfer Nick Price got one, but--unlike Mr. Skokos--he had won multiple championships, earned over a million dollars in prize money, and he had Jack Nicklaus, Lee Trevino, and Hale Irwin execute affidavits supporting his position.If only Mr. Skokos had managed to get a raise from Celine Dion and recommendations from Gladys Knight and the Pips.______________________________David Horrigan is an attorney, journalist, analyst at The 451 Group, editorial director at Courtweek.com, and former staff reporter and assistant editor at The National Law Journal. His articles have appeared also in The Washington Examiner, Law Technology News, The American Lawyer, The New York Law Journal, The San Francisco Examiner, Corporate Counsel, Texas Lawyer, Florida Lawyer, and Daily Business Review. E-Mail: dhorrigan@courtweek.comJuly 20, 2011American Idol''s American LitigantMany contestants on the hit television show, American Idol, may believe Simon Cowell is a somewhat nasty fellow. He berates participants, calls them names, and generally makes people wonder if his momma taught him any manners. Nevertheless, most of these verbal salvo victims don''t sue. But, one did, leaving us with the question: Does Simon Cowell''s boorish behavior on American Idol violate Title VII of the Civil Rights of 1964?Effeminate Idol?In what some take as evidence of the decline of Western civilization, American Idol, the American spin-off of the British program, Pop Idol, has become one of the most successful shows on television. Contestants participate in singing competitions to win recording contracts, and the winners, including singers Kelly Clarkson and Carrie Underwood, have gone on to fame and fortune.Some of the contestants weren''t as talented. One of those contestants was Ian Bernardo.Mr. Bernardo first appeared on American Idol in 2006 on the opening show of the season. These season-opening audition shows feature a few acts that will advance in the competition and a few acts that will come close. They also feature performers with no reasonable chance of advancement. These contestants--possessing little or no talent--apparently appear to provide comedic material by making fools of themselves. Apparently, Ian Bernardo was one of these comedic contestants for the 2006-2007 season.Not surprisingly, Mr. Bernardo was unsuccessful in his American Idol audition. However, Mr. Bernardo--who described himself as "having a non-conforming appearance based on gender stereotype," which a U.S. District Court interpreted to mean that "he appears to conform to a stereotype of an effeminate homosexual male"--did make subsequent appearances on the show for the 2006-2007 season finale and for Simon Cowell''s final appearance on the show in May 2010.The Courthouse AuditionClaiming he was an employee of American Idol Productions Inc. on each of his appearances, Mr. Bernardo claimed also that he was subject to discrimination and harassment due to his sex on each of his appearances. He claimed American Idol Productions employees told him to "gay it up" and that producers conditioned his appearance on Mr. Cowell''s farewell show on Mr. Bernardo''s willingness to be "outrageous, flamboyant, and really gay."Claiming he was also subject to epithets such as "fag" and "homo," Mr. Bernardo filed a complaint with the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC). He obtained a right to sue letter from the EEOC and sued American Idol Productions for violations of Title VII of the federal Civil Rights Act of 1964 and New York State law.American Idol Productions moved to dismiss the case, making several arguments. In addition to claiming Mr. Bernardo suffered no adverse employment action, the producers argued Mr. Bernardo had failed to make a case for hostile work environment under Title VII. Although the court conceded that--if true--the conduct at the Simon Cowell farewell show would constitute a hostile work environment, the court rejected Mr. Bernardo''s legal argument.Noting Title VII is not a civility code and that discrimination on the basis of homosexuality is not prohibited under Title VII, the court held Mr. Bernardo had not established that gender stereotyping, which is prohibited by Title VII, had so permeated the workplace so as to create a hostile work environment.The court went on to dismiss all Mr. Bernardo''s claims, noting, "He, like everyone else with a modicum of talent (or less) who auditions for American Idol, chose to appear on a program that was famous for its judges'' insulting behavior. Benardo went on the air after being told what was expected of him, and he knew what to expect. Having volunteered to be insulted, he cannot now claim that he was sexually harassed."There was no word as of press time as to any possible Ian Bernardo appellate audition at the Second Circuit._____________________July 10, 2011Suing After Ferocious Puppy PanicPeople are injured in Americas stores, streets, and subways all the time, making personal injury law a big business. Its also one of the most contentious. Some cases may seem easy, but what if youre injured after being chased down a supermarket aisle by a charging dog owned by a store employee? Should the store be liable? Two Mississippi courts disagreed recently. Of course, it helps if you know something about the dog.Attack in the Artichoke AisleLenetra Outlaw decided to do some shopping at her local Penny Pinchers discount grocery store in West Point, Miss., one day in Aug. 2006. An otherwise pleasant shopping day took an unfortunate turn when Ms. Outlaw heard a sound that gripped her with fear and panic.She heard a dog bark.Ms. Outlaw then heard the terrifying sound of dog claws on Penny Pinchers'' floors as the possibly ferocious beast came charging down the aisle. Ms. Outlaw, who said she was extremely afraid of dogs, decided it was time for drastic evasive maneuvers.She ran down the aisle, made a turn, and sought refuge from her brutal foe. Not finding a safe place in the aisle, she ran into a freezer. Thinking that wasnt safe enough--after all, she probably saw the movie, Cujo--Ms. Outlaw leaped on top of the freezer. In her Quixotic quest to escape Armageddon, Ms. Outlaw exacerbated a previously existing hip injury, and decided to sue Penny Pinchers and Cindy Scott, the store manager who owned the attack dog.A Mississippi state court jury found for Ms. Outlaw and awarded her $130,000, finding Penny Pinchers 70 percent at fault and Ms. Scott 30 percent to blame.At this point, you may be wondering, What''s so interesting about this case?Remember at the beginning we told you it would help if you knew a little about the dog?Baby Weiner DogIt turns out this allegedly ferocious attack dog was nothing more than a four-month-old Dachshund puppy. That''s right. A little weiner dog weighing four pounds.It seems Ms. Scott brought the adorable puppy named Sophie to work every day. The pleasant little puppy had never attacked anyone before. Ms. Scott kept Sophie behind the counter--not to protect customers, but so that no one would step on the little thing. Rather than a 150-pound Rottweiler with a spiked collar, Ms. Outlaw jumped on top of a freezer in mortal fear of a tiny weiner dog puppy.Given this fact pattern, Penny Pincher and Ms. Scott decided an appeal was in order. The issue facing the Mississippi Court of Appeals in Penny Pinchers v. Outlaw: Did the presence of the four-month-old Dachshund puppy create an unreasonably dangerous condition at Penny Pinchers that day?The court noted that the Mississippi Supreme Court had held that dogs are not dangerous per se. The Magnolias State''s dog-loving supreme court held in Poy v. Grayson that to impose liability on a dog owner for personal injuries, a plaintiff must show the dog had a propensity for violence and that the owner knew it.The court in Penny Pinchers noted that the four-month-old, four-pound bundle of love, Sophie the Weiner Dog, had a clean record.Citing the Mississippi Supreme Courts 1969 decision in General Tire & Rubber Co. v. Darnell, the court went on to hold that a premises does not have to be completely safe from any hazardonly reasonable safeand that the plaintiffs own actions can be a factor."We acknowledge Outlaw''s extreme fear of dogs. However, we cannot say that it was reasonable for Penny Pinchers to anticipate that anyone, even someone with a great fear of dogs, would have such a reaction to Sophie''s presence in the store," Judge Thomas Griffis wrote for the court.Thus, we feel confident in saying, if you hurt yourself jumping on top of a freezer to escape a four-pound Dachshund puppy, don''t bother suing anyone because its probably your own fault.__________________________June 29, 2011A Defamer''s Guide to ''Dirtbag v. Dirtbag''What does it really take to slander or libel someone? The law of defamation can be complex, but a New York state court recently tried to sort out this weighty issue: What is a "dirtbag," and is the term defamatory?The issue arose after a man named William Schumacher penned comments that another man, John Acheson, was "the biggest dirtbag" he had ever met in his life. Acheson sued Schumacher before Westchester City Court in what, amusingly, could become a seminal case of black letter law. Apparently, no other U.S. court has ever issued a reported decision on the issue of whether it is defamatory to call someone a "dirtbag."Citing a New York precedent, the court in Acheson v. Schumacher said libel or defamation was "a writing or broadcast that tends to expose the plaintiff to public hatred, contempt, ridicule, or disgrace." The court went on to cite the five proving elements of the tort, including the truth or falsity of the statement and whether the complaining party actually sustained damages.Without offering any citation, the court defined "dirtbag" as "an informal term" meaning "a dirty, grimy, sleazy, or disreputable person." The court went on to explain various possible meanings for Mr. Schumacher''s allegedly defamatory statement. Did Schumacher mean that Acheson was the physically largest of the dirtbags he had known? Or perhaps just one of the most powerful? The court surmised also that Schumacher may have believed Acheson to be "just a tad worse" than the other dirtbags he had known.The point the court was making was that -- in any case -- these statements would all be opinions. Citing the case of Gilliam v. Richard M. Greenspan, P.C., the court held that statements of opinion are not defamatory. (In Gilliam, one lawyer penned a nastygram, saying unflattering things about another lawyer. The court held it was opinion and threw out the case.)But don''t take these court decisions as a license to spew any insult you please. In Lund v. Chicago and Northwest Transp. Co., a Minnesota appellate court held that certain epithets -- in that case, the unfriendly word "s---head" -- used alone might be only "unactionable rhetorical hyperbole," but combined with other defamatory words or statements, such words could "take on actionable characteristics."It also matters where and when insults are hurtled. In National Recruiters Inc. v. Cashman, the Minnesota Supreme Court found it slander when a plaintiff was called "a no-good loser; a no-good son of a bitch" in the context of an employment reference.Other courts are more hostile toward such lawsuits. When ESPN posted a photo of daredevil Evel Knievel and his wife with the caption, "Evel Knievel proves you''re never too old to be a pimp," the Knievels sued the network for defamation. They lost on the grounds that a reasonable person would not have taken the photo and caption to mean Evel was literally a pimp and Krystal his prostitute, despite their 29-year age difference and his rose-tinted glasses in the photo.And Florida courts have held that even such insults as "cockroach" and "mega-scumbag" do not constitute defamation, nor do references to a woman''s "poor feminine hygiene." Despite being "crude and indecent," such comments were considered permissible as "satirical hyperbole."The bottom line is that you can freely call someone a dirtbag or a mega-scumbag, but be careful the next time you write a letter of recommendation. If you can''t say something nice, at least don''t say anything that will get you sued.___________________________David Horrigan is an attorney, journalist, analyst at The 451 Group, editorial director at Courtweek.com, and former staff reporter and assistant editor at The National Law Journal. His articles have appeared also in The Washington Examiner, Law Technology News, The American Lawyer, The New York Law Journal, The San Francisco Examiner, Corporate Counsel, Texas Lawyer, Florida Lawyer, and Daily Business Review. E-Mail: dhorrigan@courtweek.comRead more at the Washington Examiner: http://washingtonexaminer.com/opinion/op-eds/2011/06/defamers-guide-dirtbag-v-dirtbag#ixzz1Qfc82pzXJune 12, 2011The Law of Ben & Jerry''s and Natural BeansHave you ever wondered just what "all natural" means? There was once a professor who reminded his students that the bubonic plague was all natural. Various merchants--from sellers of cereal to purveyors of popcorn--claim their products are "all natural." Ben & Jerrys claimed its ice cream was all natural, but the Center for Science in the Public Interest didnt agree, so they got someone to sue Ben & Jerry''s.So, we can attempt to discover once and for all just what all natural means, the tale of Chubby Hubby, Chunky Monkey, and Cherry Garcia defending their honor gets to be this week''s Case of the Week.Activist ice creamIn the 1970s, childhood friends Ben Cohen and Jerry Greenfield took a correspondence course in ice cream making. Then they scraped up $12,000, opened an ice cream shop in an old Vermont gas station, and delivered dairy products in a station wagon. Ben & Jerry''s Homemade Inc. was born, and, as they say, the rest is history.Ben & Jerry''s expanded quickly. Not only was the company known for its tasty ice cream with imaginative names, Ben & Jerry''s became known as a leader in social and environmental activism. The growing company tried to promote world peace, and--from green dairy farms to recycled supplies--Ben & Jerry''s made environmental stewardship a focal point of its operations. In addition, Ben & Jerry''s donated 7.5 percent of the companys pre-tax profits to charity through the Ben & Jerry''s Foundation. In 2000, Ben and Jerry sold the company to Unilever.Although they are now very rich dudes, Messrs. Cohen and Greenfield and their ice cream operation still conjure up images of granola, Birkenstocks, peace signs, and...well...things that are all natural. Of course, the labels of Ben & Jerry''s ice cream read all natural, too. Some people didn''t think it was natural enough.Dutch chocolateAlthough Amsterdam may be more famous for Rembrandt, the Rijksmuseum, and reefers, some people believe the Netherlands is also famous for Dutch chocolate. But, does anyone really know what Dutch chocolate is? Hint: it''s a little more complicated than just being made near The Hague.Chocolate is produced when seeds from cocoa beans are fermented and dried and mixed with fat and powdered sugar. Cocoa powder can be made in two forms: unalkalized cocoa or Dutch-process alkalized cocoa. The unalkalized cocoa is made by merely pressing the beans. The process produces a light brown, very acidic powder.Dutch-process cocoa, on the other hand, is produced by cocoa nibs with a mild alkali solution to raise the pH and thus, lower the acidity. This process improves taste, color and solubility, but it also destroys many of the flavonols, which are believed to have health benefits. Ben & Jerry''s used the Dutch alkanization process.All Natural?The Center for Science in the Public Interest (CSPI) doesn''t think alkanized cocoa is all natural, so it contacted Unilever, demanding that the company remove the words all natural from both Ben & Jerry''s and Breyers ice cream, another brand the company owns. Ben & Jerrys agreed to remove the phrase, all natural, from any products containing alkanized cocoa. Breyers did not.CSPI organized a class action with the ice cream-enjoying Skye Astiana as lead plaintiff of a band of ice cream eaters who hate the allegedly unnatural Dutch chocolate, and sued Ben & Jerry''s in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California in Astiana v. Ben & Jerry''s Homemade Inc. They alleged violation of both federal and California law in the labeling of the ice cream as all natural even though its cocoa contained potassium carbonate from the alkanization process.Specifically, the CSPI plaintiffs argued Ben & Jerry''s committed fraud and engaged in false advertising in violation of California Business & Professions Code 17500. In addition, CPSI claimed Ben & Jerry''s violated regulations promulgated by the federal Food and Drug Administration (FDA).Ben & Jerry''s filed a motion to dismiss the case, making numerous arguments, including debating the definition of all natural.The ice cream makers argued that "all natural" was a term of art under FDA and U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) regulations. Thus, Ben & Jerry''s argued, for the CSPI plaintiffs to have been deceived by the all natural packaging, they would have had to have possessed an intimate familiarity with the FDA''s natural policy as well as the USDA''s regulations about what constitutes a synthetic process.Ben & Jerry''s was taking the position that Ms. Astiana was merely an ice cream lover and not a federal regulatory expert.In addition, Ben & Jerry''s argued a prospective class plaintiff would have had to taken that extensive regulatory knowledge, then actually have seen the all natural phrase on the package, and then made her own analysis that the ice cream was either not alkanized or that the alkali used in the Dutch cocoa process was not synthetic under the USDA regulations.After all that, under Ben & Jerry''s argument, the potential plaintiff would have had to have relied on that regulatory analysis in deciding to enjoy that pint of Chubby Hubby. Ben & Jerry''s argued that when the reasonable consumer bought her Chunky Monkey, she was not assuming all natural meant alkanized with sodium carbonate and not potassium carbonate.The court wasn''t buying it--at least not for now.The court denied Ben & Jerry''s motion to dismiss, holding that the dispute was too fact-dependent to be thrown out at this point."Moreover, the fundamental dispute--what is a natural product?--will likely present some factual disputes. The only FDA guidance appears to be a distinction between natural and synthetic in the policy, but that definition in the Federal Register is qualified as meaning something that would not normally be expected to be in food. Surely, that characterization raises multiple linguistic and philosophical questions, not to mention factual questions," U.S. District Judge Phyllis Hamilton wrote for the court.So, the battle between Ben & Jerry''s and the enemies of Dutch chocolate will continue. What have we learned this week? Well, according to the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, there really isn''t any definition of "all natural"...at least for the moment._______________________________June 5, 2011The Law of Bees and BudsWhat does it mean to operate a motor vehicle? It seems to be a simple question. Get a bunch of lawyers and judges involved, and it becomes anything but. Although alleged drunk driving cases are where this question is asked most often, this week''s "Case of the Week" asks it in a different setting.What about when that motor vehicle is attacked by a swarm of bees?Unhappy HiveOne May day in 2009, Michael Corpus called animal control for the city of McAllen, Tex. It seems he was having a bit of a problem with a beehive.City of McAllen Animal Control Officer Roberto Mata responded to the call, and upon arrival at the scene, Mr. Corpus asked Officer Mata to accompany him to the hive with the swarming army of displeased bees.Possibly remembering what happened to the fools who tried to go into a hotel room with Mike Tyson''s tiger, Officer Mata said something along the lines of: "I don''t think so; Homey don''t play that," and refused. Officer Mata insisted Mr. Corpus accompany him to the hive.So the two gentlemen entered Officer Mata''s animal control vehicle, equipped with animal protection equipment. Officer Mata donned protective gear and approached the hive of danger, but he instructed Mr. Corpus to remain safely in the animal control vessel as the engine remained running.Things would have been just fine and dandy had Officer Mata not done something that may have been somewhat unwise.Insects Attack!Not unlike a Saturday Morning Super Hero decked out in protective gear as he makes Saturday mornings safe for kiddie sales of sugary cereal and overpriced toys, Officer Mata approached the hive in his protective animal control gear. Then, the swashbuckling hero of animal protection began spraying the bees.Guess what happened next?Shockingly, the bees attacked. But, no worries. Officer Mata was protected by his animal control gear. The problem was what Officer Mata did next.To escape the mighty swarm, Officer Mata ran to the truck, opened the door, and hopped in.The only problem, of course, was that, when he opened the door to the animal control truck, he let in a bunch of very angry bees--who proceeded to have a field day biting the [expletive deleted] out of the unprotected corpus of Mr. Corpus.Mr. Corpus was not amused.What do unamused people do in this column? They sue.The Law of Bees and CarsMr. Corpus sued the city of McAllen, alleging Officer Mata''s negligent operation of his city-owned vehicle cased serious injuries to Mr. Corpus.Operating a motor vehicle? What about spraying the bee hive and opening the truck door so the bees could turn Mr. Corpus into a walking, talking pin cushion.Actually, Mr. Corpus had a smart lawyer.You see, government entities are usually only liable in civil suits if they waive what lawyers call sovereign immunity, the government''s immunity from legal actions. Governments waive sovereign immunity for certain activities. Basically, you can sue the government only if the government says you can sue the government.One of the exceptions to sovereign immunity in Texas is for operation of motor vehicles. If Mr. Corpus'' lawyer could show Officer Mata was operating the animal control truck, then he would have a case under the exception to sovereign immunity.So just what does it take to be operating a motor vehicle?If you asked a bunch of convicted drunk drivers, they would probably tell you Officer Mata was operating the animal control truck. That''s because courts have held that, to be guilty of drunk driving, all one must do is sit in the drivers seat with the key in the ignition.Bud or Bees?For instance, in People v. Wood, Andrew Wood had a very unfortunate night at McDonald''s. When he pulled up to the drive-up window in his van, he passed out--with his car running--and, giving new meaning to the phrase, "This Bud''s for you," he had a can of Budweiser between his legs. At least it wasn''t hot coffee. Oh yeah, he also had a cooler full of marijuana on the front seat.The legal story from the bad night at the Golden Arches wasn''t so bad for Mr. Wood at first. Both a trial court and an intermediate state appellate court threw out the evidence against him, holding he was not operating his van at the time of the arrest and search.However, the Michigan Supreme Court reversed both courts and held Mr. Wood was operating the motor vehicle even though his van wasn''t moving, and he had his foot on the brake. Noting that his van was running and in drive, the state''s high court held he was operating the vehicle because he had put the vehicle in motion, was still in control of it, and the vehicle still posed a danger to the public. In doing so, the court reversed two previous Michigan cases that held one could not be sleeping and operating a motor vehicle at the same time.Actual physical control of the vehicle is the standard used by many jurisdictions, and in Illinois, Michigan, Minnesota, and Nevada, that control can be maintained while sleeping.Putting the key in the ignition will get you in some states, including Vermont. In the Vermont Supreme Court case, State v. Helton, one hapless, inebriated fellow was convicted of DUI for merely putting his keys in the ignition to roll up his car windows--after he had gone to retrieve his vodka from the car.Note to self: appoint a designated sober window operator.So what about Officer Mata, was he in control of the vehicle and thus operating it for purposes of Mr. Corpus bee attack case?Departing from the case law of other states, both the trial court and the Texas Thirteenth Court of Appeals said "no.""The animal control truck was not in operation; it was parked. Corpus was injured when the bees entered the cab of the truck where he happened to be sitting. Although we do not condone Mata opening the truck door and exposing a passenger not wearing protective gear to agitated bees, we nonetheless cannot conclude that Corpus''s injuries resulted from the operation or the use of the truck," Judge Nelda Rodriguez wrote for the court.So for this week, we''ve established that you are operating a vehicle in Michigan if you''re asleep at the wheel in the McDonald''s drive-through with weed on the seat and Budweiser between your legs, but that you''re not operating a running vehicle in Texas with a swarm of bees on the seat and between your legs.Either way, its not a Happy Meal._____________________________David Horrigan is an attorney, journalist, analyst at The 451 Group, editorial director at Courtweek.com, and former staff reporter and assistant editor at The National Law Journal. His articles have appeared also in The Washington Examiner, Law Technology News, The American Lawyer, The New York Law Journal, The San Francisco Examiner, Corporate Counsel, Texas Lawyer, Florida Lawyer, and Daily Business Review. E-Mail: dhorrigan@courtweek.comRead more at the Washington Examiner: http://washingtonexaminer.com/blogs/opinion-zone/2011/06/law-bees-and-buds#ixzz1OXOJfS6kMay 29, 2011The Law of Rambo and Air FreshenersOur column two weeks ago about the Fourth Amendment has generated some discussion about just what will negate yourFourth Amendment protections and allow the cops to haul your posterior end to jail. As a public service to help our readers remain free from bondage, we will, from time to time, present our Case of the Week: Fourth Amendment Follies edition.This weeks helpful hint: Don''t use too much air freshener.Druggies from CharlotteRobert Little was traveling through the pleasant North Carolina hamlet of Thomasville early one August morning in 2008. It might not have been any big deal, but it was 4:03 in the morning, and Mr. Little was driving an old Buick with a malfunctioning headlight.Bonus reader helpful hint! If you''re carrying contraband, don''t drive through a small Southern town at 4:03 in the morning in an old Buick with a busted headlight. Bad things will happen. At least wait until 5:00 when the first batch of doughnuts comes off the conveyor belt at the local Krispy Kreme.Because Mr. Little didn''t get the memo on suspicious vehicles lurking through the Bible Belt during the wee hours of the morning, he got to meet Officer Adam Kallfelz of the Thomasville Police Dept.Officer Kallfelz observed three things that made him decide it was time for back-up.First was Mr. Little''s nervous and agitated demeanor. Second, Mr. Little said he was traveling from Charlotte. Finally, Mr. Little had approximately 10 tree air fresheners hanging from the rear-view mirror.Before we get to those pesky air fresheners, please allow us to defend the good people of Charlotte, North Carolina. You''re a fine city with an economy built on good barbecue and Bank of America overdraft fees, and--unlike Office Kallfetz--we don''t think you''re a bunch of druggies. We don''t think people should be stopped by the cops just because they''re coming from Charlotte.But, back to those tree air fresheners.Rambo RaidA nervous dude driving from Charlotte with 10 air fresheners made Officer Kallfelz realize he needed a crime deterrent.It was time for Rambo.At 4:07 AM, Officer Kallfelz called Officer Christopher Leonard, asking him to bring his partner, Rambo.Not unlike Sylvester Stallone searching swamps for sadistic Viet Kong alumni, Rambo, a drug dog, went over that old Buick like a frat boy going through sofa cushions looking for that lost last joint.Rambo signaled for the presence of narcotics in the Buick''s door, and Mr. Little was arrested for being a felon in possession of a firearm.Mr. Little moved to suppress the evidence, arguing the search was illegal, but a trial court denied the motion, holding that the stop and the search were lawful. Mr. Little appealed.Air Freshener JurisprudenceIn his appeal to the North Carolina Court of Appeals, the Tar Heel State''s intermediate appellate court, Mr. Little argued in State v. Little that the search was improper because the cornucopia of air fresheners did not provide reasonable suspicion for extending the stop until Rambo arrived.Unfortunately for Mr. Little, North Carolina has a proud tradition of air freshener jurisprudence. They even go after Santa Claus if there''s air freshener involved.In State v. Hernandez, the North Carolina Court of Appeals held a stop was proper when it was based, at least in part, on Christmas tree air fresheners.In Hernandez, Trooper Jonathan Whitley of the North Carolina Highway Patrol stopped a vehicle when driver Jose Hernandez removed his seatbelt while still operating his vehicle. Not unlike with Mr. Little''s arrest, air fresheners would help lead to Mr. Hernandez''s undoing."I noticed there were several of these Christmas trees, air fresheners in the vehicle. I noticed a strong odor coming from the vehicle," Trooper Whitley testified in defending his actions.Christmas tree air fresheners as a basis for detaining a motorists? Well, the court upheld the stop, and the court in Little followed the court in Hernandez."Facts giving rise to a reasonable suspicion include nervousness, sweating, failing to make eye contact, conflicting statements, and strong odor of air freshener," Judge Martha Geer wrote for the court in Little.And, if you think North Carolina is the only state fighting the war on air freshener, you would be wrong.In Commonwealth v. Watts, the Massachusetts Appeals Court held reasonable suspicion could be based, in part, on the presence of fabric softener drier sheets.The federal courts have joined this attack on pleasant aromas as well. In United States v. West, the Tenth Circuit proclaimed, "The Tenth Circuit has consistently held that the scent of air freshener is properly considered as a factor in the probable cause analysis, and in the Eleventh Circuit held in United States v. Wright that evidence of a drug conspiracy existed based partially on the fact that two persons entered the Winn-Dixie together to purchase carpet freshener and fabric softener; materials known to be used to mask the odor of cocaine.Many other federal circuits, including the Third, Fifth, Seventh, Eighth, and Ninth, have upheld convictions based, in part, on the presence of fabric softener, and in United States v. Edmonds, the Third Circuit upheld a trial court''s refusal to believe a drug mule was a mere unsuspecting courier. Why? She brought along a box of Bounce fabric softener sheets.So, the lesson from this week''s Case of the Week: with a Mountain Fresh scent filling the air, your dorm hall monitor in college didn''t believe you then, and the cops don''t believe you now. If you have contraband and notice Rambo sniffing your car, ditch the fabric softener...Bounce can get you busted.____________________________Read more at the Washington Examiner: http://washingtonexaminer.com/blogs/opinion-zone/2011/05/law-rambo-and-air-fresheners#ixzz1Nvzi9iNpMay 22, 2011The Law of Airport TipsHave you ever been sitting in a hotel room, staring at a room service bill, trying to determine whether the service charge added to your bill is the tip? And let''s not even get started with deciphering the cryptic hieroglyphics known as the cable bill.But what if your employer hoisted a sign informing customers there would be a two-dollar charge for your services? Would that payment be your tip? Would posting that sign get somebody sued? Of course, it would. This is the Case of the Week.Air a la carteOur story begins in Sept. 2005, when American Airlines began charging a $2.00 fee for passengers to check a bag at curbside.Before this policy began, curbside check-in was free, but customers tipped the skycaps--usually a dollar per bag--for curbside service. Until American went and messed up things, most skycaps earned most of their earnings from tips.As the airline industry faced significant financial problems, airlines began charging for many services that had been free. This a la carte fee system affected everything from headphones to handbags.Want to watch the in-flight movie? No problem. That''s free. Want to hear it? Two dollars for headphones, please. Want to eat? Pay up.Pay2Pee, the world''s first aircraft pay toilet, can''t be far away.At the moment, we can add curbside check-in to our non-complimentary airline a la carte menu.American--and its subcontractor actually employing the skycaps--made out like Tijuana bandits. The charge was designed to defray the cost of curbside service in a dark and dreary economy, but it actually became a profitable business venture for all...except the skycaps themselves.Many passengers thought American''s $2.00 fee was the tip. Others felt $2.00 per bag was enough to pay for curbside service. The end result was the same: the skycaps lost a significant amount of their income as tips plummeted.Suing SkycapsTwo skycaps at Boston Logan International Airport sued American and the contractor, seeking class certification and arguing that American''s curbside fee violated the Massachusetts statute governing tips, Mass. Gen. Laws, ch. 49, 152A (2008), constituted tortious interference with an advantageous relationship, unlawful conversion, and unjust enrichment under Massachusetts law, and that the skycaps were entitled to restitution under the legal theory of quantum meruit.The skycaps'' employer was dismissed due to an arbitration agreement, and American removed the case from a Massachusetts commonwealth court to federal court.The skycaps argued Massachusetts law prohibited American from charging the curbside baggage fee because the fee qualified as a service charge under the commonwealth law because it was a fee that a consumer would reasonably expect to be given to the skycap.American countered that the skycaps suit was preempted by the federal Airline Deregulation Act of 1978. When a federal law preempts a state law on an issue, the federal statute has sole jurisdiction, and the state statute is preempted and nullified for purposes of that dispute.The District Court held for American on several grounds, but held for the skycaps on the preemption argument. Thus, the claims under the Massachusetts tips law and for tortious interference were tried to a jury.Big TippersIt turned out the jury was a bunch of big tippers. The jury found for the skycaps in April 2008 and awarded damages in the amount of $2.00 to each skycap for every bag handled between Sept. 2005 and the verdict.Thus, the jury awarded the nine prevailing plaintiff skycaps approximately $333,000 in damages plus interest and attorney fees. One plaintiff skycap from the St. Louis airport did not get to share in the bounty because--as a citizen of Missouri--he was not covered by the Massachusetts tip law.But, our story is not over. Cheap tippers can rejoice. American appealed, and the First U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals handed down a decision bound to make Parisian tourists do a happy dance.The First Circuit reversed the district court and ruled for American in DiFiore v. American Airlines, Inc., holding that the Massachusetts tip statute was, in fact, preempted by the federal Airline Deregulation Act.Although the appellate court conceded there was conflicting case law, it relied on three U.S. Supreme Court cases, Morales v. Trans World Airlines, Inc., American Airlines, Inc. v. Wolens, and Rowe v. New Hampshire Motor Transport Assn, in holding that the federal law preempted the Massachusetts tip statute vis--vis the skycaps tips.The court held the commonwealth''s law was preempted when applied to Ameircan because it was related to a price, route, or service, noting that related to and service were statutorily broad terms.The First Circuit rejected the skycaps'' argument that the tip law''s connection to airline price, route, or service was so tenuous, remote, or peripheral as to not trigger preemption under Morales or Rowe."This, to borrow an apt airplane image, is walking into a rotating propeller: the advertising and service arrangements are just what Congress did not want states regulating, whether at high cost or at low. When the Supreme Court invoked the rubric ("tenuous, remote, or peripheral"), it used as examples limitations on gambling, prostitution, or smoking in public places--state regulation comparatively remote to the transportation function," the court said.So, next time you go to the airport, please remember that--because a federal court has ruled that curbside check-in is not like betting on ponies, retaining the services of a hooker, or smoking a joint at baggage claim--these guys aren''t protected by the Massachusetts tip statute.Even if you pay an airline curbside baggage fee, please, folks, tip your skycap.________________________May 14, 2011The Fourth Amendment and the Law of Bongs and BaggiesThe Fourth Amendment provides some of our greatest protections from government. It keeps colonial constables out of our tea, J. Edgar Hoover and the FBI out of our mothers underwear drawers, and seizure-hungry sheriffs out of our Chevys.Yet, as with anything, the Fourth Amendment is not absolute. The Fourth Amendment prohibits only unreasonable searches. Thus, if police have probable cause for a search, its not unreasonable, and the Fourth Amendment won''t stop it. In fact, the Fourth Amendment has a specific clause allowing searches with probable cause.A recent Massachusetts case gets to be our Case of the Week because it addresses the novel legal question: Does the presence of a bong and Baggies constitute probable cause for a search for marijuana?Speeding and SeizingWhen Shawn Smith decided to do some urban drag racing with friends, he probably should have left his bong at home. For readers who may be unfamiliar with the household appliance known as the bong, it is a water pipe--used by some to smoke marijuana.The speeding Mr. Smith was attempting to outduel a fellow motorist when police clocked him traveling 67 miles per hour in a 40 mile per hour zone.When police stopped the Smithmoblie, they noticed a bong and an open box of plastic sandwich bags in the car. The police testified that, based on their experience, a bong and Baggies usually meant one thing...and it usually happens a lot in Cheech and Chong movies. Yes, police thought they were dealing with that plague on humanity: marijuana.Having spotting the offending bong and Baggies, law enforcement swung into action.Police ordered Mr. Smith from the car, and frisked him. They asked him if there were any marijuana in the car, and he said there was not. However, Mr. Smith admitted he had some herbal enjoyment in his pocket. Police seized it, arrested Mr. Smith, and impounded his speedy car. Shockingly, they found more marijuana.However, in a development that will be significant legally later in our story, police did not detect any marijuana smoke or residue in the bong.Evidence Up in Smoke?Sure, police get to do an inventory when they seize a car. In this week''s case, police were arresting Mr. Smith for his weed, so they got to go through his car and inventory everything. However, when police misbehave, there is a judicial remedy known as suppression of the evidence. For those who never have time to watch Law and Order, that means the evidence is thrown out because the cops got it illegally.In this case, because the police failed to give Mr. Smith his Miranda warnings before giving him the Spanish Inquisition, Mr. Smith moved to suppress evidence of the search.However, Massachusetts prosecutors argued the bong and Baggies sitting in the car in plain sight gave the police all the probable cause they needed to search the carMiranda or not. In essence, the Commonwealth argued, it was the probable cause supplied by the bong and Baggiesnot the Mirandaless utterances of Mr. Smith that gave police the pot.Both a trial court and the Massachusetts Appeals Court, the commonwealths intermediate appellate court, rejected prosecutors'' arguments and threw out the evidence--and thus, the case. Citing Massachusetts case law, the court held that bongs and Baggies--and nothing more--do not give the police probably case for a search.Bong and Baggies LawThe Appeals Court distinguished Mr. Smith''s case from two previous Massachusetts Appeals Court decisions where bongs did lead to probable cause for a search: Commonwealth v. Dolby from 2000, and Commonwealth v. Correia in 2006.It is true the facts in all three cases were somewhat similar: cops stop car, cops see bong, cops arrest driver. However, Smith differed from Dolby and Correia in one, key respect. Unlike in Dolby and Correia, in Smith, there was neither marijuana smoke nor residue present in the bong.The Appeals Court said that distinction was critical. In Dolby and Correia, the evidence was not suppressed, but it was because there was residue in the bong--not because police spotted an innocent bong just hanging out, minding its own business, with no nefarious residue or smoke.Baggies get the same constitutional protections.Citing its decision in Commonwealth v. Garcia, the court held, the observation of two lawful items--the bong and the box of sandwich bags--did not supply probably cause. The court articulated its rationale in Garcia:"The trooper''s experience, coupled with his observation of an apparently empty baggie, is not enough to provide probable cause to conduct a warrantless search of the automobile. Benign objects such as spoons, mirrors, and straws are often used in the narcotic trade. To allow police officers, experienced in narcotics investigations, to conduct a warrantless search whenever they observe one of the above items, and nothing more, would permit random searches, which are condemned by the Fourth Amendment and the Declaration of Rights," the court said.So, Mr. Smith got off: the evidence was suppressed, and the charges were dropped. The moral of this week''s Case of the Week: if you''re going to go drag racing with your bong in the back seat, at least make sure it is clean._________________________Read more at the Washington Examiner: http://washingtonexaminer.com/blogs/opinion-zone/2011/05/law-bongs-and-baggies-fourth-amendment-searches-probable-cause-miranda-marijuana#ixzz1MKivXiVWMay 8, 2011The Law of Cow Bones and BungeesWhen you buy a product or service, how much information should the seller disclose to you? This week''s Case of the Week examines that issue in a case involving breast implants, bungee cords, a surgeon''s eyesight, and the jurisprudence of cow bone implants...not necessarily in that order.Manmade ChassisDenise Dalien decided she wanted to augment the chassis God gave her, so she consulted plastic surgeon Stanley Jackson of Puyallup, Wash. Dr. Jackson performed breast augmentation on Ms. Dalien in 2000, using saline implants.After a diet and exercise regimen caused her to lose weight, Ms. Dalien noticed some indentation and rippling on what was once her soft and supple upper left bosom.No problem. Dr. Jackson went in again, removed the saline implants, and replaced them with gel implants.Turns out there was a problem. Ms. Dalien was not happy with her new gel bosoms, so under the surgical theory of more is more, Dr. Jackson performed additional revision procedures on Ms. Dalien during 2005 and 2006.Blinding BungeeJust before all this happened, and--importantly for our story--unbeknownst to Ms. Dalien, Dr. Jackson was having issues with a bungee cord. Dr. Jackson went into mortal combat with the killer cord in July 1999.The bungee cord won.Dr. Jackson received surgery on his eye, and took over a month off from his practice. In July 2006, Dr. Jackson reported additional changes in his vision. He retired in October 2006 after unsuccessful surgery.Citing her allegedly unsuccessful surgeries, Ms. Dalien sued the good doctor twice. In one suit, Ms. Dalien argued negligent medical malpractice in the botched boob job.In her second civil action, Ms. Dalien sued under Washington States Consumer Protection Act (CPA). Ms. Dalien argued, among other things, that Dr. Jackson violated the law by failing to disclose his eye injury.Cow Bone LawDr. Jackson argued that the nondisclosure of his eye condition did not occur in trade or commerce and that any alleged professional malpractice or negligence was exempt from the CPA.Ms. Dalien countered that the nondisclosure of the eye condition was, in fact, done in trade or commerce because Dr. Jackson solicited and retained patients by failing to disclose this condition.In siding with Dr. Jackson, Washington State''s Court of Appeals cited the Evergreen State''s jurisprudence on cow bone disclosure and the case of Michel v. Mosquera-Lacy.In Michel, Mystie Michel sought treatment from Lucy Mosquera-Lacy, a periodontist employed by Bright Now! Dental, Inc., and the doctor said Ms. Michel needed a bone graft.When completing her pre-procedure paperwork, Ms. Michel was given the choice of human bone, cow bone, or synthetic bone for her graft. Stating she could not fathom the thought of having animal parts in her body, Ms. Michel declined the opportunity to get authentic cow bone.Well, unfortunately for Ms. Michel, supplies were running low in the dental office that day.When Dr. Mosquera-Lacy ran out of human bone, she finished the job with cow bone.Although the dentist claimed she merely finished up with cow bone--and that cow constituted no more than 10 percent of the graft--Ms. Michel said she now had a McImplant with the doctor having implanted a cow bone in her mouth.Whatever damages or urges to graze on her front lawn Ms. Michel may have experienced, her case wasn''t actionable under the Consumer Protection Act, the Washington Supreme Court held, because the use of cow bone was not an entrepreneurial activity in trade or commerce."Michael failed to show that Dr. Mosquera-Lacy''s use of cow bone is entrepreneurial. It does not relate to billing or obtaining and retaining patients. It simply relates to Dr. Mosquera-Lacy''s judgment and treatment of a patient. There is no evidence that cow bone was used to increase profits or the number of patients. When the supply of human bone ran out during the procedure, Dr. Mosquera-Lacy used her judgment and skills as a periodontist to finish the procedure. This is not actionable under the CPA," the court said.Bovine Bones and BungeesFollowing the Washington Supreme Court''s holding in Michel, the Washington Court of Appeals held in Dalien v. Jackson that Dr. Jackson''s nondisclosure of his eye condition was also an activity that fell outside the scope of Washington''s Consumer Protection Act. Thus, the court declined to certify her class action, and it affirmed a trial court''s dismissal of her case."As in Michel, Dalien has failed to show that Dr. Jackson''s nondisclosure of his eye injury is entrepreneurial. Dr. Jackson''s nondisclosure does not relate to Dr. Jackson''s billing or obtaining and retaining patients. Dalien has presented no evidence that Dr. Jackson represented that he had better vision than his competitors or somehow relied on his vision to promote his business," Judge Russell Hartman wrote for the court.However, the court didn''t say Ms. Dalien didn''t have a case--just that she didnt have a case under the CPA. Referencing her other suit, the court said, "To the extent that Dr. Jackson''s eye injury may have affected his ability to examine, diagnose, treat, or care for his patients, that question is actionable under the negligence theory, which Dalien is pursuing in her original lawsuit."The lesson of this week''s Case of the Week? If you want to sue under Washington''s Consumer Protection Act, make sure they advertise their excellent vision allows them to see your head before they implant a cow bone in it.____________________________Read more at the Washington Examiner: http://washingtonexaminer.com/blogs/opinion-zone/2011/05/law-cow-bones-and-bungees#ixzz1Ll8lzZ00May 1, 2011The Law of Bait Car JournalismDavid Broder, Edward R. Murrow, William F. Buckley Jr., Walter Cronkite, and now Bait Car?As the old Sesame Street song said, it would appear that one of these things just doesn''t belong here. Well, that''s not what the producers of the television show, Bait Car, say. They argue their show is real journalism, and--in an attempt to avoid producing evidence in a California court proceeding--they say their photographers are journalists. In recognition of this creative legal argument, their case gets to be our Case of the Week.What is a Journalist?The proliferation of new media sources has created a novel question: Just what is a journalist? Must one possess government-issued press credentials, sending shivers down the spines of First Amendment advocates? How about a requirement that you earn your living from journalism? Perhaps there should be a requirement that at least your Aunt Betsy actually read what you write?This question has taken on real legal significance as the U.S. Congress and many states have tried to implement so-called reporters'' shield laws. These laws attempt to protect reporters and their confidential sources by shielding confidential information from disclosure to courts and third parties.Although there has been substantial progress, a federal shield law has not yet passed. However, 40 states and the District of Columbia have shield laws, with many states enacting them after what some argued were Bush administration abuses, prosecutorial attacks on the press, and the prosecution of New York Times reporter Judith Miller.Some Republican lawmakers cited national security concerns with reporters'' shield legislation, and others had a more fundamental issue: How do you go about deciding which writers get to be journalists in a New Media world vs. Old Media world?Many hipsters sipping lattes at Starbucks like to bash so-called Old Media. As they iPad away their afternoons, bowing before the altar of New Media, they mock institutions such as The Wall Street Journal as the old media of their grandparents, and--bless their little black turtlenecks and Birkenstocks--they weren''t fooled by Rupert Murdoch''s purchase of Myspace. Silly, Rupert, New Media is for hip kids.But, the beautiful world of blogging Brown alumni opining on global warming and Maya Angelous contributions to literature while their conservative brethren blog on banks and hedge funds may be in for a shock to its modern sensibilities. There may be unwanted guests at this post-modern, online clambake, and it may be a sign of things to come.Bait Car as New MediaThe folks at truTV, that network of cop shows that used to be Court TV, have come up with a new show called, Bait Car. In Bait Car, the producers work with local police to place an unlocked car with keys in the ignition out on the street. Its the bait for would-be car thieves. Get it, bait, car?Many unsuspecting citizens, including Joseph Bullard, took the bait.Or did he?In the case of People v. Bullard in the Superior Court of California, San Francisco County, Mr. Bullard argued that he was merely being a good citizen, moving the Bait Car out of its illegal parking spot.He also argued selective prosecution. Mr. Bullard, a gentleman who enjoys cross-dressing, argued it was no coincidence that the unholy trinity of producers, police, and prosecutors arranged for the Bait Car to be placed outside Divas, a well-known, somewhat risque San Francisco transgendered club. Police countered that they just picked an area known for car theft.To prove Mr. Bullard''s Good Samaritan claim, his legal counsel wanted to see the tapes of the filming from KKI Productions, the producers of the San Francisco episodes of Bait Car. Not unlike Judge John Sirica sending an order to the Nixon White House, Judge Gerardo Sandoval ordered KKI to turn over the tapes.Not so fast, said KKI. Arguing that Bait Car was journalism and that the intrepid Bait Car photographers were, in fact, journalists and so under California''s reporters shield law, KKI refused.Judge Sandoval wasn''t buying it. He rejected KKI''s reporters shield argument, and demanded the tapes.Funny thing. You may have laughed at Mr. Bullard''s "I was only helping by moving the car" argument, but prosecutors dropped the charges against Mr. Bullard.Future of Journalism?Bait Car''s producers were working with prosecutors, turning over their tapes to the district attorney''s office, and that cooperation with cops was fatal to their legal argument, according to Judge Sandoval and legal journalism experts."You can''t have it both ways. You can''t cooperate with one side and not the other," said Lucy Dalglish, Executive Director of the Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press."You can make a very strong argument that the cooperation with one side is a waiver of the privilege," Ms. Dalglish added.People v. Bullard does not decide the law on the contentious issue of who gets to be a reporter in the eyes of the law--although it does put Californians on notice that, if youre in cahoots with the cops, you probably don''t get to be one, at least for reporters shield purposes.The case also illustrates that the cozy little blogging world at Starbucks and beyond is also in the midst of a culture shift. The latter day hipsters may have make room on the Starbucks sofa for Bait Car journalists, Dog the Bounty Hunter, Big Brian the Fortune Seller, and the zany, fun-loving staffs of Ma''s Roadhouse, Lizard Lick Towing, and Hardcore Pawn.Yes, the Fourth Estate is becoming a very big tent in every respect imaginable...and in some not so imaginable.________________________Read more at the Washington Examiner: http://washingtonexaminer.com/blogs/opinion-zone/2011/04/law-bait-car-journalism#ixzz1LCFs9nEyApril 24, 2011The Law of Gwen Stefani AvatarsAt the time of this week''s legal tale, Gwen Stefani was a big, giant rock star, and Activision Publishing''s Band Hero videogame series was extremely popular. Combine the two - the theory went - and you would have what one of those MBA-types might call, synergy.Activision and Ms. Stefani thought so...until they ended up in court.This week''s Case of the Week illustrates the legal principle of the right of publicity. It also puts us on notice with the following legal poetry: Make Gwen Stefani a dude, and you''re gonna get sued.California Dreamin''In the 1990s, Gwen Stefani and Activision were both living the Southern California dream. Ms. Stefani and her Orange County band, No Doubt, achieved critical and commercial success, including Grammy nominations and huge recording contracts, while hitting the top of the charts with their 1995 single, Don''t Speak.Meanwhile, the friendly folks at Activision were building a videogame empire in Santa Monica with hit games such as MechWarrior 2: 31st Century Combat and Civilization: Call to Power. They also made some money off a game series based on the adventures of skateboarder Tony Hawk.Entering the 21st Century, one of Activision''s biggest games was its Guitar Hero series, which basically allows players to engage in computer-assisted air guitar. Band Hero was a similar, spin-off production.One of Band Hero''s features allowed players to create avatars based on real life rockers.Thinking it would be just nifty to have No Doubt avatars in the game - or at least thinking that it would be just nifty to have some of Activision''s cash -- No Doubt executed its Professional Services and Character Licensing Agreement with Activision, allowing the gamemaker to create avatars -- or computerized characters -- based on the band, and use them in Band Hero.Gwen is not a dudeMuch to their horror, the members of No Doubt learned about a special feature of Band Hero shortly before the product''s launch -- it was a special feature No Doubt may have worried pubescent punksters might manipulate.In their Agreement, Activision and No Doubt agreed Activision would license only a limited number of No Doubt songs for use in the game. However, that provision failed to consider another potential use of Band Hero.When players reached a certain level of the game, Band Hero allowed them to unlock their avatars, changing their song selection and personal characteristics.For instance, Activision licensed only a few No Doubt songs, but if Little Johnny were proficient enough in Band Hero to get his avatar -- say, perhaps, a lasciviously alluring Ms. Stefani -- to reach Level Nine of Band Hero, he could unlock her and free her from the bondage of her current condition, in every way, including gender.No Doubt was most displeased to discover that, once your Gwen Stafani avatar were unlocked, not only could Avatar Gwen be singing Janet Jackson, she could also be singing Tito Jackson.You see, once unlocked, an avatar''s voice could be changed from male to female.Not surprisingly, Ms. Stefani and her bandmates were not excited about the prospect of having their voices replaced with the manly sounds of Boy George.Ska vs. SuitsCould Activision really use the twisted avatars without No Doubt''s permission?No Doubt didn''t think so, and the band sued Activision in California state court. In No Doubt v. Activision Publg, Inc., the band sued for injunctive relief and damages, arguing Activision had engaged in the unauthorized exploitation of No Doubt''s name and likeness.The band sued on several grounds, including Activision''s alleged violation of No Doubt''s right of publicity.The right of publicity gives an individual control over the commercial use of her name or likeness. About half the states have a statutory right of publicity and others protect the right of publicity as part of their right of privacy laws.There has been a movement to extend the right of publicity beyond death. Not surprisingly, this movement is led by the heirs of some very famous dead people, including the heirs of Marilyn Monroe.California is one of those states with a codified right to publicity, contained in section 3344 of the California Civil Code.However, Activision countered that No Doubt''s right of publicity claim was barred as a matter of law because Activision''s actions on the avatars constituted constitutionally protected activity under the First Amendment.A Los Angeles Superior Court judge denied Activision''s motion to strike No Doubt''s complaint, and Activision appealed to California''s Second District Court of Appeal.Citing Comedy III Prods., Inc. v. Gary Saderup, Inc., the appellate court applied the transformative use test, a method to determine whether a use of a likeness was transformed from something more than a mere impersonation.The appellate court sided with No Doubt and the trial court. The court ruled that a transgendered avatar did not qualify as a transformative use. Thus, the appellate court held, the First Amendment did not excuse Activision''s alleged violation of its right to publicity."Nothing in the creative elements of the Band Hero elevates the depictions of No Doubt to something more than conventional, more or less fungible, images of its members that No Doubt should have the right to control and exploit. Thus, the trial court did not err in denying Activision''s motion to strike the right of publicity claim based on Activision''s assertion of a First Amendment defense," Judge Thomas Willhite Jr., wrote for the court,The court compared and contrasted Ms. Stefani''s avatar with the image in another case involving a Sega videogame and the former lead singer of Dee-Light, Kirby v. Sega of Am., in holding Avatar Stefani was not a transformative use. The First Amendment may be powerful, but -- at least in this Case of the Week -- it provides no constitutional protection for a Gwen Stefani avatar in a Boy George voice singing, Do You Really Want to Hurt Me?_________________________Read more at the Washington Examiner: http://washingtonexaminer.com/blogs/opinion-zone/2011/04/law-gwen-stefani-avatars-band-hero-No-Doubt-v-Activision-Publ-Inc#ixzz1KUS9gVwHApril 17, 2011The Law of Urinal TrademarksTrademarks and the legal disputes involving them may be the most entertaining area of intellectual property law, and a recent Pennsylvania federal court case illustrates just how entertaining trademark fights can be. You might think this fight over the name, "Pint," was a beer dispute. You would be wrong.This week''s Case of the Week examines what happens when two urinal manufactures get into a legal dispute over the names of their products.Pint of Yellow LiquidThe urinal and its bathroom cousin, the toilet, use a lot of water. As people have become more concerned about the environment, manufactures have joined the party, developing so-called green products, and urinal makers are no exception. After all, no self-respecting urinal manufacturer wants to be known as a truck stop eco-terrorist.Among the leaders in the urinal market are Zurn Industries and Sloan Valve Co. Both Zurn and Sloan wanted to help save the planet by making eco-friendly urinals.Zurn developed a urinal Mother Nature would love and named it, The Pint. The U.S. Patent and Trademark Office awarded Zurn the United States Trademark Registration No. 3,389,517 for The Pint, part of Zurn''s EcoVantage line of environmentally friendly "fractional flush" urinals. They''re called fractional flush because they use a fraction of the water regular urinals use when you flush them.Not to be outdone, the nature-loving folks at Sloan came out with their own environmentally sound urinal, the Sloan 1 Pint Urinal System.Not unlike a fraternity pledge spotting someone swiping his pint of Guinness from the bar, lawyers for Zurn swung into action.Urinating ContestAfter noticing a Sloan press release for the Sloan 1 Pint Urinal System on the website, greenlodgingnews.com, Zurn''s lawyers sent Sloan a cease and desist letter, arguing Sloan''s name infringed on Zurn''s registered trademark for The Pint. Zurn demanded that Sloan stop marketing its allegedly infringing urinal with "pint" in its name.In an apparent attempt to maintain peace and harmony in the urinal world, Sloan changed the name of its urinal from the "Sloan 1 Pint Urinal System" to the "Sloan Pint Urinal System."It was a nice try, but Zurn was unsatisfied. Simply deleting the numeral, "1," from the name wasnt enough. Not unlike Carrie Nation on a bar raid, Zurn wanted the Pint the h*ll out of there.Sloan refused, and Zurn''s trademark lawyers did what it takes to become the Case of the Week. They sued.In its case, Zurco, Inc. v. Sloan Valve Co., filed in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania, Zurn argued Sloan''s use of its name violated the federal Trademark Act of 1946, known commonly as the Lanham Act. Specifically, Zurn argued that Sloan''s name caused a likelihood of confusion among potential customers.Sloan countered that -- despite Zurn''s federal trademark registration --The Pint was not a legally protectable trademark for a urinal because the mark was generic, a trademark legal term meaning the name is a common, general term with no secondary meaning.Sloan argued that pint was merely an identification of a type of urinal -- one that uses one pint of water when flushed. Thus, Sloan argued, urinal purchasers would associate the term, pint, with the flush volume of the urinal, not the maker of the urinal, Zurn.In attempting to decide the dispute between the fighting flushers, the federal court applied the so-called primary significance test, used in many cases, including A.J. Canfield Co. v. Honickman. Under the primary significance test, the court determines whether the primary significance of a term in the minds of the consuming public is the product or the producer.The court illustrated the difference by citing E.T. Browne Drug Co. v. Cococare Products, Inc., where the court made the distinction that cola was generic because it described a product, but Pepsi-Cola is not generic because it describes the producer.Zurn disputed the generic label by noting that, in the toilet and urinal industry, flush volumes are described -- not in pints -- but with the terms, gallons per flush (GPF) and liters per flush (LPF). In fact, Zurn claimed the use of gallon and liter by those other wasteful water-hogs in the toilet and urinal industry was precisely why it chose the unique term, pint.However, Sloan countered that pint had become an industry standard, noting that American Standard has used pint and 1 point since 2008, Mansfield Plumbing Products has used 1-pint for its Brevity line of urinals, and Caroma USA had used one pint for its Cube Ultra line of urinals for two years.Unfortunately for Sloan, the court noted that none of those urinal craftsmen had used the term before Zurn introduced the Pint in 2007. In addition, Zurn argued it had been diligent in sending cease and desist letters to the allegedly infringing urinal producers, a requirement for protection under trademark law.To Be ContinuedIn denying motions for summary judgment on most issues, the court held that there were genuine issues of material fact as to whether The Pint was generic. As a result, the case will move forward, and more evidence about urinals and what people call them can enter the hallowed halls of American jurisprudence.________________________Read more at the Washington Examiner: http://washingtonexaminer.com/blogs/opinion-zone/2011/04/law-urinal-trademarks#ixzz1K9cmh600April 10, 2011The Law of Chicken HeadsEmotional injuries and related damages may be one of the most contentious areas of the law, especially when -- as in thisweek''s Case of the Week -- that emotional injury is based on an employer''s forcing a worker to wear a chicken head mask in order to get medical benefits. Yes, this week, we go to Massachusetts to bring you the law of chicken head damages.Poultry ProblemsKaren Cappello worked full-time for Cricket Productions, where she processed orders. Because she was a full-time employee, she asked her boss, Victor Grillo Jr., for medical coverage.Mr. Grillo was very happy to give Ms. Cappello the medical coverage she desired, but it seems there was a catch.Mr. Grillo said Ms. Cappello could have the medical insurance only if she wore a chicken head mask."No head, no payment," Mr. Grillo wrote in an e-mail.We''re not making this up. We couldn''t come up with stuff this good.Even with major medical and hospitalization coverage for her young daughter on the line, Ms. Cappello declined to don the chicken head, which was part of a complete chicken costume kept in the office. You see, according to court papers, the employees at Cricket Productions considered themselves a fun-loving group that often socialized after hours.Apparently, none of the production place''s playful pranksters thought there was anything odd about making a session in the chicken head a prerequisite to health coverage.Ms. Cappello did.Saying she became too depressed to work as a result of the alleged harassment, Ms. Cappello sought medical attention and claimed she was unable to work.Of course, this is the Case of the Week, so you know what happens next.Colonel Sanders or Jack Daniels?Ms. Cappello decided to file a claim for her alleged injuries, and an administrative legal action ensued. Cricket carried no workers compensation coverage, but an administrative law judge held that, because Cricket was doing the business of DTR Advertising, Inc., DTR''s insurer, The Hartford Insurance Co., was liable for Ms. Cappello''s claim.Based on the opinion of her psychiatrist, Mark Cutler, Ms. Cappello argued Mr. Grillo''s alleged chicken head harassment was the predominant contributing cause of her adjustment disorder and major depressive disorder. The administrative law judge agreed and held for Ms. Cappello, but The Hartford appealed, arguing the chicken head incident was not the predominant contributing cause of Ms. Cappello''s alleged injuries.Hartford argued there could be other potential causes for the alleged injuries, and -- on appeal to the Commonwealth of Massachusetts Department of Industrial Accidents in the case of Cappello v. DTR Advertising, Inc. -- the judges noted that Ms. Cappello had received previous psychiatric treatment for issues related to a divorce and an alcohol-dependent husband.Ms. Cappello rejected the notion that marital warfare or her husband''s close, personal relationship with Jack Daniels and Johnnie Walker caused her injuries.It was all about that chicken head.Foul fowl?Because of her preoccupation with the perceived harassment at work and her disbelief that she was being asked to do what her employer asked her to do, which she perceived as very humiliating, she has been unable to return to any work for which she is reasonably trained by virtue of her education and job experience, Ms. Cappello''s psychiatrist told the administrative law judges.In a legal ruling sure to shock the San Diego Chicken, Mardi Gras revelers, and others who actually enjoy wearing chicken head masks, the judges sided with Ms. Cappello.Rejecting the insurer''s argument that there were other causes for Ms. Cappellos psychiatric issues, the judges ruled Ms. Cappello had shown those problems were not the cause of her present injuries. Although the judges conceded she had past psychiatric problems, they noted she had not experienced her present symptoms until the chicken head incident.The judges held that Dr. Cutler''s medical opinion satisfied the Massachusetts standard for predominant contributing cause of injuries established in the Massachusetts Appeals Court decision, May''s Case, and the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court decision, Robinson''s Case.In addition, citing Bouras v. Salem Five Cents Savings Bank, the judges held that, because Dr. Cutler''s opinion satisfied the predominant contributing cause standard, the chicken head incident was the only legal cause of her injuries."Because the doctor''s opinion effectively ruled out the previous stressors in the employee''s life as causes of her emotional disability, his opinion can be understood to implicate the events at Cricket Productions as the only cause," the judges wrote.The Massachusetts case of the chicken head was remanded to the lower judge on additional claims Ms. Cappello made, but she was victorious on this day...so was her lawyer.For their efforts on behalf of their client and for furthering the jurisprudence of chicken heads in the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, the judges awarded Ms. Cappello''s lawyer $1,488.30 in legal fees.__________________________Read more at the Washington Examiner: http://washingtonexaminer.com/blogs/opinion-zone/2011/04/law-chicken-heads#ixzz1J7TcDYNfApril 1, 2011The Law of April Fools'' JokesFor our April Fools'' Day edition of the Case of the Week, we visit the California Court of Appeal, which supplies us with a case touching on constitutional law, contracts, defamation, and, of course, the law of April Fools'' jokes. Not surprisingly, our case involves Sasha Baron Cohen, known popularly as Borat and Ali G.A 2004 episode of Mr. Cohen''s British television show got his network into a bit of trouble, and it had to pay the alleged target of his jokes $90,000. When the infuriated supposed subject came back for more, it ended up in American court, raising the question: could a reasonable viewer take the show seriously, resulting in a judgment for defamation?The Art of AmendingOn a 1987 youth trip to Israel, Sasha Baron Cohen began a friendship with a woman known only as "Jane Doe" in court proceedings. The friends lost touch over the years, but Ms. Doe followed Mr. Cohen''s increasingly successful career as a comedian, and, apparently, Mr. Cohen never forgot Ms. Doe''s real name.On the Aug. 15, 2004, episode of Mr. Cohen''s television show, Da Ali G Show, Mr. Cohen interviewed the American author, Gore Vidal. Among the topics of conversation were the United States Constitution and the practice of amending it.Mr. Cohen asked Mr. Vidal if it were not sometimes better to get rid of something rather than amending it. As an example, Mr. Cohen referred to Ms. Doe. Using her real name and referring to her with a term also used to describe a female dog, he said Ms. Doe was always trying to amend herself by such means as highlighting her hair, adorning herself with tattoos, and shaving her private regions.Mr. Cohen said Ms. Doe''s amending was for naught because he dumped her after he impregnated her. (Ms. Doe denied her relationship with Mr. Cohen was ever romantic or sexual in nature.)Given what Mr. Cohen claimed were Ms. Doe''s unsuccessful attempts at amending herself, he reasoned that amending anything -- including the Constitution of the United States -- was ill-advised.With no apologies to Vidal Sassoon, the people of the Eastern Hemisphere, or George Washington, in his role as Ali G, Mr. Cohen went on to suggest that Mr. Vidal was an internationally famous hairstylist, that euthanasia was a means of exterminating the elderly in Asia, and that Denzel Washington resided at Mount Vernon.Ms. Doe was not amused.Costly ComedyDa Ali G Show was produced by Britain''s Channel Four Television Corp. and distributed in the United States by HBO. After complaints from Ms. Doe, HBO settled with her in 2004 for $40,000. As part of the settlement, HBO agreed to edit the episode so Ms. Doe''s name would be removed in any future broadcasts.Well, Ms. Doe''s fame -- or infamy, depending on ones perspective -- continued. When HBO presented the episode on Comcast, it left Ms. Doe''s name in the airing of the show, resulting in another settlement with Ms. Doe in 2006 with the same terms as the 2004 settlement, except this time Ms. Doe received an additional $50,000 payday.Nevertheless, viewers of Da Ali G Show had not heard the last of Ms. Doe.When a friend of Ms. Doe''s saw the unedited version -- that would be the one with Ms. Doe''s name -- on YouTube after the second settlement, he contacted her, and they discovered a viewer in Estonia had uploaded the clip from Finnish television, which had received the unedited version from Channel Four.No more settlements. Ms. Doe decided to take her battle to court.The Law of April Fools''Ms. Doe sued HBO and Mr. Cohen in California state court, and later added Channel Four as a defendant. She sued on multiple grounds, including libel, slander, breach of contract, invasion of privacy, and negligent infliction of emotional distress.Channel Four moved for summary judgment -- a legal ruling where one side wins the case before it even gets to trial -- arguing, among other things, that no reasonable person could have understood Mr. Cohen''s statements as factual.The trial court sided with Channel Four."No reasonable person could consider the statements made by Ali G on the program to be factual. To the contrary, it is obvious that the Ali G character is absurd and all his statements are gibberish and intended as comedy. The actor, Sacha Baron Cohen, never strays from the Ali G character, who is dressed in a ridiculous outfit and speaks in an exaggerated manner of a rap artist. Ali G''s statements are similarly absurd," the trial court said.Ms. Doe appealed, but she fared no better with the Californi''s Second District Court of Appeal in Doe v. Channel Four Television Corp. Citing cases involving comedian Robin Williams and an April Fools'' joke, the appellate court agreed that no reasonable person could have taken Mr. Cohen seriously. Thus, the court held, there was no defamation.In the case involving Robin Williams, Polygram Records, Inc. v. Superior Court, California''s Third District Court of Appeal held there was no defamation when Mr. Williams did a skit where a wine distributor complained that there was white wine and red wine, but no black wine.The court noted Mr. Williams said the so-called black wine was tough enough to be advertised by Mean Joe Green, was black in color, tasted like urine, and went with anything it damn well pleased. The court added that no reasonable person could have taken Mr. Williams seriously and that to hold the skit defamatory would run afoul of the First Amendment.Likewise, in San Francisco Bay Guardian, Inc. v. Superior Court, California''s First District Court of Appeal held there was no defamation when, in its April Fools'' Day edition, the San Francisco Bay Guardian newspaper ran a fictitious letter from a landlord stating that he found his tenants who had undergone electroshock therapy where much more cooperative because no reasonable person would take the fake letter seriously.Today''s legal lesson is thateven if it involves an electroshocked tenant with shaved privates drinking black wineits tough to win a defamation action against a comedian.________________________Read more at the Washington Examiner: http://washingtonexaminer.com/blogs/opinion-zone/2011/03/law-april-fools-jokes#ixzz1ISyc57fbMarch 27, 2011The Law of Cantaloupes and Inflatable SharksHave you ever been really impressed by marketing displays constructed at your local store, where industrious employees create displays of commerce only slightly less impressive than the Taj Mahal?Well, Joyce Henderson may have felt that way before she broke her hip falling before a marketing temple of stacked cantaloupes at her local supermarket.Adding insult to injury, Ms. Henderson lost again in this week''s Case of the Week as the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Oklahoma grappled with the weighty issue of whether cantaloupes are the legal equivalent of inflatable sharks for premises liability purposes.Cantaloupes of DoomThe story of Henderson v. Harps Food Stores, Inc., began on a fine June day in 2009 when Ms. Henderson visited the Harps Food Store in Fort Gibson, Okla. Harps employees had created a display of cantaloupes, which was actually a giant octagon of wholesome, fruity goodness.Harps displayed the cantaloupes in large cardboard containers resting on a wooden pallet. The cardboard containers were roughly square in shape with the corners slightly recessed, forming the muskmelon octagon.Ms. Henderson admitted spotting the pallet beneath the pile, and even considered the pesky pallets potential as a pitfall. Nevertheless, she plowed ahead.While examining one of the succulently sweet cantaloupes, Ms. Henderson''s foot caught on the pallet, and she hurt her hip hitting Harps'' hard floor.The stage was now set for Ms. Henderson and Harps to debate the jurisprudence of cantaloupes vis-a-vis inflatable sharks.Ms. Henderson sued Harps in Oklahoma state court in a tort action, alleging Harps was negligent in its dangerous display of the killer cantaloupes and in its negligent failure to warn customers of its alleged fruity booby trap.Harps removed the case to federal court and filed a motion for summary judgment, arguing it was not liable because the exposed cantaloupe pallet was an open and obvious condition.Generally, under Oklahoma premises liability law, which applied even though the case was in federal court, businesses are not liable for damages sustained from these so-called open and obvious conditions. However, there is a possible exception in the law for conditions or defects visible but unseen by a plaintiff.Ms. Henderson and Harps battled over the case law. For instance, both parties cited the Oklahoma Supreme Court case of Phelps v. Hotel Mgmt., Inc., where an unsuspecting patron hit her head on a decorative glass bowl that protruded into the seating area of a hotel lobby.Sure, the thing was open and obvious in the literal sense, but the court in Phelps held a reasonably prudent person might not have noticed the risk of injury from the protrusion of funky art into the seating area and -- for the condition to be open and obvious as a matter of law -- the potential for injury must also be noticeable.The court in Henderson rejected Ms. Henderson''s reliance on Phelps and another court decision, Zagal v. Truckstops Corp. of Am., a case where things went horribly awry in the aisle of a truck stop. The court held those cases did not apply to Ms. Henderson''s case of the killer cantaloupes because -- not only did Ms. Henderson see the open and obvious collection of cantaloupes -- she knew it posed possible danger.However, all hope was not lost for Ms. Henderson. It was time for her lawyers to launch a legal shark attack.But could an inflatable shark really save Ms. Henderson''s case?Shark TaleMs. Henderson''s attorneys cited the Oklahoma Court of Civil Appeals case of Hansen v. Academy, Ltd., where Kimberly Hansen, an unsuspecting customer, was apparently in awe of a large inflatable shark that was part of a boat display on the sidewalk in front of an Academy sporting goods store.So mesmerized by the inflatable shark was Ms. Hansen that she proceeded to walk straight into the tongue of the boat, causing her to trip and break both her arms. Ms. Hansen sued Academy, but a trial court ruled for the sporting goods store, holding that the boat tongue was an open and obvious condition.But, remember...Jaws had a sequel.Ms. Hansen appealed, and the intermediate appellate court ruled for her. Noting an Academy employee testified the purpose of the inflatable shark was to get people''s attention, the appellate court reversed the trial court''s grant of summary judgment to Academy, holding that, although the boat tongue was visible, the plastic, air-filled fish of terror changed the legal outcome."The evidence certainly raised a question of fact as to whether Academy intended for its customers to devote their attention to the merchandise on display rather than to the sidewalk," the appellate court held in Hansen. Unfortunately for Ms. Henderson, U.S. District Judge James Payne wasn''t buying the shark argument in her case.Noting that arrows on the cantaloupe boxes actually pointed to exposed pallet on cantaloupe display, Judge Payne held the inflatable shark case didn''t apply."Because the cantaloupe display actually drew attention to the alleged hazardous condition, the Hansen case is distinguishable and does not provide an exception to the open and obvious rule," the judge wrote.The lesson of our Case of the Week? Apparently, at least in Oklahoma, a cornucopia of cantaloupes provides no exception to the open and obvious rule...but, an inflatable shark does._______________________Read more at the Washington Examiner: http://washingtonexaminer.com/blogs/opinion-zone/2011/03/law-cantaloupes-and-inflatable-sharks#ixzz1HonZsGj9March 13, 2011The Sixth Amendment and another Texas Chicken Ranchby David HorriganIn the film adaptation of the Broadway musical, The Best Little Whorehouse in Texas, Burt Reynolds, playing a Texas sheriff, falls in love with Dolly Parton, portraying the good-natured, warm-hearted proprietor of a local brothel. That theatrical house of ill-repute was based on a real life bordello known as the La Grange Chicken Ranch.Although many local residents supported the Chicken Ranch -- and the entertainment and tax dollars it brought to Greater La Grange -- its closing involved law enforcement at the highest levels of Texas government.For those whove always wanted yet another sequel, we have one for you. It doesn''t have Ms. Parton, Mr. Reynolds...or even Dom DeLuise. What is does have is an intriguing question of constitutional law, which is why it gets to be our Case of the Week.Texas cathouse jurisprudence now considers: Does memory loss render a witness absent for purposes of the Confrontation Clause of the Sixth Amendment to the United States Constitution?Before we get to any of that legal stuff in the case of Woodall v. Texas, let''s take a look at the story of the latest little whorehouse in Texas.Naughty HaremPhyllis Anne Woodall may or may not have a lot in common with Dolly Parton''s Best Little Whorehouse in Texas character, Miss Mona Stangley, but Texas prosecutors alleged they were in the same profession.Ms. Woodall was the co-owner and operator of the Naked Harem, an El Paso, Tex., establishment some would refer to euphemistically as a "gentlemen''s club." Ms. Woodall and her business partner, Jeannie Coutta, ran a strip joint empire, El Paso Cosmopolitan, which not only operated the Naked Harem, but also its sibling club, the El Paso Cosmopolitan Topless Show Bar.Sadly for the ladies and their clients, those Texas prosecutors thought they were having a little too much fun.After repeated incidents of alleged prostitution at the Naked Harem, authorities arrested the ladies, charging Ms. Woodall with aggravated promotion of prostitution and engaging in organized criminal activity.At trial, prosecutors called dancers who testified prostitution was plentiful at the club, while Naked Harem loyalists testifying for Ms. Woodall cited Naked Harem policy forbidding dancers from having sex with its gentile clientele. Ms. Woodall then called a dancer, Lucia Pinedo, to testify.It was a bad move.Forget Me NotMs. Pinedo testified she sustained memory loss after an automobile accident and that she could not remember her prior testimony before a grand jury -- nor could she remember even being part of the Naked Harem. However, when Ms. Pinedo didn''t show up for a subsequent day of the trial, prosecutors -- over Ms. Woodall''s objections -- read her grand jury testimony for the jury.Before the grand jury, Ms. Pinedo had testified she had sex with patrons many times in the club''s private rooms, and -- in an unfortunate turn of events for Ms. Woodall -- Ms. Pinedo testified that, although she lied about her age to Naked Harem staffers, she was only 15-years-old when she began dancing at the club. To make matters worse, Ms. Pinedo contradicted the testimony of one of Ms. Woodall''s managers who said Ms. Pinedo showed a birth certificate as part of her identification upon being hired.Instead, in a moment worthy of X-rated versions of High School Musical or Glee, Ms. Pinedo testified her identification to get her job as an exotic entertainer was not her birth certificate, but was, in fact, her high school ID card.As they did with the La Grange Chicken Ranch, the good people of Texas may turn the other cheek when it was just a bunch of adults having consenting, albeit illegal, fun...prostitution by 15-year-olds is a very different story.After prosecutors made numerous references to Ms. Pinedo''s impressionable youth during closing arguments, the jury sentenced Ms. Woodall to 16 years in prison.Ms. Woodall appealed, arguing, among other things, that introducing Ms. Pinedo''s grand jury testimony was a violation of Ms. Woodall''s rights under the Confrontation Clause of the Sixth Amendment to the United States Constitution because Ms. Pindeo''s memory loss prevented Ms. Woodall from being able to cross-examine her.Constitutional ConfrontationA Texas intermediate appellate court reversed the trial court and sided with Ms. Woodall, holding that allowing prosecutors to read Ms. Pinedo''s grand jury testimony to jurors despite her memory loss violated Ms. Woodall''s Sixth Amendment Rights because the State used out-of-court testimonial statements [the grand jury testimony] about which the declarant [Ms. Pinedo] could not be cross-examined due to memory loss.The state argued also that, because Ms. Woodall refused the trial judge''s offer to issue a so-called writ of attachment forcing Ms. Pinedo to return to continue her testimony, Ms. Woodall was precluded from arguing Ms. Pinedo was absent for Confrontation Clause purposes.However, Ms. Woodall argued that Ms. Pinedo''s memory loss made recalling her futile, and the intermediate appellate court agreed."She did not remember giving the grand jury statement, nor could she remember working at the Naked Harem. A writ of attachment would not have changed Pinedo from an absent witness into a witness available for trial and examination. Her undisputed testimony about the car accident and resulting memory loss established that she was unavailable as a witness regarding the relevant subject matter," the intermediate appellate court held.Yet, in another legal twist, on Mar. 2, the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals, the states highest court for criminal matters, reversed the intermediate appellate court on both issues.First, citing three U.S. Supreme Court decisions, California v. Green, Delaware v. Fensterer, and United States v. Owens, the Texas high court rejected the argument that a Confrontation Clause violation could be based on witness memory loss.Second, Ms. Pinedo''s memory loss notwithstanding, the court held Ms. Woodall''s failure to take the trial judge up on the offer to haul Ms. Pinedo back into court was fatal to her Confrontation Clause argument. The court said Ms. Woodard induced the alleged error of which she now complains, and she may not argue on appeal that her confrontation rights were violated.In the movie, Burt and Dolly went off happily into the sunset. It doesn''t look as though thats happening here._________________________Read more at the Washington Examiner: http://washingtonexaminer.com/blogs/opinion-zone/2011/03/sixth-amendment-and-another-texas-chicken-ranch#ixzz1HaDgOkKeMarch 6, 2011Labor, Lassie, and the LawIts been a tough week for the First Amendment and labor unions, but perhaps not for puppies.In this space, we attempt to look at the lighter side of the law, but there''s just nothing funny about a Marine making the ultimate sacrifice for his country or alleged followers of Jesus thinking the Messiah wants them desecrating other people''s religious services. However, Americas courts never let us down when we need comic relief, and free speech cases are no exceptionThis week, California''s Second District Court of Appeal ruled on a particularly perplexing constitutional quandary. It''s a question not yet addressed in the current labor unrest in Wisconsin:Does labor union speech enjoy greater constitutional protection than speech about puppies?Well give you the court''s answer in Best Friends Animal Socy v. Macherich Westside Pavilion Prop., LLC, in a moment, but let''s start off by saying that -- not unlike fallen heroes and violated funerals -- theres nothing funny about animal abuse or unfair labor practices. Nevertheless, what we''ve got here is an appellate court of law weighing the constitutional rights of terriers versus Teamsters.Puppies and PicketersThe Best Friends Animal Society does good work. Not only does the Utah-based organization have adoption programs for dogs and cats, it has programs for parrots and pigs as well. In addition, it operates an animal sanctuary, and its Pup My Ride program transports dogs from overpopulated areas to places where they are more likely to find homes.Best Friends also operates the Puppies Aren''t Products campaign with the stated goals of fighting against so-called puppy mills and irresponsible breeding.One of the weapons in Puppies Arent Products arsenal is the staging of protests at shopping malls where the evil puppy mills alleged middle men -- the pet shops -- attempt to sell their canine cargo.Although Puppies Arent Products bills its mission as a fight against the puppy mills, unlike more militant animal rights groups, Puppies Arent Products stresses the peaceful nature of its protests...a Gandhi for golden retrievers, if you will.Peaceful or not, one shopping center didn''t want to give the puppy protesters free rein over its establishment. When Puppies Arent Products targeted the Barkworks Pups & Stuff store at Los Angeles Westside Pavilion, the owners of the mall swung into action.Not unlike abortion protesters at a Democratic convention or anti-war protesters at a Republican convention, the puppy protesters were confined to undesirable areas -- in this case, mall space far away from Barkworks. Incidentally, Barkworks denies its dogs come from puppy mills, stating it takes great pride in having built a reputation of bringing healthy, happy puppies to loving families and homes.Look for the Union Label?Westside Pavilion had rules about when people could protest in its common areas. The rules applied to so-called noncommercial expressive activity, and covered various forms of expression, such as political and religious speech, soliciting for signatures on petitions, and the dissemination of noncommercial leaflets and fliers.The rules were what constitutional lawyers call content neutral, meaning the rules didnt vary depending on what a speaker was saying. There was just one catch.Labor unions got special treatment.The mall had special rules for qualified labor activity, which was defined, in part, as activity authorized by the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA) or applicable state labor laws.Non-labor expressive activity -- such as the puppy protest -- was limited to certain areas of the mall and was subject to certain blackout days, days when no protests were allowed, such as the busy business days of Valentines Day, Halloween, and the Christmas shopping season.In contrast, labor expressive activity had no blackout dates, and the workers'' expression could take place near the targeted, allegedly union-busting establishment.The litigating Lassie lawyers saw this distinction as the way to get the puppy protesters within pawsteps of the alleged villains at Barkworks.Collies in CourtBest Friends sued Westside Pavilion''s owners in California state court, arguing the mall''s restrictions violated the free speech provisions of article I, section 2 of the California Constitution. Specifically, Best Friends argued, among other things, that it was unconstitutional for the mall to give labor union protesters preferential treatment over the Puppies Arent Products protesters.Westside Pavilion countered that the restrictions passed constitutional muster and that the mall was forced to give labor union protesters special treatment in order to comply with state and federal labor law.The mall won the first round when California Superior Court Judge Linda Lefkowitz ruled against the puppy protesters, holding that, under the 1997 California appellate decision, Union of Needletrades, Indus. & Textile. Emp. v. Superior Court, the shopping mall was within its rights to limit the activities of the puppy protesters and that the NLRA and state law required the mall to make special accommodations for labor protesters.But, this dogfight wasnt over.Best Friends appealed and found a more fur-friendly tribunal in California''s Second District Court of Appeal. In a 3-0 decision on Mar. 2, the appellate court overturned Judge Lefkowitz, and ruled in favor of the puppy protesters.The appellate court rejected the holding of the case on which Judge Lefkowitz relied and instead followed two other California appellate decisions, H-CHH Associates. v. Citizens for Representative Government and Snatchko v. Westfield LLC, in holding the mall could not restrict the puppy protesters in the manner it sought, and it rejected the mall''s preferential treatment of labor protesters.The appellate court said the mall suggests that the law compels it to discriminate. But federal and state laws do not require shopping malls to give labor speech more access to common areas than political and other types of free speech.Celebrating its victory and the apparent end of Puppies Arent Products banishment to the dark corners of the mall where one wouldn''t expect to find Jennifer Grey, Best Friends issued a statement entitled, Nobody Puts Baby in a Corner.______________________________________________Read more at the Washington Examiner:http://washingtonexaminer.com/blogs/opinion-zone/2011/03/labor-lassie-and-law
84
English courses abroad and online courses | Saffron Walden English Courses Discover English courses of Saffron Walden in Great Britain and online, skilled teachers and study programmes for students, adults and professionals.
85
Study Medicine, Dentistry, Vet Medicine in Hungary – Study Medicine, Dentistry, Vet Medicine etc… in English in Hungary Medicine, Dentistry study in English in Hungary.Worldwide recognised degrees, state of the art learning facilities.
90
Dancesport UK - Dance Shoes, Apparel, Equipment & Accessories Supplier Online Britain''s first and favourite site dedicated to Ballroom and Latin American dancing
92
@bout ENGLISH.it: to learn English and discover the English-speaking countries An awarded site, created for students/teachers of English by an Italian teacher, to learn English language, literature, culture and to discover the English-speaking countries, such as Great Britain, USA, Australia.
93
Learn English with Oxford International Language School English classes in Oxford for adults, Summer Junior School for teenagers, accommodation and social programme. Small classes - maximum of 10 students.
94
Right From the Hip | Observations & Opinions | Politics, Law & Current Events In which our Vagabond Seeks a City in Motion. It is early Saturday evening, the doors are open, the coffee house beckons. I enter into a crowd – young and old, in pairs, groups and singles, are standing in line, checking their phones, reviewing the menu board, sitting astride chairs, leaning on counters, stirring their mugs, contemplating their next move, and conversing with animation and verve. After securing a mug of herbal orange blossom tea and plain pound cake (something different and contemplative), no booths are available. I occupy a seat at a long, central bench and table with the other patrons. Immediately next to me sits a young couple, face to face, wearing various shades of blue denim (she also sports a floppy, soft-brim robin egg blue hat), who have stopped talking to enjoy one of the house's calorie-generous desserts. Their desserts are laden with strawberries, fresh, fragrant, jumbo-sized, strawberries, tumbling generously, abundantly, off the dessert cakes which shyly peek out underneath. These are six-dollar desserts, suitable for serious courtship. The whipped cream had disappeared already. Their strawberries are not shy - they flaunt their bright deep red strawberry color, their inviting texture, they flirt their white edges. These strawberries profligately cast about their unmistakable ripe fragrance. Indeed, the fragrance demands attention. For an unmeasured moment, these strawberries own the bench and my perceptions – my other senses have quietly stepped down and wait for the strawberry fragrance to master the stage, to take its bows, to aromatically speak for strawberries everywhere. Each strawberry is joined with all strawberries - connected in a web of genetic code, agricultural pedigree, sense perception and idea. The smell, the fragrance and appearance of these strawberries, and for a distinct slice of time, the connected picture, the taste, the idea of many strawberries, all strawberries, as an adjective as well as a noun, occupy my thoughts. If there had been no name for strawberries ever given, I would have conjured a name for them, then and there. Strawberries are versatile. We can give Latin names to their various genus, Fragaria. We may note that each apparent achene, or seed, on the outside is actually one of the ovaries of the flower, with a seed inside it, perhaps explaining why the couple beside me ordered them for dessert. Philosophers might debate whether or not there exists a non-physical essence of strawberry, an ideal Platonic form of strawberry, or be skeptical that we could ever be sure that what we perceive as strawberry was reliable. Mischievous children have picked them to throw at each other. We can observe them on wild vines, clip, transplant and cultivate them in our gardens, study what combination of sun and water gives them the greatest growth and sweetest flavor, pick them gingerly to set at our breakfast table, eat them singly or in groups in little morning fruit bowls. We have financed agri-businesses to grow them in vast number, might someday sell strawberry futures on a commodities exchange, have hired agricultural workers to pick them in mass quantity. Graduate students in economics might measure the economic impact of establishing a minimum wage for strawberry pickers, while employers make certain their immigration papers are in order. We can contest the right of strawberry pickers to go on strike, and use courtrooms to enjoin secondary strikes by other fruit pickers. Independent truck drivers can transport them in refrigerated, insured freight carriers at free-on-board rates. District managers of supermarket chains can offer them for retail sale in little green baskets at trendy supergrocers which have memorable advertising logos and trained-to-be-friendly checkout people, and serve them in coffee houses at upscale prices. In laboratories we can measure their molecular carbon chains, forensically identify them with gas and mass chromatography, and fit them into biochemical schema of study. We can mash them into lipstick or cream for purposes of skin and beauty enhancement, advertised by slender, photogenic models. We can handwash our dirty dishes in our neglected kitchen sinks, or shampoo our thinning hair with liquid soaps flavored with them. No small series of achievements, for an aggregate accessory fruit. But we have strawberries as descriptors also, as concepts and additions to the language in which we think and speak and describe, in which we write poetry and love sonnets. They act as triggers or stimulants, to remind us of things, things we may want to remember. I bend my head over my tea and soak a piece of my cake into my orange-blossom tea. But these strawberries are not yet done their work. The fragrances of my coffee-house neighbors' strawberries trigger vivid memories. A series of pictures is summoned up, interior miniatures composing a sequenced event in my life, a road trip of an altogether different sort. Gently unfaded, affectionately insistent, parading in silence one at a time yet making a whole, a set of gliding images from the past paints over my vision. ____________________ My wife, Erma, and I were dating, and engaged. I was just 32. At the time, she was just 23 years of age, not quite 5'2" unless she stood on her tiptoes (she was generous in describing her height on various health and application forms), slender, lithe, with quick, athletic reflexes, light brown hair never allowed to grow long, a bright upturned face full of energy, green-grey eyes that were never quite the same shade from day to day, and a stand-your-ground manner suitable for the youngest child who had five older brothers. Erma had been a Christian since her experiences as a teenager in church youth group, and had been well taught by a beloved senior pastor, Reverend Pusey. She could field a ground ball or steal third base, tell every player on the Philadelphia Flyers in 1977 (she still had a Bobby Clark doll) or quote scripture by memory, intelligently and to the point under discussion. She was a secretary at DuPont, a job she had held since the day after she graduated from high school. There was emotional trauma in her childhood, including a miserable relationship with her father (the misery shared by her brothers and sister), and a tragic gun accident which took the life of one of her brothers, after her father irresponsibly brought home a rifle and gave it to his children without supervision or safety instruction. The collapse of the family unit brought economic difficulties. Erma bubbled over with hope and energy – she was ready to wrestle wildcats, hid her fears, counted her pennies, and laughed loudly and easily. Erma pooled shock, grief, loss and anger in reservoirs of her soul. She introduced herself to a pair of young men attending a Christian singles conference in Sandy Cove, Maryland, one of whom was me, because she recognized the church my friend Dave had announced at the beginning of the conference, and that was enough of a conversational opening for her. We took a trip to North Carolina, to visit her brother Noel, the only one of her family to graduate from college. Noel was a marketing manager for a large agricultural chemicals company, and he was moved about the country every few years. For several years he had lived near Research Triangle Park outside Raleigh. Our trip was a happy one; we packed up Erma's silver Honda Civic, years old but running like a Swiss watch, and toodled down the highway one Monday in the early summer. Life was opening up. My disorderly life, spread across two coasts, was moving in a good direction. Erma, deeply emotionally cautious, was hoping that the world held good things as well. After staying the first night with friends in Virginia, we arrived after a day of easy driving at Noel's, still single. As always, he was a gracious host, owner of a sensible but well-maintained home. His practice of buying and selling homes as he was transferred around the company proved to be economically rewarding. I don't know whether he liked his job in its own right, but years later when he was offered a retirement package at the age of 50, he took it, and to my knowledge, has never worked 9-5 job since. Noel was working 9-5 when we arrived though, so during the day we were left to our own devices around Raleigh, Chapel Hill, Durham and the surrounding areas. Open to guidebook suggestions, we went to the North Carolina Botanical Gardens in Chapel HiIl. We walked the displays of native plants, violet-purple iris, milkweed, wood anemone, maidenhair ferns, wild indigo, water-plaintains, bluestars. The Gardens have a display of carnivorous plants, pitcher plants, Venus fly traps, along with their orchids and lilies. I found a very tiny spider among the carnivorous plant displays, picked him up with a leaf, and deposited him into a Venus fly-trap, which promptly, as advertised, closed its tender petals. The wispy trigger hairs of the plant quite quickly formed a bars-of-a-jail cell effect as the plant's leaves closed reflexively – I could see the tiny spider, looking out, as forlorn and puzzled as any prisoner would be. At the time, I had nothing to say to him, and regretted somewhat causing his fate. With the advantages of hindsight and advancing years, today, I might encourage him with words of sympathy – "you and me both, brother," a final salute, issued nunc pro tunc. Erma and I went to see a movie in the evening. Mr. Hulot's Holiday. Monsier Hulot, the French actor Jacques Tati, "decides to vacation at a beautiful seaside, resort. Rest and relaxation don't last long, given the gangly gent's penchant for ridiculous antics." Released in 1954, you have to be in the right mood to see this slapstick farce. Erma and I were nearly alone in the theater, it was a Tuesday evening. We were in the mood – I laughed hard. Erma laughed uproariously, full volume. I never heard anyone laugh so hard – her cackles filled the theater – no nook or cranny escaped the piercing volume of her laughter. Many times. How can you not fall in love with a girl like that? If anyone else was in the theater at all (maybe one other couple), they certainly knew they weren't alone. The next day, we visited Duke University in Durham. The lawns and grounds were green, immaculate, carefully maintained; the buildings, the Chapel, all were elite-college campus beautiful. I daresay visiting parents longed to expend vast sums of money to send their children there. After walking around for several hours, near the end of the day, we found a small restaurant/coffee-shop. Because of the day and hour we were again nearly alone. The shop featured a strawberry desert, loaded with whipped cream. They were the freshest, sweetest, most flagrantly-and-fragrantly-delicious strawberries imaginable. It was a lifetime trophy desert. The taste, the aroma of the strawberries filled our noses, our palates, our tongues – our sweet, ripe taste buds went off like bells. Erma was just swooning with joy. It seemed as if we just sat and ate for hours (which could not possibly be true), as if the strawberry dessert stopped local time to go on forever. These strawberries had royal, domestic, South American and continental antecedents. According to Wikipedia, the garden strawberry was first grown or bred in Brittany, France in the 1750s by crossing Fragaria Virginia from eastern North America with Fragaria Chiloenses, brought from Chile. The French began harvesting wild strawberries in the 14th century. Strawberries were added to cream in the Court of King Henry VIII. What can I add to that? World production of strawberries is in excess of nine million tons, and not a strawberry too many. After we had spent a few days at Noel's, we drove east to go to the Outer Banks of North Carolina. The Outer Banks are a resort area, but wilder, less cultivated than the homogenized resort areas one sometimes visits. We rented two separate hotel rooms to stay in the area around Kitty Hawk. I had sexual relationships prior to becoming a Christian. Erma had many dating relationships, but had learned her sexual ethics as a teenager at a conservative, evangelical church and drew a line she believed in. We did not sleep together on that trip. It helped to make our dating relationship simple, clean, pure, uncomplicated. (Our physical relationship began on our honeymoon - when Erma exited the bathroom and entered our bedroom the evening of our 11 a.m. wedding in Bear, Delaware. We had driven to a bed and breakfast in Milford, New Jersey, Linda and Rob Castagna's Chestnut Hill on the Delaware River. Looking at the teddy-bear decorated bed and room in the honeymoon suite and at me, Erma asked, "do you think we should pray?" I answered, "I already have.") But that wedding ceremony day was still in our distance, like a beckoning city on a hill. The next day on our excursion to North Carolina, we traipsed about on the Kitty Hawk beach. It was not yet warm enough for swimming; the beaches were nearly empty. I discovered that small fish, mullets or small kingfish, filled some of the deeper surf pools and beach ponds left by retreating waves. There is a picture of me taken by Erma, bending over at the waist, looking down, with my pants rolled up as I stood in the middle of one of these surf pools, wearing a plaid shirt with the sleeves rolled up, trying to catch little silver fish with my bared, cupped hands. Trying to catch small fish by hand was a predictably unsuccessful effort, but loads of fun to try. I looked perfectly ridiculous, and we were perfectly happy. On our trip back in the silver Honda Civic from North Carolina, driving north to Wilmington and Phoenixville, we sang hymns on the road. Neither Erma or I have any musical talent at all - neither of us can carry a melody. But there was no music critic in the car, no one to be distressed. We sang "Fairest Lord Jesus," in toneless acapella - it fit our mood and excursion well. _______________________ I was interrupted in my coffee-house reveries by a young man, of Asian background, whose face I recognized, but whose name I didn't know. He had been listening to me a previous week, when I was proclaiming out loud verses from the Book of Revelation, the lake of fire verses, the judgment verses, on a previous morning when the coffee house was much emptier than it was that Saturday evening. His interruption lead into quite an extended discussion, carried out over three locations in the coffee house. "Hello," he said. I responded with my own 'hello.' "I saw you here the other week. You were reading out loud. I was standing over there" – he indicated where he had been standing when I had my brief confrontation with the coffee house manager, Jen, over reading Bible verses out loud. I nodded 'yes' and offered my hand and introduced myself. "My name is Qi," he introduced himself with a small but perceptible bob of the head. His English was good, with a slight British accent. Qi looked to be in his early twenties, fifty years younger than I. His hair was black parted on one side, his chin and cheeks clean-shaven, his eyes brown, his lashes somewhat long, his build slim, probably 5' 10" in height and weighing 140 or 150 pounds, wearing blue jeans and a neat maroon pullover jersey. His facial expression was respectful, intelligent and friendly. "I wanted to ask you. Why were you reading out loud? And why did you choose those verses?" I had to think to recreate my thoughts and mood the previous week. "I can't answer that easily. God moves inside me without giving me explanations. Why those verses? I felt like I wanted to get somewhere - we ought to get somewhere. I saw those verses on the path." "I heard what you said to the manager. The owner doesn't mind?" His expression suggested that people reading out loud in a coffee house crossed a line in the culture he came from. "No," I told him, "the owner doesn't mind." We paused our conversation for a moment, so Qi could find a way around the bench and people to squeeze in opposite me. He was sitting right next to the strawberry-eating couple, also seated across each other on the bench, as I was. "Do you work, or are you a student?" I asked. Qi explained his background to me, responding to my questions. He was 23 years old, a graduate student seeking a Master's degree in statistics from the graduate department of a nearby university. He was an exchange student, a resident of China, whose family came from near Beijing. Much of his life was not spent in China however. His father was an investment banker, and they spent a number of years in different countries and cities, including London, where he learned as a teenager to speak English well, and learned his slight but discernible British accent. He was one of three children, and had two sisters, one older, who was married and living near Shanghai, and one considerably younger sister, who was living at home near Beijing, where his parents had returned. I asked him about China's one-child policy and he explained that his father had sufficient resources to obtain relief from the rule. Since the first child in the family was a daughter, apparently this exception was not difficult to obtain with respect to Qi. Having official sanction for having a third child was more difficult, but by then his father had political and economic connections. By this time the strawberry dessert-eating couple had left. Their seats were taken by others so it wasn't always easy to conduct our conversation. The coffee house was noisy, there was music in the background and people were sliding behind us at times to reach seats further down the long benches on which Qi and I were seated. When I paused my deposition-like questions, I asked if he attended any local church. He did, he explained, and had been for about a year. "What did you think when I read those verses out loud?" I asked. "How did you react?" "I like hearing the Book of Revelation read aloud. It doesn't often get read out loud. When you hear a sermon, somebody tells you what to think about it. There's always a doctrine or a system. Everything has to be explained." He thought for a few moments. "There's more in the words, than there is in the explanations." He said, and I quietly nodded in agreement. "Well, if you just listen to the words, read by somebody else, you wouldn't have a system," I offered. "You might have a language, though. A set of mutual symbols. Even if we didn't agree on what they meant." He listened to what I said and we talked about language, and symbols. His criticisms of symbolic language were well-thought out; a person whose native tongue is Chinese understands well the strengths and weaknesses of symbols to communicate. I suggested that symbols and graphic pictures cut through many language systems. The phrase "a woman clothed with the sun," eludes precise rational understanding, but it's an accessible image everywhere. We had the mutual and considerable pleasure of two people speaking thoughtfully to each other. "You don't agree with any systems about it?" I asked, meaning the Book of Revelation. "I don't know. My church teaches a system." "Which one is that? Dispensationalism? Premillennialism?" "Yes." "The Rapture, any minute. The Jews left to face the anti-Christ." "Yes. Yes." "You're not defending it very hard," I suggested. His facial expression indicated that I had discerned his feelings accurately. "Is that what you believe?" Qi asked me. "No. I'm a Postmillennialist. I believe in the Great Commission. Christ gave us an order. Go into the far reaches of the world. Convert the nations. So we will succeed. It's the prayer he taught us. 'Thy Kingdom come. Thy will be done.'" "How does reading about the burning lake of fire out loud, help that?" Qi queried. "I'm not sure. Does the Spirit have to explain everything to me? I respond as I'm called. But I think everybody wants good news. Ask them, and they'll tell you the world is a mess. But then they want good news - warm and reassuring. God's judgment in a burning lake of fire is a very unpopular topic. But it wakes people up. It made you ask me questions." "Do you think bad news is more likely to win converts?" Qi was looking at me with a certain amount of respectful skepticism. "I think telling people the truth helps people see the truth." "But you, too. You didn't recite the burning lake of fire verses with a big smile on your face." "Perhaps so. Me too," I admitted. "Maybe there's enough bad news already," Qi suggested. "Sufficient unto the day is the evil thereof. That's true too. You're right. But why are all those burning lake of fire verses there? Fierce warnings, aren't they?" I asked rhetorically. "Maybe it's the bad news that already exists. Maybe the world loves judging. Maybe the world needs judging. There's a lot of judging inside of us already." As he said this, I thought I detected some personal history in Qi – perhaps his father was a judgmental person. "I think it's a warning - a guide and a look to the future. But I'll be careful about trying to interpret it, with you around. I'll let the words be the words. Burning lake of fire and all." I raised my hands slightly to indicate surrender – the acknowledgment of my limitations. "Don't some people believe the whole book was just meant for the 1st century Christians? They think it all relates to the destruction of the Temple in Jerusalem by the Roman armies. That's it – nothing else." Qi's knowledge suggested some study; his tone suggested questions, perhaps questions deeper than interpreting the Book of Revelation. "Are you a preterist?" I asked him. I wasn't sure whether his question was a narrow, specialized question over eschatology, or rather a deeper question that any young person might have, about whether the whole structure of religion is connected to anything real at all. "I'm not sure what that means," he admitted. "About what you said. Preterists believe most of the Book of Revelation has already been fulfilled. It was a warning for the 1st century, for the early church. A tract for the times. Now it's done – it has no future significance," I explained. "If that's what you're asking." "No, I haven't thought about it much, but don't think I think that. How about you?" Qi asked. There were questions in this young man, but I didn't know quite what they were. "I think it's prophecy. The Word of God to us. It's no more fulfilled and done than the Sermon on the Mount is fulfilled and done. Does that answer your question?" I returned. "I guess we'll never know, this side of Final Judgment," he offered. "Maybe we just wait for the Rapture?" "It makes a difference now. It changes how we act, because of what we expect. If all you're doing is sitting around here, waiting for the Rapture, that's one kind of answer. But I'll buy you a cup of coffee, and we can wait together." As I was about to get up to buy coffee, a young woman, talking to her friend following behind her, was trying to make her way behind the bench to a seat. She was holding a sandwich on a plate and a glass. Someone moved on the crowded bench, not knowing anyone was behind him, and bumped directly into her. Her sandwich spilled and tumbled across the back of an unshaven but pleasant-looking blonde young man and onto the floor. There, visible for the world, near Qi's feet, were the ingredients for her sandwich, two slices of multi-grain bread, two chunks of avocado, two generous slices of tomato, and a large stack of bean sprouts, scattered across the floor along with a slice of dill pickle. She moved back apologetically, waving the now-empty sandwich plate in her hand, obviously embarrassed. The young man stood up, rather mildly and saw who had spilled sandwich fixings on him. He didn't seem angry - he was apologetic and rather embarrassed himself. No one quite knew what to do. For a few moments the two of them milled about each other in rather disorganized fashion. The coffee house manager was nearby. She saw what had happened and signaled for a staff person to assist. Qi and I both stood up to move out of the way and sidestepped our way to leave the benches and table. As we were moving, I made brief eye contact with the manager and we mutually and quickly nodded. I didn't want her to think I had been a problem again, but she saw I was an innocent bystander, not an repeat instigator of disturbances. While the clean-up was being accomplished, Qi, seeing our mutual nod, asked if I knew the coffee house manager. "Yes, her name is Jen Geddes. She's a Christian. She's nice – a calm person." We watched the cleanup. I thought I would share a bit more, thinking still about what Qi's questions might be. "Years ago, she was in the newspaper, picture and all. She had a bit of a temper. I think she came from a very fundamental background. She was in a church, and for whatever reason, something was going with a visiting pastor she definitely didn't agree with. She expressed her theological disagreement by shouting out loud, picking up a stool, and heaving it at this visiting pastor. She actually hit him with it and there were disturbances in the church. The police had to be called. As a sentence I think she got what is called ARD, a non-trial diversion. It usually means she had to do some community service and get some counseling. I was practicing as a lawyer at the time, so I paid attention. Some years later, she got the job here. I recognized her when she started. Very calm - very welcoming to everybody these days. I never talked with her about it. I always wanted to ask her what it was about. Part of it was reported in the newspaper – apparently, whatever it was the visiting pastor was saying, her response was along the lines of "are you really going to say that, in my ear?" The cleanup was over, but Qi and I found a different place to sit and resumed our conversation. He wanted to know more about the type of law I had practiced, which was a general community practice. We started talking about the law and about the U.S. Constitution and some well-known constitutional principles, which were not, as Qi described, the rule or norm in China. He described a culture and circumstance in China which might be characterized as intense and ubiquitous favoritism. "We have those problems here - in a big way," I acknowledged. "You have laws about it, though. In China, there is no law to appeal to, to correct such things. The party is the law, and the party officials who operate without needing any approval." "We do have laws," I acknowledged. I narrated for Qi a United States Supreme Court case, which is a staple of the Constitutional Law curriculum in law school. "In San Francisco, around 1880, most of the laundry workers were Chinese. Laundries used heat in wooden buildings. There was a statute that said you couldn't operate a laundry without a permit. The statute itself wasn't crazy - there was a genuine fire risk with boiling water used in the laundries – not a joke in San Francisco. But Yick Wo had been operating his laundry for years, when he was told he couldn't operate his laundry anymore without a permit. Unfortunately, if you were Chinese, you didn't get a permit. If you weren't Chinese, then you got one. Yick Wo was fined for operating without the permit, and he couldn't or wouldn't pay the fine, so he was put in jail. The Supreme Court ruled that the administration of that permit law was unconstitutional – even if the laundry owners weren't citizens. Even if the law itself made sense considered in isolation. The Chinese laundry owners still had a right under equal protection, under the equal protection laws of the 14th Amendment." "You would not find such laws in China," Qi lamented. "Well, it took us years to take the legal principle serious," I told him. "Taking your principles seriously takes time." Our conversation continued. We talked about Chinese coolies and how they worked. We talked about Christianity in China. We talked about the beginning of the movie Crazy Rich Asians where they're having a Bible study. We talked about missionaries and Hudson Taylor and the Chinese Inland Mission, and when Qi's family had become Christians. We talked about wars in Asia – in the Pacific against Japan. Qi had a very distinct opinion about the treatment of the Chinese by the Japanese in WWII, which flowed over to his opinion over disputed islands in the South China sea. We talked about the wars in Korea and Vietnam. We talked about Mao, and Communism and the treatment of Christians in China during the cultural revolution. Qi's family had suffered and practiced their faith in secret, but had emerged. We talked about the Three-Self Church in China. "Sanzi Jiaohui" Qi explained, trying to help me to pronounce it correctly. "But my family has spent so much time overseas, it was not critical to us. We didn't argue about religion, we argued about how many hours my father worked." He looked not as happy making this last statement. I decided to change gears altogether. "You'll be married someday. You'll have a wife and probably children. Do you have a girlfriend?" I asked. "Yes. But she is in graduate school in Michigan now. So I only get to see her on vacations. Sometimes we meet in Chicago. We are making some plans, but they have to wait. We text. She likes it, but she thinks it's cold there." We talked about the weather in China, and in the U.S. We moved our location one more time, when a booth opened up. Time passed, but the Rapture still lay in the future. In the meandering talk and silence of our time together, we made friends. The Holy Spirit, as known to coffee houses as He is to great cathedrals, entered somewhere. Eventually Qi said it was time for him to get back home, and we parted company with the idea that he would be back in the coffee house, and we would have a chance to talk again. Perhaps further, on the Book of Revelation, he suggested. ___________________ And in the Spirit he carried me away to a great, high mountain, and showed me the holy city Jerusalem coming down out of heaven from God. Revelation 21:10. Those trained in theology and ministry should present the bulk of the inspired message of Rom. Ch. 12-15. But there is an element of those passages I want to address. I have a law degree, was valedictorian at law school, have practiced law for many years, and have held elected office. I serve as a volunteer on various boards with legal and executive authority over substantial matters. The business of law and government is something with which I am familiar. Although words like "law and government" don't sound San Francisco hippy-ish, don't seem to blend into a coffee-house or a road trip to the last chapters of Revelation, that is my direction now. Rom. 13:1-10 is my topic. Everyone must submit himself to the governing authorities, for there is no authority except that which God has established. Rom13:1a. The passage is central. It does not stand for, nor should it be understood, to be a command to political authoritarianism. It is an invitation to law, to legitimacy, to ascertaining the will of the people in a democracy, enacting that will within the confines of a constitutional system, and then respecting the laws that flow therefrom. Within the world at large, we may be subject to, or may become the governing authorities – but we are always Christians. The Apostle Paul had multiple purposes in so writing – he had a concern with the relationship of Christians to the outside world and to the political authority of the Roman empire. Paul was also concerned about how Christians relate among ourselves. Christian religious/political conflict among ourselves has been a challenge for Christian theology. Theological disagreement may be the reason or the excuse for the ecclesiastical, political or social separation of Christians. Once reasons develop, theological disagreement, leading to differing communions and groupings, becomes the vehicle for separation. As the Reformation commenced and continued through the 16th and 17th centuries, it appeared the immovable object had met the irresistible force. When Christian conscience met Christian government in vehement disagreement, the results were tragically unacceptable in individual cases. Theologically, the issues have never been resolved. One person wishes to pray to the saints, another does not, one expects an early Rapture with no warning, another does not, one thinks the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Father and the Son, another does not. There are innumerable such differences. The continuing disagreements demonstrate that we have no recognized method of either resolving the dispute, or even a recognized method of staying in communication with each other. The argument continues unresolved. The fallback position for various Christian disputants is spiritual distance and intentional distancing, and attrition over time. Politically, we have addressed the most negative consequences of those 16th and 17th century conflicts by privatizing religious conscience. The results of privatizing Christian conscience are only partially satisfactory, as the 21st century is demonstrating. Organizing a better society is problematic, if each Christian has no greater loyalty than to his or her conscience. Conscience slides into self-will. Beyond denominational or theological boundaries, no one is able to present, to debate, to respond, to adjudicate, to give, or to obey an order issued by a recognized body of Christians, on any issue – not just very large important issues. All issues are 'off the table,' as it were, beyond joint resolution. No one could today post 95 theses on the door of a church and have an audience. We are stalled on Christian conscience-autonomy. No one says 'my conscience is God' but that is the net result. Each spider sits on her own web. The Old Testament analogue is the Book of Judges. The civil and political theory and authority that God has established pertinent to us, and to all, has been two thousand years in the making. The development of this theory is an argument for and an example of common grace, extended by God to all, who makes his sun to shine on the good and on the evil, and sends his rain on the just and on the unjust. "All peaceful beginnings of government have been laid in the consent of the people," John Locke, the British philosopher wrote in his Second Treatise on Government, Sect. 112. His work was instrumental in the framing of American constitutional ideas. Within the United States, we are both the governed, and the governing authorities. Perhaps odd, perhaps obvious to say, but if we as Christians want to reach the heavenly city of God, we have to be capable of governing and being governed by each other. This does not suggest extinguishing the ordinary and necessary debate and contentions that accompany civil and religious life. But at some point, a methodology of decision-making has to be established. Decisions are to be made, and they have to be respected. These 'decisions' are Christian decisions, critical to the communications and communal life of all Christians. That is not intended as a challenge to fundamental theological positions. When our government formed, Maryland did not become Pennsylvania – each state assigned certain powers to a federal government, and retained the rest. Lawful is not lawless, even where there is hard questioning and debate over what is really or ought to be 'lawful.' There are many different ways to connect with each other in the exercise of our Christian faith. Our movement toward the Jerusalem from above is obstructed, if we are situated like a collection of hermit crabs, each communion barricaded in its own shell of theological position, ecclesiastical organization and personal conscience. The authorities that exist have been established by God. Rom. 13:1 b. God created and enables all things, in providing the motive power for all events, outside of whose permissive will nothing ever can happen or could happen. Such establishment includes "the authorities that exist." As Jesus said to Pilate, "You would have no power over me if it were not given you from above." God is the source of lawful authority. The present state of world and national affairs, including our legal and political structures, is not accidental. It may be temporary, or cause us to pray "How long, O Lord, will the wicked by jubilant?" But if we cannot obey our own lawful authority, exercising decisions derived from faith, there is no possibility of building a genuinely lawful structure. If we cannot debate our Christian statements, decrees, findings or laws, enable and enact our Christian decrees, respect or obey our Christian laws, because they come from the authority already announced and ordained by our God and Savior, we're not going to move. We are stranded in the valley of stasis. I am postmillennial, a believer in the Kingdom of God that comes into this world. The extension of Rom. 13:1 b is necessary. This verse sends us forward, makes us look to the future. The current set of authorities have been established by God. The next set of authorities will be established by God - and the next set, after that. We want this set of authorities, each set of authorities, to be better, more Christ-like. When we say more 'Christ-like,' it is not reasonable to expect that denominational and theological differences are going to evaporate. We want to be Christ-like as we assume, or obey, or exchange, this developing authority which expresses itself in constitutional forms among us - not because it results in theocracy or theonomy (or any other system of being ruled by the laws of the Old Testament). Rather, we remember that the "authorities that exist" may be us, or may not be; and if we're not holding office at the moment, we may retain our theological positions or political differences. Do unto others as you would have them do unto you, has special significance when we are talking about different groups of Christians contending over beliefs, ideas, or courses of conduct which may be supported and advanced by force of decree, statement or law. If we are going to move toward a more complete Christian community, theological convictions count, inspiration counts, but also, impartiality counts. We want the debate (and the penalties for losing the debate on whatever topic is at hand) to be just and impartial. The rules, the conduct, the doctrine, whatsoever it is under discussion, and the statement or law that issues from them, or us, are to be impartial. The means and procedure of discussing, debating, challenging or appealing the decision regarding the resolution of Christian issues, have to be impartial. Due Process is a legal term but it paves a spiritual road. It means notice of the issue at hand, before the time and place of decision, and the opportunity to be heard on the point by the decision-makers. We hope valued impartiality flows into our political and national lives. But whether it does or does not flow nationally, we have to communicate these exchanges and accord this due process among ourselves in an impartial manner – and then voluntarily respect the outcome. The amorality of the present state of our national political life is not ultimately acceptable, but neither it is acceptable to go back to the political situation, rife with religious persecutions, that characterized Great Britain (and here in New England) in the 17th century. We do not criminalize people with whom we disagree. We will not move toward a golden, millennial age until we capture solutions to both sets of problems – spiritual unity which enables voluntary association and cooperation, and spiritual dissent. Our risen Lord Jesus has set us a mid-term examination. God has graciously provided us guidance. As explained by Locke in his Second Treatise, sect. 131: And so whoever has the legislative or supreme power of any commonwealth, is bound to govern by established standing laws, promulgated and known to the people, and not by extemporary decrees; by indifferent [impartial] and upright judges, who are to decide controversies by those law; and to employ the force of the community at home, only in the execution of such laws; or abroad to prevent or redress foreign injuries, and secure the community from inroads and invasion. And all this to be directed to no other end but the peace, safety, and public good of the people. The peace that Jesus confers - "Peace I leave with you, my peace I give unto you" (John 14:27), connects to this Lockean peace, safety and the public good. The kingdom of God ("Thy kingdom come," Jesus taught us to pray, Mat. 6:10, "on earth as it is in heaven.") and "the leaves of the tree are for the healing of the nations," Rev. 22:2, converge on this peace. They are intended for this-world Christian implementation, and this implementation and obedience to God's will is not beyond us. John Locke described the "peace, safety and public good of the people" in terms that were attainable. He presented his solution at the time of intense religious persecution that frequently was the excuse, rather than the reason, for political persecution. The experience of the Amish community in self-regulation provides some useful guidance. The Nashville Statement, signed initially by more than 150 evangelical leaders, affirming what is set forth or implied in Scripture about sexuality, particularly Romans ch. 1, is a productive step toward our self-regulation and our movement toward a Holy City. The Nashville Statement engendered disagreement and resentment. Nor do I endorse all views, on all issues, of those Christians who developed the Nashville Statement. The point is to cooperate as actively and as far as we can, but no further. Theological statements and decisions are presented to address conflicting positions. The resentment within large elements of our national society, of the Christian position on the sexual issues addressed in the Nashville Statement, is intense – but that is acceptable. Disregard of God's Word engenders its own consequences. We want to be frog-marched off the Titanic of modern secular culture and nominal Christianity - thrown unceremoniously into a little lifeboat named Jesus and the Bible. We expect to be marginalized with the world's imprecations following, as the Titanic leaves us behind. We may bob in the ocean of broad societal disapproval for a short season. It's not hard to see the iceberg coming. After the iceberg has done its work, we, the Christian community, build a better world. We may communicate our own internal understandings and direction without surrendering those theological positions which are essentially non-negotiable. John Locke calls out the following elements in the above-recited passage: legislative power, established law, impartial judges, a judicious use of 'force' to execute such laws, directed to peace, safety and public good – and we would add, for the community of our faith. The challenge is to connect that political peace, of which we are clearly capable, with Jesus' spiritual peace. The alternative, the Valley of Christian Stasis, is incapable of being characterized as good faith. That is not how the Book of Revelation ends. To disconnect the two kinds of peace, to say that the peace that Jesus provides is always and forever not of this world, is to take a position on eschatology. That is to take the position that the Kingdom of God is not coming (despite praying "thy Kingdom come") in this world except by the visible return of Christ but in no other way. It is to take the position that the Great Commission does not fully succeed (apparently, then, a command to partial failure?). It is to take the position that the ending of Romans ch. 16 ("so that all nations might believe and obey him") doesn't count. If the Kingdom of God is coming in this world, then those good ends that John Locke asserted - peace, safety, the public good - have to be realized in the context of a multitude of Christian expressions (the 'Seven Churches' of Revelation), giving rise to our City in Motion. The political events of the last two thousand years include what has politically taken place in this country in the last 250 years. We may begin with the Deist-influenced proclamation of the Declaration of Independence (which, despite its Deist influences, repeatedly and insistently invokes God, the Creator, the Supreme Judge, and Divine Providence), which is also directly of God. The Declaration of Independence, like all other expressions of common grace, is directed by and under the authority of our risen Lord, Jesus. Pilate's authority derived from Roman military and civil power gets the benefit of God's imprimatur, as spoken by Jesus. Then surely also so does the Declaration of Independence, the U.S. Constitution, and the Federalist Papers. We have political tools. We need to use them. We don't want to supplant the state, we want to create a miniature of a Constitutional and legislative system, for ourselves, entered into by three gates: by Christian faith, by subscription to the doctrine of Scriptural inerrancy, and by a commitment to a forward-looking eschatology. Beyond that, once through those gates 'of the outer courtyard,' we acknowledge a diversity of views, a gathering of seven churches, a lively exchange of ideas. We will make and find our city and move toward peace, joy, and the enjoyment of the presence of God, characterized by our love for God, and our love for each other. There, we will be in a position to lead useful and interesting lives and have enjoyable and interesting discourse. We do not resurrect the past, look to the past, long for the days of ancient Israel, look for theocratical forms of government, or long for the days when our particular theology will be adopted by everyone. Christianity is just beginning. "By calling this covenant new, he has made the first one obsolete. And what is obsolete and aging will soon disappear." Heb. 8:13. The orchestra is just tuning up - we're barely getting started. I have no use at all for nostalgia. To quote a modern theologian, Greg Bahnsen: Postmillennialists believe, therefore, that the kingdom of God will gradually grow on earth, visibly, publicly, and externally. . . It will grow through the gradual conversion of the nations – through the preaching of the Word of God. . . . This salvation of many people must have visible expression and influence and be seen in an outward culture in society. (Victory in Jesus, Bahnsen, CMP 1999, p. 27). (See also, Postmillennialism, an Eschatology of Hope, Keith A. Mattison, P&R Publishing, 1999; The Victory of Christ's Kingdom, John Jefferson Davis, Canon Press, 1996; Prophecy and the Church, Oswald Allis, Presbyterian and Reformed Publishing, 1978 (critique of dispensationalism); He Shall Have Dominion, Kenneth Gentry, Apologetics Group Media, 2009 (thorough defense of postmillennialism); and An Eschatology of Victory, J. Marcellus Kik, Presbyterian and Reformed Publishing, 1971) ("the Holy City is situated in time and history . . . " p. 245). (Noting also with all these authors, that their theology is learned, their eschatology is inspiring, their legal and political theory needs better direction.) Consequently, he who rebels against the authority is rebelling against what God has instituted, and those who do so will bring judgment on themselves." Rom:13:2. Paul instructed Christians in the Roman Empire, where we began as a tiny minority. Stay out of trouble, direct your energy away from rebellion, stay away from political revolt or disobedience. Move in our spiritual life and the witness to the growing faith. Paul was concerned about building the church locally and across geographical distances and cultural groups. It was the Holy Spirit saying, "it's okay to obey the Roman authorities – in fact, you should, this is part of your obedience to me, unless (as is clear from the Book of Revelation), you are being asked to deny Christ or otherwise blaspheme." Christ warned his disciples to stay clear of the military and political disaster coming because of the Jewish rebellion brewing against Roman authority in his pointed discourse at the Mount of Olives. In whatever direction we decide to move, it must meet the fundamental standards enunciated by Paul. For rulers hold no terror for those who do right, but for those who do wrong. Do you want to be free from fear of the one in authority? Then do what is right and he will commend you. For he is God's servant to do you good. But if you do wrong, be afraid, for he does not bear the sword for nothing. He is God's servant, an agent of wrath to bring punishment on the wrongdoer. Therefore, it is necessary to submit to the authorities, not only because of possible punishment, but also because of conscience. That is also why you pay taxes, for the authorities are God's servants, who give their full time to governing. Give to everyone what you owe him; if you owe taxes, pay taxes, if revenue, then revenue; if respect, then respect; if honor, then honor. Rom. 13:3-7. Christian, don't do the crime, if you can't do the time. The bearing of the sword is intended for punishment. The state has a monopoly on the use of force, for a good reason. Generally, Christian conscience acts in conjunction with the state (but not always, see, e.g., Martin Luther King's Letter from a Birmingham Jail). In his Letter to the Romans, Paul meant a number of different things by 'the Law,' understood by context: the Ten Commandments, the Law of Moses implying a special revelation of God's will to the Jews, natural law available to and applicable to all people, spiritual law to be followed by Christians out of obedience to the gospel, the law of love, Roman civil or criminal law to be obeyed at the risk of punishment, the law of conscience, including accusations or defenses of conscience, the law of interior struggle with sin, sin and death itself, and the new life of the Spirit - all are referenced in Paul's letter, all characterized in his writing as or associated with the Law. The Law shows us our sins by holding up a mirror to our conduct in the light of God's Law, sending us to call on Christ's atoning mercy. The Law protects the weak from wrongdoing at the hands of those stronger and is essential to a civil society. The Law in all its forms and expressions is surely the great chain, wielded by an angel, which binds Satan in Rev. 20:1 and 2. As the Holy City comes down out of heaven as described in the 21st Chapter of Revelation, it is not described as the City of Law. By implication, the City may be protected by Law. Law may reinforce its walls and its gate. Spiritual law may flow from and through the Church to separate those who may enter the City of God from those who may not. But the Holy City's light, foundations, jewels, gates, streets, river, fountains, or its Tree of Life are not described in terms of Law. In the Sacred City of divine and human joy, where Christ reigns by acclamation, by love and by power, the purposes of the Law have been fulfilled. Lawlessness has no place in the City as it can never enter in. The Abyss may be escaped, only to give rise to further battle and fire, but the Holy City is prepared as a bride. The description of the Millennial City calls us to something higher, further and more perfect than Law as a goal and end of human society. The Law has a purpose and an end, and it reaches fulfillment in Christ's work on the Cross. In a more perfect society, where equity is done everywhere, there is no need to petition a court of equity for relief. Where love and trust are more perfect among people, no judge is needed to assert jurisdiction, hear argument or rule for one party or the other. In a meeting with our beloved, we who love fold our papers, close our law books and put our contracts aside. Their purpose has been served. Love keeps no record of wrong, so we may leave the courtroom. We go to meet for a wedding ceremony and a feast. The beauty of the meeting calls us to travel the road. Questions arise about doing right, what obedience means, in a Constitutional democracy where we are asked to play a part. The part we play nationally, whatever it is, to which we are also called and from which we refuse to be disenfranchised, is not the same as the spiritual movement we pursue among ourselves. We are called to something higher than the surrounding political confrontation and factionalism (not an easy problem to solve; see Federalist No. 10 – Madison thought the danger of factionalism would be solved by the new Constitution, and clearly that has not been the case). John Locke thought the solution was self-evident. "[F]or nobody has an absolute arbitrary power over himself, or over any other, to destroy his own life, or take away the life or property of another. . . Thus the law of nature stands as an eternal rule to all men, legislators as well as others. The rules that they make . . . must be conformable to the law of nature, i.e., to the will of God . . ." 2nd Treatise, sect. 135. To say something must be conformable to the will of God, or the law of nature or an eternal rule, has proved to be guidance not so obvious, beyond the first application, of not destroying life. Many Christians are united on this point at least. Given the number of abortions being performed annually in the United States and western world generally, even Locke's standard of 'not taking away life' appears to have given way to a notion of personal rights that is practically unlimited in its scope or application. In the case of abortion on demand, the notion is tragic on a massive scale, leads to infanticide (and the purposeful abortion of Downs' syndrome babies), is contrary to God's will, is destructive of our national political fabric, and presents an irresistible temptation to federal courts to exceed their Constitutional jurisdiction and intended scope of authority. Next to the Dred Scott decision, Roe v. Wade is the worst decision ever made by the U.S. Supreme Court, and its consequences have been destructive. The decision raises political problems regardless of religious faith – there is no serious legal question of any type that cannot be formulated into a query about individual rights and then answered in such a way as to make individual rights (defined to assure the preferred outcome) preempt and supersede any other type of right. In the case of abortion, all that is necessary is to deny the definition of human life to children in the womb. The definitions decide the outcome. When we now use the term 'civil rights' the meaning is – rights of the individual. In current judicial reasoning, advancing individual rights is always expansive of the good, as long as the individuals are out of the womb. In current judicial reasoning, the rights of the group are nearly always oppressive, subtracting from the net benefit of civil society. My civil rights cannot be added to the civil rights of my fellow citizens, in such a way as to develop a society promoting religiously-based ethical views. One hundred thousand people may not be lead in prayer at a government-sponsored or funded event, if one objects. If it is necessary to justify protecting children in the womb from destruction by making a religious argument, because the definition of the beginning of life implies theological and ethical reasoning, then the destructive consequences of advancing individual rights above other rights are wrongly justified as compelled by the implied language of the Constitution. An intellectual shell game has been played by our federal judiciary, of which Roe v. Wade is the most notorious example – get the definitions right, set up the conflict as the individual vs. the group (included in 'the group' is any assembly of state legislators) – and the desired judicial result will pop out like candy from a dispenser. From this Christian's viewpoint, and I am also a citizen of this nation, this is unacceptable. As an individual, my name is not "Congress," as in the 1st Amendment ("Congress shall make no law"). The idea that ethical decisions, which result in law, may not have religious foundations, is to be rejected. The idea that I may not join with others to vote for or to pass laws which at some point in their chain of reasoning, rely on religious belief or revelation, is to be rejected. A method of judicial reasoning which relies on carefully-crafted initial definitions and nomenclature to avoid the obvious, observable acts of medically terminating life, with the resulting infant body parts available for marketing, is to be rejected. Political acts which have ethical foundations, which themselves have religious foundations, are ordinary acts of Constitutional self-rule, not the establishment of a theocracy. We will do better, because God will compel a better result. The City of God is a promise to seven churches, standing for a society of communities engaged in the voluntary worship of God and obedience to Christ. Discovering the will of God, in our own relations with other Christians, raises harder questions than challenging bad national law or opposing abortion on demand. Discovering God's will mean moving forward to our own better self-governing society, even if we construct a model first on a 'table-top,' as it were. I quote a passage from Locke which will have a familiar sound to any reader familiar with the Declaration of Independence: Great mistakes in the ruling part, many wrong and inconvenient laws, and all the slips of human frailty, will be born by the people without mutiny or murmur. But if a long train of abuses, prevarications, and artifices, all tending the same way, make the design visible to the people, and they cannot but feel what they lie under, and see whither they are going; it is not to be wondered, that they should then rouse themselves, and endeavor to put the rule into such hands which may secure to them the ends for which government was at first erected . . . 2nd Treatise, sect. 225. Locke observed that the people may "rouse themselves." Indeed, 'rousing ourselves' is essential. But in what way did the Apostle Paul view 'rousing ourselves?' The difficulty with Paul's passage in Romans ch. 13:3-7, is its static nature. Those admonitions made sense then, for a small religious minority in a vast pagan empire. The Roman authorities were there, and the Roman Christians submitted to them, and were grateful to God for the opportunity to worship him in peace. There was no political development implied; it was intentional separation from Roman interference, by giving no cause for offence, for purposes of Christian religious practice. A difficulty with the passage of Locke cited above is that it takes the matter one, but only one, drastic step forward. If the authorities are inflicting a "long train of abuses . . . all tending the same way" then the people ought to put "the rule into such hands as may secure to them the ends for which government was at first erected." Locke's concepts are binary, but they also will become static – either the people accept the "great mistakes and wrong laws without mutiny or murmer" – or, as the American people did in 177 6, they "rouse themselves" to "put the rule into such hands, etc.," in other words, to put governmental rule into American hands in the legislatures of the American states. Continuing, aspirational movement was not contemplated by John Locke either. The wasn't the problem he was facing 320 years ago, but it is a problem we are facing now. There is much the Book of Revelation does not do. There is one thing it does do, beyond its powerful encouragement in the face of persecution – it says, 'look, there's a goal here, a destination, and we want to get to it.' The Book has an end, and the end is a City. The Great Commission is equally dynamic – Jesus telling us "Go, make disciples." There's a goal here, a command, something we are supposed to be doing – and disciples, discipling and discipline has to extend to more than personal conscience, to the exclusion of Christian community. The argument against amillennialism is parallel to the argument against premillennialism (whether in its dispensational presentation or classical presentation) – those doctrines don't go anywhere. When it comes to Revelation ch. 21 and 22, these doctrines 'sit on their hands.' Rather, our doctrine of eschatology is postmillennial (Christ comes after ("post") the millennium) by our voluntary choice, by Revelation's destination, by inspiration of the Holy Spirit to reach a millennium in this world. Jesus is awaited at the end of the golden, millennial period, however long and wonderful that period may be, a thousand years or a ten times a thousand years – and we have acted in obedience to him in making or moving to such a society and such a world. (For the Kingdom of God will be like a man going on a journey, who called his servants and entrusted to them his property - one to receive five talents, one to receive two, another, to receive one). Our goal is forward. Neither John Lock or the Apostle Paul, or Jesus, say: "let's go back to an Old Testament theocracy as soon as we have a chance." Hence, my profound disagreement with all forms of political theocracy, theonomy, etc. We move to the future here, in terms of our political understanding – our Lord Jesus has not been asleep for the last 2000 years. For that matter, if you need open-heart CABG surgery as I did, you will not seek out a doctor who applies the methods of healthcare available in the days of Moses – there are no instructions in the Old Testament for a triple-bypass procedure. Common grace has done something with respect to medical care, as it has done something with respect to political theory which the churches may apply. After the passage quoted above about obeying the authorities, the Apostle Paul moved directly, with no further transition, to a society characterized by love that has already internalized the Law. The movement is sudden between Rom. 13:7, extolling obedience to external Roman authority, sharing neither political power or a faith with us, to Rom. 13:8. Here is our endpoint: Let no debt remain outstanding, except the continuing debt to love one another, for he who loves his fellow man has fulfilled the law. The commandments, "Do not commit adultery," Do not murder," "Do not steal," "Do not covet," and whatever other commandment there may be, are summed up in this one rule: "Love your neighbor as yourself." Love does no harm to its neighbor. Therefore love is the fulfillment of the law. If we wish to go On the Road now (and we find ourselves On the Road whether we wish it or not) – static conceptions will not do. We construct with the law in the manner of a homebuilder, using our tools to lay on progressively wiser and more effective structural elements, until we reach the fulfillment of home-building, a home where we may love. That is the postmillennial vision – a millennial world, a golden age of faith, love and peace, before Christ returns. The thousand years of the millennium in Ch. 20 is both a reality and a symbol for that vision. The reality of God's ordaining will is a driving movement. Growth through the Holy Spirit is neither limited to or circumscribed by the symbol of a thousand year time period. We travel to an end and a society good beyond words. Our driving force and our destination comes from God. Golden ages are hard to come by, but not only can we get there, we will. Christ has called us to this, and his sobriety and his power in doing so is beyond question. ____________________________________
97
History revision for GCSE, IGCSE, IB and AS/A2 History | Mr Allsop History – GCSE History, IGCSE, IB and AS/A2 history revision podcasts for Modern World courses, history resources and history lesson ideas for school teachers and students at KS3, KS4 and KS5. GCSE History, IGCSE, IB and AS/A2 history revision for Modern World history courses, history resources and history lesson ideas for school teachers and students at KS3, KS4 and KS5.
98
Home Page The Paddington Rifles; The reign of George III; the reign of George IV; the reign of William IV; Bute; Chatham; Grenville; Rockingham; the American War of Independence; the impact of the French Wars on England; Pitt the Younger; John Wilkes; Eighteenth Century English History; Peel; History; Social History; Nineteenth Century History; Irish Affairs; Political Personalities in the Nineteenth Century; Economic History; Sir Robert Peel British Politics, Society, Personalities and Economics in the age of Sir Robert Peel. A resource for students of English History; Trevor Bloy; florida; condo rental; Indian Shores; Florida condo; holiday in Florida
100
Bob O''Hara - Public Record Searches at the National Archives Bob O''Hara is an independent researcher of Military, Genealogical and other public records at The National Archives, Kew, UK. He conducts research for genealogists, historians, students, authors and academics and lives next to The National Archives building at Kew.